Relations are zero sum – Russia must chose NATO or Iran
Lt. Col. Gordon B. Hendrickson ’05, Atlantic Council Senior Fellow, “The Future of NATO-Russian Relations: Or, How to Dance with a Bear and Not Get Mauled”, The Atlantic Council, December 2005, https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/46291/2005_12_The_Future_of_NATO-Russia_Relations.pdf
Russia is now more readily acknowledging, at least publicly, the value of NATO and of closer relations with the Alliance. Ambassador Anatoly Adamishin, President of the Russian Association for Euro-Atlantic Cooperation, recently affirmed this view when he opined that NATO-Russian relations are currently exemplary, despite some disagreements. As he pointed out, Russia must “have an alliance with the Alliance” and any quarrels between the two must be settled without taking sides. He put it plainly when he said, “NATO is necessary.” The challenge, he said, is to avoid tackling new problems with old, obsolete methods.105 It is vital for the Alliance to encourage this view and to keep Russia engaged with the West. Without a continuation of strong, active, and regular engagement from NATO and other important Western institutions, such as the EU, Russia naturally will look for support, security and prosperity from other sources, such as China, India, and even Iran, if they offer much-needed economic capital for Russia. NATO’s European members will be particularly key players in this regard, both multilaterally and even bilaterally, as Moscow looks more and more toward integration into European institutions and seeks to regain what it considers its rightful, prominent role on the continent. Without such continued active engagement, NATO could face a hardening of Russian attitudes toward the West. The likely result would be for Russia to close more of its society and become even more secretive than it already is, clearly a step backward from the Alliance’s goal of transparency. NATO has to avoid these pitfalls, insofar as it can possibly influence them. Above all, NATO should avoid marginalizing Russia, which will take creativity as NATO’s borders expand further eastward toward Russia’s. The Alliance could encourage a more active Russian role in the PfP, include more Russian officers in technical ventures such as joint exercises and force planning, and even possibly integrate Russia into its own efforts at military reform.106 One thing NATO leaders can count on is that as NATO expands its membership, especially to the east, Russia will continue to look more to other nations to establish or strengthen other alliances and partnerships in response. NATO’s leaders also must keep in mind that words matter to the Russians. The details and exact wording of international treaties, agreements, and even simple diplomatic notes matter. The author saw this repeatedly during his time in Moscow, when reaching agreement on the seemingly smallest details sometimes took excruciating lengths of time. In the Russian view, the spirit and intent of an agreement cannot necessarily be proven—only that which is written can be proven. Accurate words also prevent a subsequent administration or government from changing the intent of an agreement without resorting to formal channels. Russian leaders believe they can avoid being cheated or taken advantage of by correctly spelling out everything. Conversely, they do not see a problem in taking advantage of loopholes in treaties and agreements, if the letter of the law is not violated. In their view, it is perfectly fair, even if it might violate the intent of the law. Otherwise, their treaty partner should have seen this possibility and guarded against it. The moral: Whenever Alliance leaders can join formally with Russia in an activity or partnership, they should do it. Close, honest and transparent dialogue is critical to NATO success in continuing to engage Russia, and the NRC definitely has been a step in the right direction. Fortunately, the Alliance has recognized this, and should do everything it possibly can to encourage dialogue. Ambassador Maurizio Moreno, Italian Permanent Representative to the North Atlantic Council, recently commented on the importance of dialogue regarding NATO’s new history in its relations with Russia. In his view, Russia is now an equal partner and the process within the NRC is working well, even on sensitive issues such as Iraq, Afghanistan, Georgia, and the recent Ukrainian presidential election. Although there are natural differences of opinions, and even some differences between NATO and Russian values, he believes the two sides can work successfully through these challenges. According to Moreno, “there are values we can share” and he stated that we have done so recently through the NRC. Although Russia has not joined NATO, and most likely will not, in his view there is still the definite possibility for beneficial and productive dialogue.107 Former NATO Secretary-General Lord Robertson captured the essence of NATO’s success in the NRC when he presciently stated in 2002, “the real difference between ‘19+1’ and ‘20’ is not a question of mathematics, but one of chemistry: the success of the NATO-Russia Council will depend on the political will of the participants.” Based on the apparent willingness of both sides to make it work, he believed “the prospects for a genuinely new quality in NATO-Russia relations appear bright.”108 Thus far, his belief in the NRC’s prospects has proven well founded. Now, it is up to Alliance and Russian leaders to ensure that chemistry remains strong and positive. This will undoubtedly require a skillful mix of patient dialogue combined at times with more forceful pressure, without resorting to confrontation. As history has shown, confrontation, demands, and ultimatums will accomplish very little with Russia (as indeed, these tactics accomplish little with any country). The best prospects for NATO-Russia relations will result from NATO leaders honestly listening to and considering Russian views, even if in the end Moscow does not like the answer. To the extent possible, NATO must avoid marginalizing Russia.