All-out diplomacy is critical to solve the Ukraine war---otherwise, Russia will fight to the bitter end, prolonging the war as long as possible---plus, military engagement draws-in China
Harris 7/14 (Scott Harris; *interview with Melvin Goodman, a senior fellow at the Center for International Policy, and former CIA and State Department analyst*; "The Urgency of Pursuing Diplomacy to End the Ukraine War", 7-14-2022, BTL, https://btlonline.org/the-urgency-of-pursuing-diplomacy-to-end-the-ukraine-war/, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten
So your recent article lays out some of concerns that you have regarding the current situation in Ukraine affecting you know issues across the globe. And I was just reading a dispatch from the G20 meeting in Indonesia and I'll just quote from it. Briefly G20 foreign ministers called for an end to the war in Ukraine and grain blockade on Friday as Russia's top diplomat. Walked out of a meeting and denounced the West for frenzied criticism and squandering a chance to tackle global economic problems. Russia's invasion of Ukraine and its impact on food security and energy dominated the meetings at the G20 summit on the island of Bali in Indonesia. And the meeting ended with no joint statement and no announcements of any agreements being reached. Anyway, it looks like not much progress was reached there and not a good sign for ending the war in Ukraine. That there is really not even any discussion between. The US and Russia at this point about where this conflict may head. Now, maybe you can summarize your concerns about where the war in Ukraine may be headed and the different direction you'd like to see U.S. policy at least attempt to find a diplomatic solution here. Yeah yeah I have a lot of concerns. Or in day I don't know about 138. There's a certain sameness about these days. The Russians continue to make incremental advances. Very small advances but extremely costly for Ukraine for its people, for its infrastructure, for its it's villages, it's towns. The Russians are busy fast tracking citizenship to Ukrainians living in eastern Ukraine, and the Donuts, and they show no sign of backing down. And at the same time, Zelensky still feels he's winning and can win the war and you have too many American officials who are at least agreeing with that publicly. I don't know what they genuinely believe. I can't believe they think that. Ukraine can actually win this war and take back significant amounts of territory as well. So the nuclear background is something that's always concerned me because the Soviets fought a war or losing war in Afghanistan and never raised the issue of nuclear weapons. We fought losing wars in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and the idea of nuclear weapons never came up. Putin raises it as a threat from time to time. We seem to believe he wouldn't do it, but who knows what Putin will do when his back is against the wall? Given the fact that he's already conducted the war with such? Brutality and senselessness that it's hard to say what he'll do and unlike Khrushchev, who had to face a. A politbureau in the wake of the disastrous decision to put missiles in Cuba. Putin faces no possible counter, let alone opposition, and no one who's probably arguing a different point of view. And and when you mentioned the G20 meeting, I I just think it's wrong for Secretary of State Anthony Blinken, who doesn't really impress me. In fact, you wonder where has the State Department been during the Biden administration? What is the role of diplomacy? Or are we still active in the diplomatic arena? Uh, he went out of his way to make it clear that he had nothing to say to Lavrov and there was no. Point in meeting with him, you know, Lavrov is the foreign minister. But he he's not a power center in the in the Moscow Arena. But he is a voice that probably could reach Putin on some level, and the lines of communication I think need to be kept open. Uh, I know the Pentagon has gone out of its way to keep lines open to their Russian counterparts in the defence ministry. And there have been a couple talks, not many, and I think they're they're probably inadequate, but we have deconfliction zones in Syria between Russian and American forces. Uh, I think we have to talk about confidence building between Russians and Americans. In Ukraine, because as far as Putin is concerned, I think he believes now he's fighting not only Ukraine, he's fighting the West and he's fighting the United States. That's why I refer to what we're doing as a special military operation. This is what Putin calls his war in Ukraine. A special military operation, and he does that to downplay the notion that there's going to be any need for a draft or mass mobilization or extensive measures to get more citizens involved in this war he's trying. To have it both ways, guns and butter the same thing that Lyndon Johnson thought he could do in Vietnam, which. Became a failure and we're just continuing to send more arms, more sophisticated arms, and now the high mobility artillery rocket system. These himars we're going to send four more. They have a range of 40 to 50 miles and it will be possible for Ukraine to hit targets. Inside of Russia and there have been a couple targets hit inside of Russia. Russia has not called any attention to that. Because I don't think they've decided what they're going to do about it, it does raise the stakes and how this war is going to. Be thought but. I think back to really the 2nd 30 years war, which is how I define World War One and World War Two. Because when you think about it from 1914 to 1945 with this brief. Interruption in the 20s. There was a world. War going on. How long is this Ukraine war going to last? What are the implications now? You mentioned food. We could add energy to that list because. 'cause I'm seeing signs of war fatigue in Europe, and I certainly think we're going to see more signs in the coming winter as gas and oil deliveries get interrupted and the Germany German economy. Has some real problems with not fulfilling its energy needs, so there's more unwinding that can take place. None of it is good. None of this. Healthy and at the same time we're doing this, we're going out of our way to antagonize both Russia and China. And now the Pentagon and their military appropriations that they send up to the hill are talking about the need to fund A2 front war. But do they really believe they can take on Russia and China at the same time? I played war games when I was at CIA and the National War College that involved Taiwan. And we didn't win one of them. China always was the winner in a war game that involved Taiwan, and at some point we're going to have to discuss. Are we really going to defend Taiwan militarily? UH, is Taiwan part of our national security posture? Do we need to defend Taiwan? But if so, I think the