Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Huge barriers to grain deal---demining ports, persuading shippers, Russia already stole the grain, and substantial political divisions

Malsin et. Al 7/21 (Jared Malsin, William Mauldin and Alistair Macdonald; "Russia, Ukraine Face Thorny Issues to Complete, Implement Grain Deal", 7-21-2022, WSJ, https://www.wsj.com/articles/russia-ukraine-face-thorny-issues-to-complete-implement-grain-deal-11658408580, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

ISTANBUL—Negotiators, having reached the outlines of a deal for Ukraine to export grain from seaports amid the war with Russia, face challenges to getting it done, from the demining of ports to persuading shippers they can operate safely in a conflict zone.

Russian, Ukrainian, Turkish and United Nations officials are expected to resume negotiations this week on a framework that would establish a grain export corridor in the Black Sea and potentially help alleviate a hunger crisis in some developing countries.

U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres planned to fly to Istanbul on Thursday evening, a U.N. spokesman said. The announcement of the trip raised hopes that a deal could be signed in the coming days, although the spokesman said the situation remained fluid.

Turkey’s and Russia’s presidents have sounded positive about the talks, as has a senior Ukrainian official. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, whose government has brokered the negotiations with the U.N., expressed optimism Wednesday that Russia and Ukraine would soon sign a deal.

Video Investigation: Russia Is Using a Secret Network to Steal Ukraine GrainPlay video: Video Investigation: Russia Is Using a Secret Network to Steal Ukraine Grain

While the war in Ukraine has upended the global supply of grain, a WSJ investigation reveals how Russia has quietly institutionalized the theft of hundreds of thousands of metric tons of it out of newly occupied areas of Ukraine and into Russian-allied countries in the Middle East. Photo illustration: Adele Morgan

“This week, we want to put this agreement into writing. And we wish that this plan will start to be implemented in the coming days,” Turkey’s state-run news agency quoted Mr. Erdogan as saying, a day after he met with Russian President Vladimir Putin.

An agreement could potentially free up about 18 million tons of wheat, corn and other supplies that war has prevented Ukraine from exporting, with the Russian invasion contributing to a rise in global food prices that U.S. officials said has sparked protests in 17 countries.

Substantial differences still need to be bridged among the warring parties, said Western officials. Should the governments reach a deal, privately owned freighters, insurers and sea crews might be reluctant to handle cargoes from Odessa and other war-zone ports, given the threat of further attacks, according to the officials, grain traders and other industry experts.

Ukraine faces the challenge of how to store or export its coming summer harvest.

Both Russia and Ukraine have laid sea mines in the Black Sea that pose a hazard to the movement of any ships in the area. Military delegations from Russia and Ukraine disagreed in the talks in recent weeks over how the demining would take place, a U.S. official said.

Ukraine has also increased the number of mines near its ports in recent weeks to defend against possible Russian attacks, the official said.

Safe passage for ships handling food cargoes and procedures for searching private vessels to ensure they aren’t carrying military equipment are among the issues to be resolved, officials said. Beyond that, Ukraine has demanded international security guarantees to prevent a Russian attack once mines are removed.

“You still have to get the parties to address the demining and the unfettered access and movement for the vessels themselves,” said the U.S. official.

Russian, Ukrainian, Turkish and U.N. officials took part in grain-export talks in Istanbul earlier this month.PHOTO: TURKISH DEFENCE MINISTRY/ASSOCIATED PRESS

Russia is still seen as a potential spoiler, U.S. and other officials said, with Washington and Ankara trying to pressure the Kremlin to reach a deal and implement it.

“Turkey is pressing Russia to say this can’t be a zero nothing forever. And Russia, you’re not going to like the look if you make your own navy guys take back their own mines. That’s an admission of guilt,” the official said.

Mr. Putin, meeting Mr. Erdogan on Tuesday, thanked him for his mediation and said that the talks had made progress. “Not all issues, however, have been resolved. But the fact that we have moved forward is already good,” Mr. Putin said, according to remarks shown on Russian television.

Meanwhile, skeptical U.S. officials this week pointed to recent Russian attacks on Ukrainian ports and grain-storage facilities as part of its war strategy.

“We are hoping for the best, but we have seen how Putin weaponizes food,” Jose Fernandez, the U.S. undersecretary of state for economic growth, energy and the environment, said on Wednesday.

To nudge the talks forward, the U.S. and the European Union have in recent days clarified that financial sanctions against Russia don’t pertain to food and agricultural trade. Clearing a path for Russia’s food and fertilizer exports is part of the framework for a broader deal on grain exports put forward by Mr. Guterres.

Russia and Ukraine have laid sea mines in the Black Sea. Cargo ships wait for port access near Constanta, Romania.PHOTO: ANDREI PUNGOVSCHI/BLOOMBERG NEWS

The stakes of a potential agreement are high for the poorer nations that were Ukraine’s biggest customers. Much of the grain formerly exported via the Black Sea went to Asian countries and to Egypt, the world’s largest importer of wheat.

While grain prices have fallen from the highs they reached in the aftermath of the invasion, an increase in Ukrainian supply would ease pressure on prices.

Grain traders working in the region also expressed doubt that Russia would allow the grain exports while its military campaign continues to destroy Ukraine’s farms, roads, grain-storage facilities and other vital infrastructure necessary to export grain.

“To me, their objective is strangulation, somehow or another, of Ukraine. They’ve been stealing grain from the occupied areas,” said Jonathan Grange, a partner at Sunstone Brokers, an agricultural-commodities brokerage working in Ukraine and the Black Sea region.

Ukraine exported about two million metric tons of grain in June overland and via smaller ships leaving the Danube River into the Black Sea, according to Ukrainian officials. That maritime route opened up this month after Ukraine’s military retook strategic Snake Island from Russia, which occupied it soon after the invasion began in February.

In addition to up to 18 million tons of grain currently trapped in Ukraine as a result of the invasion, there is also the challenge of how to store or export the country’s coming summer harvest of an estimated 65 million tons, according to Mr. Grange.

“We are desperately looking at those negotiations,” said Ivan Kriuchkov, a director at Ukrainian agribusiness IMC. “If the ports don’t open, where do we put all our grain?”

Write to Jared Malsin at jared.malsin@wsj.com, William Mauldin at william.mauldin@wsj.com and Alistair MacDonald at alistair.macdonald@wsj.com

A truck unloads harvested wheat into a storage facility in Ukraine’s Donetsk region as the Russian invasion continues.PHOTO: AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.