Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Asian Americans should engage legal architectures—it’s critical to challenge transnational structures of vioence---spills over to challenge immigration exclusion and deportation of undocumented people—coalitions are valuable

Gee, 17—attorney, previously served as an Attorney with the Office of the Federal Public Defender in Las Vegas and Pittsburgh, the Federal Defenders of the Middle District of Georgia, and the Office of the Colorado State Public Defender (Harvey, “Asian Americans and the Law: Sharing a Progressive Civil Rights Agenda During Uncertain Times,” 10 DePaul J. Soc. Just. 1, dml)

The November election of Donald J. Trump as the 45th U.S. President heightened ever-growing concerns about a retrenchment of civil rights for Americans, 2 limiting voting rights, invoking tougher criminal penalties, 3 keeping Guantanamo Bay prison open and returning to aggressive interrogation techniques, 4 mass deportations 5 and stricter immigration laws. 6 Immigration holds particular relevance for Asian Americans because the majority of Asian Americans are foreign-born,7 and they along with Latinos, are among the fastest growing immigrant groups in America.8 This immigration stream shows that immigration has never been a white/brown issue even though mainstream America tends to think of immigration as an issue only affecting Latino/a immigrants. 9 On the contrary, immigration law and historical exclusion have shaped the Asian American legal and political identity within the existing U.S. racial hierarchy: whites on top, African Americans on the bottom, and Asian Americans as somewhere in-between.

The majority of Asian Americans have been identified as immigrants or children of immigrants.1 0 Asian immigrants from Asian countries face the longest backlogs for visas.11 The perennial connection between race and immigration comes up often. historically and as seen and felt in last year's presidential election, race and immigration status have enhanced the unpopularity of immigrants who have become scapegoats for the nation's economic troubles.

Critical race theorist Ian Haney Lopez answers that the efforts to seal the borders allowing no one to come into this country combined with arguments about the issue of illegal immigration has nothing to do with an immigrant's racial background are disingenuous because they share "deep similarities with racial hysteria that accompanied the mass deportation of Mexican Americans during Operations Wetback in the 1950s, and the Asiatic Barred Zone that prohibited all Asian immigration through the first half of the twentieth century." 12

Many citizens in the waiting, including 1.3 million Asian American undocumented immigrants 13 were hoping that that immigration reformers would happen during Obama' s presidency, those hopes were dashed when a deadlocked Court last term in United States v. Texas left in place the nationwide injunction barring implementation of the Deferred Action of Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents (DAPA) and expansion of the 2012 Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which would have provided deportation relief for up to four million unauthorized immigrants. 1 4

As this past election cycle, along with continued debates over affirmative action, immigration, police brutality, and reports of hate crimes, demonstrate, this country is far from existing in the "post-racial era" that was proclaimed by some pundits when Obama, this country's first African American President, was elected into office eight years ago.

Against this backdrop, it is imperative that social coalitions for justice continue to band together during these uncertain times. To be sure, despite the cultural and class differences and the potential conflicts and impediments that have arisen, African American, Latino, and Asian American civil rights groups have joined together to preserve affirmative action and immigration, to support lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender ("LGBT") issues; and to advocate for criminal justice reform and against mass incarceration. Perhaps not widely-known, these issues are key components of the Asian American civil rights agenda, which has gradually expanded to accommodate the most pressing issues that affect communities of color and subordinated individuals. As this Article discusses, the past few decades of coalition building between African Americans, Latinos, Asian Americans, and others offer reasons for some optimism about future possibilities notwithstanding a Trump Presidency, a Republican-controlled Congress, and Department of Justice led by Jeff Sessions which could translate into immigration policies and guidelines targeting immigration violations, speeding up deportations, and limiting federal funding to cities refusing to cooperate with the Department.1 5

This Article suggests that given the unique place that Asian Americans are situated in race relations in the U.S.-a racial group situated between black and white-they can inform the struggle for social justice, which has never been binary. This Article draws upon the interdisciplinary areas of social science, critical race theory, and Asian American legal scholarship to explore the manner in which Asian Americans are treated differently form other racial groups, which as seen in affirmative action, same-sex marriage, and criminal justice, can inform litigation and community activism strategy. Professor Eric Yammamoto calls this, "critical inquiry into the interplay between law and racial hierarchy." 16

Far from being a single monolithic voting block holding a particular perspective on important social issues. Asian Americans are a diverse community made up of many ethnicities, holding divergent opinions. For instance, there are Asian immigrants who are against affirmative action, same-sex marriage, and do not agree with the Black Lives Matter movement. These conservative Asian immigrants are deeply insular, and deny the existence of racism, unless it affects them. These Asian Americans act of self-interest, and do not work with other Asian groups or communities of color in fight for social justice. But there are also more assimilated Asian Americans, who may have familial ties span a generation or more in the U.S., willing to work together with others seeking fairness and social justice for all, regardless of skin color or sexual orientation.

While divergent views arise on the many social and political issues amongst Asian Americans, this Article is limited to a discussion of three topical issues: (1) affirmative action; (2) same-sex marriage; and (3) police brutality. I have chosen these issues because there have been recent Supreme Court decisions and recent litigation concerning them.

This Article is distinguishable from existing scholarship about Asian Americans and the law because it connects three areas of civil rights litigation that are rarely discussed together, or at least in relationship to Asian American advocacy. Far from being an academic discussion applying theories to hypothetical parties in the abstract, this Article anchors itself in Supreme Court cases, trial court litigation, and advocacy by real people at the grass roots level.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.