best way to defend Taiwan is to improve our relationship with China to make sure China sees some good coming out of a bilateral relationship with the United States right now. Beijing must think Jinping must think he has nothing to lose in worsening relations with the United States because Biden has really followed Trump policy with regard to China. You know the tariffs are still in place, even though it would relieve some inflationary pressure if he drops some of them. Uh, so the the entire international picture, the international arena. I think is really fraught when you think of the consequences of a war that could easily get out of hand, and then when you think that we've taken this opportunity to expand NATO to bring into Scandinavian countries, Finland and Sweden, which will double the length of the. Border between NATO states. And Russia then it allows Putin to make the case that he needs Ukraine as a buffer zone because he can tell his own people. And I think there are already signs that he has told his people and. They don't need real. Convincing that it was that buffer zone that saved them against Napoleon in the 19th century. And certainly save them against Hitler in the 20th century. So So what we've done with our actions is given Putin a. A car. Was to fight this war that. Will be attractive to the Russian people. And the one thing I learned in. Terms of dealing with Russians over the years both at CIA and at the National War College. If there's one area of superiority that the Russians contend, it's they feel they can make greater sacrifices than other people. They don't believe themselves to be materialistic the way we are or the European states are. They can deal with setbacks. They can deal with failures. They certainly did it in World War Two and. Over 25 million Russians died. In a war. Which was overwhelmingly fought on the Eastern Front. When you think of where most of the German army. Uh was located and where most of the German fatalities and casualties took place, so I don't. I don't think time is on our side I, I think Putin can play a long game. He's indicated that he can, and he seems to believe this, and I guess I take him at his word and and we don't have. Any new way of looking at the problem? Whenever there's an issue that needs to be addressed, what we do is send up another military appropriations to the hill. The last one was for $8 billion more. Actually, $400 million in this increment to raise the total value of our arms transfers just in recent months to $8 billion over $50 billion. Overall. When you think of military aid and economic aid and infrastructure aid, so it's a it's a very. We're speaking with Mel Goodman this evening on counterpoint. Mel is a senior fellow at the Center for International Policy and a former CIA analyst, and we're talking about his recent article on Counterpunch that you can read yourself, titled Moscow's War in Ukraine versus Washington special military operation. There has been some concern expressed about how the Biden administration is fighting this war in Ukraine and what its goal. Those are and. We had Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin say a couple of months ago. That the Biden. Administration's goal was to number 1 degrade Russian military capacity and their economy. If that's still in play now, what's the danger of that goal? If if that indeed is where? If that is indeed what the priority is of this administration, when it comes to the conflict in Ukraine. Well, I still think there are a lot of people in the administration who believe that, and if they had their druthers would say it. But Austin was called on the carpet for saying it. Apparently he did get a personal phone call from President Biden saying that that was. A totally gratuitous statement that you made. Don't make it again, and Austin hasn't. But I know from my contacts with general officers over the years and I, 18 years of the war college. There there are a lot of high-ranking officers who grow up from their training from their experience from their exposure internationally. Thinking that Russia must be denied any military capability to conduct this kind of military operation. So I think what Austin was saying was sort of conventional wisdom. Within the military, don't allow Russia to come out of this war with the ability to. Fight another war in any area. In other words, Russia would not even be in a position to defend itself, and Russia is a country that is surrounded by adversarial interests. This is this is part of of Russian self belief about their own history. In their own national security situation, they envy our geostrategic. A superiority over them surrounded by oceans east and West and friendly neighbors North and South. They don't have that. They have a sensitive military border on the southern front and they refer to that as their sensitive border because they go back in history that Genghis Khan and various. Muslim and insurgencies on the border that created problems for Soviet and Russian interests and then when you think of the Caucasus, the fighting that takes place in the caucuses where actually Russia had to become a peacemaker between Armenia and Azerbaijan and it got very little credit for that several months ago. And then when you think of East Europe and the Warsaw Pact, the Warsaw Pact, I think, was not so much a way of opposing the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. It was a way of putting troops into Eastern Europe to ensure the loyalty of East Europeans who, with the exception of Bulgarians, detested Russia. And now Putin has made himself such a pariah, that even the Bulgarians have joined with their other East European neighbors, in being opposed to Russian interests. So to me we're playing right into. Russia beliefs about itself and the threat to national security that the United States represents by expanding NATO by creating a military headquarters, meaning permanent forces now will be in Poland by increasing the number of naval combatants in Rota, Spain. By increasing the squadrons of F. 35's in England. I mentioned Sweden and Finland coming into NATO. Onshore Russia was counting on Erdogan, Turkish President Erdogan to put up more of a fight to keep the Scandinavian countries out because of the Kurdish issue. But actually Biden handled that very well and heard on caved in very quickly. In fact, Putin in terms of his assumptions about the the West, the West is generally hung together. K now. More tightly and for a longer period of time than I think he anticipated. Well, we've run out of time now. Thank you so much for the work you do in analyzing current crises and for joining us tonight. And people can find your articles at counterpunch.org. Is that right? With that counter comment counterpunch.org on the national security columnist there and I tend to write once a week. Thank you ma'am.