Key to smooth AV transition
Caporal et. Al 21 (Jack Caporal, Former Fellow, Scholl Chair in International Business; William O’Neil, Intern, Scholl Chair in International Business; Sean Arrieta-Kenna, Intern, Scholl Chair in International Business; "Bridging the Divide: Autonomous Vehicles and the Automobile Industry", 4-14-2021, No Publication, https://www.csis.org/analysis/bridging-divide-autonomous-vehicles-and-automobile-industry, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY AUTO MANUFACTURING CLUSTERS: BATTERIES, CHIPS, AND FACTORY UPGRADES
Motor vehicle production in the United States has created clusters of economic activity. Original equipment manufacturer (OEM) assembly plants and those that make core parts attract and support suppliers—from tier one suppliers that produce significant components like suspensions and chassis to tier two and tier three suppliers that produce less complex components. Local universities can play a pivotal role as talent pipelines, innovation centers, and testing locations for AV research and development of smart vehicles. Key examples of this include the Ohio State University's Center for Automotive Research and the University of Michigan's Mcity, which each collaborates with industry partners in Detroit and Columbus to target resources toward the exploration and testing of advanced automotive technologies and the cultivation of a highly skilled and engaged future workforce. These clusters have generated three benefits: intra-industry benefits like access to specialized workers and a pool of supporting goods and services; inter-industry spillovers stemming from the spread of knowledge across industries; and spinoffs, or new firms created by former employees from the industry.
Automakers expect that within five years, electric vehicles will cost the same amount to produce as internal combustion vehicles. Industry trends suggest that the vast majority of level four and five autonomous vehicles will be battery-powered electric vehicles.1 Given the right regulatory environment, electrified AVs would likely quickly achieve scale. Widespread adoption of EVs is generally considered a natural step toward widespread AV deployment. The EV architecture provides the power, voltage, and energy storage required by AVs that internal combustion engine vehicles cannot. Estimates of the power requirements for AVs vary widely—from 200 watts to over 2,000 watts—based on variables like chip design, algorithm efficiency, and types and volume of sensors used. There is concern that the amount of power required for autonomous functions would reduce vehicle range. However, models suggest that power demand from autonomous functions can be mitigated and eventually offset by designing more aerodynamic vehicles, lighter vehicles, and improving route efficiency via automation.
Utilities will need to invest in improving grid capacity and the ability to meet higher energy demand to serve electric vehicles and ultimately AVs. Required investments to manage the EV transition will vary by region. In some states, overall capacity is less of a concern compared to the ability to meet rapid demand spikes—for instance, in the evening when commuters return home from work and charge their vehicles. Charging during off-peak hours for electricity use would ease the transition. Utilities could also incentivize customers to charge at certain hours or locations to smooth demand spikes. Further, energy demand in the United States has hardly grown over the past 10 years while capacity has grown by roughly 12 gigawatts (about 1 percent of the 1,100 gigawatts of total installed generation capacity in the United States in 2020) a year, roughly enough capacity to service six million new EVs, according to the Department of Energy. The EV transition will occur over decades, not years. This suggests that the current pace of energy production expansion is sufficient to meet demand required by the transition to EVs and ultimately AVs.
The impending shift to EVs and AVs has generated two primary concerns with regard to the U.S. workforce. First, EVs, being less mechanically complex than internal combustion vehicles and composed of more modular parts, will require less labor and fewer workers to build, and core components will be imported. The long-term trajectory of automotive production clusters in the Midwest and Southeast is only starting to take shape amid the accelerating transition to EVs and AVs. Second, there is a risk that the technology required for large scale deployment of EVs and AVs will be manufactured outside the United States. Shortages of semiconductors owed to chokepoints in global supply chains slowed automobile production in early 2021. China now has the edge in lithium-ion battery manufacturing and maintains dominant positions throughout the supply chain, from raw material refining to component manufacturing.
However, the right policy environment and effective use of existing advantages and relationships within the U.S. automotive industry should, in turn, create an opportunity for a manufacturing renaissance in the United States that brings with it new jobs in the industry. Further, the transition to AVs composing the majority of the U.S. automotive fleet will take decades, particularly for level five autonomous vehicles. This gradual transition will smooth disruptions to the workforce and provide time for the labor pipeline to adjust to the new automotive supply chain.
Investment in domestic capacity to produce EVs, and eventually AVs, appears poised for a breakout, and early signs suggest that automakers will improve existing facilities to produce EVs and AVs, keeping the anchors of automotive production clusters in place. The United States is home to some of the top global early-stage battery research and research into the technology that underlies autonomous vehicles. However, the United States does not offer the same level of support to those industries as offered by other countries, such as China and, to a lesser extent, the European Union.
That is likely to change. The Biden administration has made clear it intends to use an array of government levers to juice battery production in the United States and catalyze major manufacturing revitalization. Political pressure is growing to employ measures that will encourage domestic production of semiconductors. Government policy will also likely encourage U.S. manufacturing and the use of U.S. labor in developing and producing EVs and AVs. While the current regulatory environment for AVs does not provide a path to large-scale manufacturing and deployment, the Trump administration laid the groundwork for AV development and manufacturing to create U.S. jobs. The United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement requires that 75 percent of a passenger vehicle’s value originate in North America for it to receive duty-free treatment, and that 75 percent of “core parts,” including advanced batteries, originate in North America.
The Biden administration is poised to take further steps to ensure key EV, and by extension AV, parts are made in the United States. The president’s executive order will undertake a review of supply chains in key industries and focus on advanced batteries, semiconductors, and rare earth minerals, all building blocks of electric and autonomous vehicles. Additionally, Biden lorplans to replace the government’s 600,000 vehicle fleet with EVs, generating significant predictable demand over the coming years. In 2019, the government owned less than 3,000 EVs.
If adopted, a combination of government incentives and regulatory changes to encourage EV and AV adoption—including through investments in underlying technologies and infrastructure such as critical minerals, semiconductors, and other next generation technology—is estimated to create over 220,000 U.S. jobs and support another 425,000 over one to five years, according to a study from Keybridge Public Policy Economics. The study assumes four sets of incentives are provided for the manufacturing and purchase of EVs along with the buildout of charging infrastructure; three programs to support the creation of critical mineral supply chains outside of China’s control; a domestic semiconductor and telecommunications manufacturing package; and the modernization of federal regulations to support AV adoption.
While powertrain simplicity in EVs may result in fewer labor requirements for production, production will drive new employment opportunities in advanced manufacturing, including battery assembly, electric motors, advanced driving systems, and semiconductors. To that end, automakers have already announced billions of dollars’ worth of upgrades to existing manufacturing facilities, and parts suppliers estimate thousands of dollars’ worth of new opportunities around electrification and automation.
To maintain and improve the workforce, pipeline automakers, other industry actors, government stakeholders, and education and training institutions continue to cooperate on curriculum development, internship and apprenticeship opportunities, and other paths to reskilling and upskilling. New components and systems, including advanced driver assist systems below full level five automation, will require upskilling workers throughout the supply chain—from engineering and design to software development to those on the factory floor and in repair shops.
EVs and AVs will require infrastructure investment to meet their full potential. A massive buildout of charging stations and upgrades to the electrical grid will be necessary as EV sales continue to grow, creating thousands of jobs. Finally, cities and states will invest in smart infrastructure to improve vehicle connectivity, which will not only create jobs but create long-term economic and environmental benefits as a result of reduced congestion, travel time, and more efficient movement of goods and people. These factors will encourage industry to continue to tap into U.S. manufacturing and the U.S. workforce as the EV and AV transitions unfold.