Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

DCA’s that extend NATO defense guarantees determine relations

Benjamin BASKA ’19, M.A. Student at Corvinus University of Budapest , “The U.S. and the Eastern European Defence Cooperation Agreements: Impacts, Geopolitics and the Hungarian Case”, Institute for Foreign Affairs and Trade - Budapest, Foreign Policy Review, 2019, https://kki.hu/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/FPR_2019_online_final.pdf

Agreements on defence cooperation have a wider regional impact, where an adversarial power might perceive the DCA as an element of an aggressive posture by the signatory states. While DCAs could increase tensions with the power to the East of NATO’s border, at the same time, they have a more cohesive effect between the parties. Brandon J. Kinne (2019) hypothesises that when states favour ties to “partners of partners”, it results in a phenomenon that he refers to as the triadic closure. In terms of DCA networks, Kinne highlighted that this would mean that country A and B are more likely to cooperate with each other if they both sign a DCA with a common country C. Of course, this would require a high degree of trust between countries A and B in order to push for a closer defence cooperation. This is where the EDI comes into play as well. As a tool to reassure allies by the increasing US presence in these countries, it enables the US to indirectly increase military cooperation among countries, and to upgrade strategic airfields or forward basing infrastructure in these countries. It is also important to mention that the DCAs are directly connected to the geographical and geopolitical position of a country. As it was mentioned before, these countries form an imaginary line of defence that is strengthened by their NATO membership and the bilateral agreement signed with the US. Since the Trump administration is a vocal advocate of increasing the share of defencerelated contribution by allies, the DCAs could be an indirect tool to nudge them in the right direction. At the same time, it also means an increase in the US presence in Central and Eastern Europe that could be perceived as a threat to Russia. With more countries signing DCAs in the neighbourhood, the growing number of concerned states would also mean that eventually the upsetting peace and stability would increase in a region. Conclusion The aim of this analysis was to highlight the important aspects of DCAs in Central and Eastern Europe, and to introduce the uniqueness of the HungarianUS agreement. Firstly, it aimed to interpret and highlight the subtle differences between the DCAs of the selected countries while it did seek to point out why sovereignty was a focal point in each of these negotiations. Secondly, it revealed the possible implications DCAs could have on the receiving states’ sovereignty and on the geopolitics of the region. Generally, there was no single framework under which these agreements could be placed since they lacked uniformity in their scope and purpose in a global context. However, the Baltic and Eastern European DCAs were commonly grounded on a thematic setting, by the creation of a legal framework for stationing US troops in the countries’ territory and for setting the stage for more detailed agreements. The similarity of the agreements stemmed from the objective that was here to set the framework for defence- and security-related bilateral cooperations. In all the examined agreements, the focal points, around which the debates revolved, were the movement and access, the criminal jurisdiction, the ownership, or in the Hungarian case, the tax exemptions. These are the essential variables that define the purpose of the treaty from different aspects. Each variable effects the sovereignty of the receiving states and could impose limitations on the sending states. At the same time, these variables introduce measures that dismantle bureaucratic roadblocks which could hinder future cooperation among the parties. The difference in the level of details between the Baltic and the Central European DCAs is more striking. The former ones are more general with less details regarding the taxation, the environmental safety or the administrative procedures, while the latter ones put a heavy emphasis on these issues, and even specify the administrative procedures, the military exercises and permits or licenses. While these elusive differences are not easy to spot, a single adjective or phrase can inherently reflect what the receiving states prioritise on and regard important in case of foreign forces in their territory. With the conflict of right of jurisdiction on one’s own territory and the law of flag, the agreements challenge the receiving states’ sovereignty. Furthermore, these agreements are based more on the absolute than the relative gains. Both parties benefit from the cooperation separately in different ways. The US is able to enhance its military presence along the borders of Eastern Europe and to create a logistical network from the Baltic to the Black Sea, while sending a message of reassurance to its NATO allies in the region. The other parties also gain concerning their security in defence, including defence modernisation, cooperation through investments from the US, and through the increased number of trainings and exercises. The defensive posture of these countries is also strengthened. The increasing number of military exercises enable the harmonisation of European and US military standards and systems paving the way for a greater cooperation and deployment efficiency, as synchronisation and interoperability are becoming crucial factors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.