The impact is legal violence- deportability is a direct form of violence imposed by the immigration regime with drastic material consequences on the lives of students- focusing on immigration policy avoids rendering the student as the object of study while allowing for improved understanding to form their own relationship to structures of power
Jeffries 14 (Julian, Department of Reading and Literacy Education, CSU Fullerton. "Fear of Deportation in High School: Implications for Breaking the Cricle of Silence Surrounding MIgration Status" Journal of Latinos and Education, 13)
In the case of one particular immigration raid, both immigrants and the general public got a strong glimpse of the “spectacle of enforcement” (De Genova, 2004, p. 177) of immigration law: In 2007, a total of 361 workers, mostly mothers, were arrested in a factory in the town of New Bedford, leaving 113 children without parental care and producing significant hardship and stress for the people involved (Capps et al., 2007), their relatives, and the community. The television footage of children crying for their mothers and the desperation of family members in newspaper reports resonated in the minds of undocumented migrants, authorized migrants, and citizens alike and plays a major role in the creation of a sense of deportability. Thus, fear of deportation is a powerful presence in the everyday lives of not only adults but also youth and the school personnel serving them. In looking at how administrators treat the issue of migration status in school, it is important to account for the effects these deportation policies have on the daily routine of a school.
The policies that contribute to the fear of deportation are linked to the growing national and international sense of deportation as being the only response to undocumented or unauthorized migration: “It has come to stand in as the apparently single and presumably natural or proper retribution on the part of the state powers to this apparent ‘problem’” (De Genova & Peutz, 2010, p. 1); furthermore, it is normalized as “uneventful, familiar, and legal as individuals come to understand it as ‘the law’” (Menjivar & Abrego, 2012, p. 1414). The effect of immigration is to make visible what scholars have called the “spectacle of enforcement.” As De Genova (2002) described in the “Border Spectacle,” the intensification of military control at the U.S.-Mexico border (Dunn, 1996; Heyman, 1991; Jimenez, 1992) serves not to stop the so-called flow of migrants but to create the “theatre of an enforcement crisis” to render undocumented migrants as distinctive national and racialized “illegals” (p. 439). In a similar fashion, immigration raids in Massachusetts, such as the one in New Bedford, create a public image of an illegal subject and contribute to the distinction between legal and illegal, belonging to this country or not. This illegalization fulfills the intended goals of deportation policies not to physically exclude migrants from the nation state but to include them socially under “imposed conditions of enforced and protracted vulnerability” (De Genova, 2002, p. 249), “pushing them outside the boundaries of jurisdiction [while] simultaneously includ[ing] them by criminalizing their presence” (Menjivar & Abrego, 2012, p. 1403). This study highlights how the conditions of vulnerability and a fear of deportation affect the educational experiences of these youth in high school by honing into their relationships with teachers and administrators and the consequences for educational success.
This study draws from recent scholarship that calls for a shift from studying undocumented migrants as an ethnographic object, as a group whose characteristics need to be described and acted upon. Undocumented populations do not constitute, as such, “an objectively or intrinsically self-delimiting domain for anthropological study” (p. 422), as the term only constitutes a vague descriptive mechanism to represent what is truly a heterogeneous population (De Genova, 2002) with a wide variety of national and regional backgrounds who have different experiences of migration and a variety of contexts of reception. What they do have in common is that they are, most important, migrations that have been tacitly attracted by labor demands (Chavez, 1998; Hondagneu Sotelo, 2001)—or in the case of Central American countries, expelled by a U.S.- induced civil war (Menjivar & Abrego, 2012). In this way, the undocumented students I observed for 4 years do not constitute the sole object of study; the focus is to make visible how laws and policies that produce their illegality have an effect on their daily lives (Jefferies, 2014). In this study, the aim is to bring to light the ways in which immigration laws and deportation measures affect the successful navigation of high school of undocumented youth by describing their communication with teachers and administrators in the context of a school.
THE CONSEQUENCES OF DEPORTABILITY IN THE DAILY LIVES OF UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS Deportability is the “specific vulnerability to arrest and spatial removal, as well as linked legal penalties, such as the loss of rights to future ‘legal’ immigration” (Talavera, Núñez-Mchiri, & Heyman, 2010, pp. 166–167). This term refers not to deportation itself but to the constant possibility that one might be apprehended and deported. It acknowledges that undocumented migrants who have never been deported experience this phenomenon and that it has a powerful presence in their everyday lives (Coutin, 2000; Talavera et al., 2010) and drastic material consequences. Some of these are well documented in the literature, such as the transformation of everyday normal activities (like driving, taking public transportation, working) into illicit acts (Coutin, 2000; Heyman, 1998); limited physical mobility (Coutin, 2000; Hagan, 1994; Rouse, 1991); and the nullification of kin ties, as some undocumented migrants cannot petition for the legalization of relatives or leave the country to visit relatives and may even be separated forcefully from relatives (Coutin, 2000, p. 32; Heyman, 1991), among others. This fear and sense of vulnerability affects the way immigrants perceive their current place in U.S. society and affects the way they interact with educational institutions. In Jefferies’s (2014) description of the school enrollment practices of undocumented youth and their families in Massachusetts, fear of deportation played a strong role in delaying eligible youth from enrolling in K–12, forcing them to choose work over education, and delaying and sometimes barring them from enrolling in school.
