Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US-NATO-Russia relations are zero-sum because of a lack of trust---win-wins are impossible

Ukraine invasion is more uniqueness for the loss of trust

NATO 15 ("Zero-Sum? Russia, Power Politics, and the post-Cold War Era,” 3/20/2015, NATO, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/opinions_118347.htm, DOA: 7-8-2022)//sposten

JENS STOLTENBERG: We have suspended all practical cooperation with Russia as a result of what we saw in Ukraine last spring. We continue to have open channels for political contact, but let me just address in a way the fundamental question you asked in the beginning, whether this is a zero-sum or a win-win situation? I can recall when I was a student, and also later when I worked in the Norwegian Central Bureau of Statistics and I worked on economic theory and game theory, and there we learned about cooperative games and win-win situations, and non-cooperative games and zero-sum outfalls or outcomes. The main message then was that it all depends on the rules. If you have the right rules and you have a minimum trust, then you are able to move from a zero-sum situation to a win-win.

The problem now is that we don't have the rules, or actually we have the rules, but they are not respected. Therefore we don’t have the trust and that's the reason why we are moving from a win-win situation toward something which is more and more like a zero-sum, a game, and we cannot go back again to the win-win situation without enforcing respect for rules. Because that's a pre-condition for trust, and trust and respect for rules is a pre-condition for win-win. This actually undermines both arms control, it undermines economic cooperation, trade, and it undermines security in Europe. So when NATO is so focussed on the respect for basic rules, like respecting the border of your neighbour – it's not a very advanced, it's not, how to say, difficult rule, it's to see the border and to respect it. Then we focus on that because that's so fundamental for the idea of coming back to a situation where we can have a win-win situation over a zero-sum situation.

DAVID IGNATIUS: Victoria, let me ask you for a final comment here and then I'm going to actually take the first question from the audience for you as well, so thoughts that you have on either the, to me, very worrisome unravelling of arms control, in particular in the INF dimension and then we'll turn to the audience.

VICTORIA NULAND: I agree with Jens that you can't have win-wins without trust. We all want win-wins, that's what we've devoted our professional lives to, that's what we need for our populations, but without trust you can't do it and you're not going to have trust if you don’t have truth. So when you have a country denying that it has troops in another country's territory, there's no trust. When you have a country denying that it is testing a new missile that may not be compliant with INF, it's hard to have trust. Our president has wanted to do not lest arms control, but more arms control. He has wanted to cut strategic weapons further. I was sent out to Europe as his negotiator to try to do a daughter of CFE, to do a brand new conventional treaty. We couldn’t get it done because Russia refused to talk about its forces that were stationed in Georgia, Moldova against the will of those governments. So we would love to do more, but it requires trust, truth, addressing the situation as it is.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.