Menjivar and Abrego (2012) also described the impact of the recent immigration regime on the lives of migrants but did so using the framework of legal violence. Heeding Mary Jackman’s examination of violence, they recognized that some kinds of violence escape attention in society, especially when this violence is “motivated by positive intentions, or is the incidental by-product of other goals, or is socially accepted or lauded” (Jackman, as cited in Menjivar & Abrego, 2012, p. 1383). Focusing on Central American immigrants in Phoenix and Los Angeles, the authors analyzed how the convergence and implementation of immigration and criminal law constitute forms of what they termed “legal violence”: the normalized but cumulatively injurious effects of the law: Legal violence is at once structural in that it is exerted without identifiable perpetrators, and it is symbolic in that it is so thoroughly imposed by the social order that it becomes normalized as part of the cognitive repertoire of those exposed. Importantly, this type of violence is legal, sanctioned, and legitimated through formal structures of power that are publicly accepted and respected. (p. 1413) With this lens, the authors unearthed the psychological, material, and economic effects of these polices that create social suffering in the implementation of the legal system for not only immigrants with tenuous immigration status but also their families and community. For example, the authors described the distress that young migrants experience in schools when they must interact and share information with gatekeepers and school officials whenever they disclose their status: “unsure about teachers’ and counselors’ stances on immigration, they worry about being publicly targeted and ridiculed” (p. 1409). This distress diminishes the chances of students seeking the help they need, severely blocking their paths to higher education. This kind of violence is a direct side effect of the immigration regime in place but goes under the radar and is legitimated through formal structures of power.
Dreby (2012) detailed the consequences of deportation policies for children, families, and communities in New Jersey and Ohio, showing how families are ripped apart as children are forced into foster care and how these policies create the conditions for mostly males to be deported, leaving behind single mothers struggling to provide for their families. In a clear example of how symbolic violence acts to normalize social relations imposed by the immigration regime, the author reported how children who are citizens are afraid of the police and begin to associate all immigrants with illegal status, attempting to “disassociat[e] themselves from their immigrant heritage” (p. 3). In this way, the lens of legal violence allows one to denaturalize the immigration regime and document its violent effects in the everyday lives of undocumented youth in schools.
RESEARCH ON UNDOCUMENTED YOUTH Within the variety of experiences and backgrounds of migrants, undocumented youth occupy a special place within the policy of immigration, with more guaranteed access to some spaces in society than their adult counterparts because of the Plyler v. Doe mandate, with more “legal protections” (Abrego, 2006), and in a situation of what Gonzales (2011) has called “suspended illegality” or “semi-protected status” (p. 608). Gonzales described their last years of high school and beyond as a “transition to illegality” consisting of three stages—“discovery (ages 16 to 18), learning to be illegal (ages 18 to 24), and coping (ages 25 to 29)” (p. 603)—and highlighted the transition, in their last years of secondary schooling, “from protected to unprotected status, from inclusion to exclusion, and from de facto legal to illegal” (p. 603). Abrego (2006) compared the experiences of documented and undocumented children of working-class Latino immigrants in Los Angeles, finding that undocumented children “undergo similar social incorporations processes as their documented peers earlier on” (p. 212) but that the end of legal protections limits their chances to attend college and decreases their motivation for education. Another subset of the literature has focused on the activism and political engagement of these students, often referred as DREAMers, and their attempt to change legislation on this matter (Gonzalez, 2008; SIN Collective, 2007).
Few studies have looked at how children and parents make sense of immigration status in K– 12 schools. One such study is Mangual Figueroa’s (2011) ethnography of mixed-status families in southwestern Pennsylvania, where she examined how citizenship status impacts undocumented parents’ and children’s participation in everyday activities. Focusing on a homework routine between mothers and sons to help “better understand the complex interactions that transpire in homes where federal and state policies mediate local understandings of kinship” (p. 278) showed that educators need to be well versed in how migratory status delimits the sense of participation allowed to them. These kinds of studies remind readers of not only how important it is to take a look at how parents and children are making sense of their undocumented status but also how lack of knowledge of these issues among school personnel in elementary, middle, and high schools can severely affect the educational pathways of these children.