Ukraine war has caused de-escalation in Libya.
Abdullah 4/20 [Bilal Abdullah; ; 4-20-2022; Russia-Ukraine War and the De-escalation in Libya; No Publication; https://epc.ae/en/details/featured/russia-ukraine-war-and-the-de-escalation-in-libya; 7-19-2022; SK]
Libya has been relatively calm since the Russian war on Ukraine started on February 24. Although this North African nation has long been viewed as a potential arena for settling scores between Russia and the West, the situation in Libya is currently moving in the opposite direction. Its political disputes have become less severe, and the flashpoints between the political rivals have decreased.
This analysis touches on three main areas of conflict between Russia and the West in Libya in the post-February 24 period – oil, the UN mission’s future, and military deployment. The analysis also examines the impact of these points of contention on the local dispute and any local party’s ability to seize the transitional authority or manage any settlement.
The Oil Factor
The dispute over oil revenues has been at the heart of the larger conflict in Libya. Controlling oil wealth creates a balance between the two sides of the conflict. The eastern camp militarily controls the oil facilities, i.e., production and export, while the western camp controls the revenue distribution because the central bank is located in the capital, Tripoli.
Considering this conflict, the international community tried to protect the independence of the National Oil Corporation and moved, for months, toward withholding export revenues from the Libyan Foreign Bank. Also, a conflict over the powers between the Minister of Oil in the government of Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh, Muhammad Aoun, and the head of the National Oil Corporation, Mustafa Sanalla, deepened the Corporation’s impartiality, which was usually affiliated with the western Libya camp.
Oil is now more critical for the western part of the country. Crude oil is a critical tool in new Western policies designed to besiege Moscow and undermine it economically and militarily by reducing Western countries’ dependence on Russian oil and gas. The idea is to deprive Russia of a significant financing source. Therefore, the United States, the architect of sanctions against Russia, is actively seeking to ensure a stable oil supply from Libya.
Indeed, the West has taken the following steps in this regard:
The embassies of the United States, Britain, Germany, France, and Italy in Libya issued a joint statement urging all actors in Libya to respect the unity and independence of the National Oil Corporation. They were urged not to politicize it or engage in any actions that would undermine the stability of this institution. Remarkably, this statement was issued on February 24, the same day the Russian invasion of Ukraine began. [1]
UN Adviser Stephanie Williams tweeted, stressing the need to preserve the independence and impartiality of the National Oil Corporation, the Central Bank, and the Libyan Investment Authority and not subject them to arbitrary pressures to employ them for the benefit of one party over another. The US and British embassies retweeted that tweet, emphasizing the same position. [2] This became clear about a month after the Western embassies’ statement referred to this position. It also coincides with growing uncertainty in the oil market against the backdrop of the Western-Russian conflict.
On March 17, the United States ambassador to Libya, Richard Norland, announced a proposal to introduce a short-term mechanism for managing Libyan oil revenues that build on the previous arrangement, i.e., depositing oil revenues in the Libyan Foreign Bank. The new mechanism assumes that the various parties publish transparent data on expenditures and revenues, and the oil revenue distribution is limited to salaries, subsidies, fuel production, and major imported goods such as food and medicine. [3]
In early March, the National Oil Corporation announced that it had agreed with British Petroleum to carry out exploration activities in the Ghadames and Sirte basins. The agreement came about 10 days after the British oil giant announced that it had quit its partnership with the Russian oil company Rosneft following the Ukraine war. [4] Kate English, Deputy British Ambassador to Libya, met Mustafa Sanalla, head of the National Oil Corporation, on March 21 and discussed expanding cooperation between British energy companies and the Libyan Corporation. [5]
UN Mission
The appointment of a UN envoy to Libya is likely to turn into a contentious issue between Russia and Western countries. The UN Security Council’s mandate is scheduled to expire at the end of April, and the Council will have to consider renewing it. There have been some key developments related to this issue, including the following:
The UN mission’s mandate was renewed on the last day of January 2022 for only three months without appointing a UN envoy. This British proposal offered a compromise between two American and Russian draft resolutions. The US decision called for renewing the mission’s mandate until mid-September without appointing a UN envoy. However, the resolution stipulated that Stephanie Williams, an American, would assume the actual tasks of the UN envoy as an adviser to the Secretary-General on Libyan affairs, a position she assumed on December 6, 2021. The goal is that Secretary-General Antonio Guterres will not have to seek the Security Council’s approval for the appointment. However, the Russian draft resolution called for the mission’s renewal until the end of April only, with the appointment of a UN envoy by the Security Council without delay.
With the date of the decision on renewing the mission’s mandate approaching, i.e., the end of April, and against the backdrop of a raging US-Russian conflict, it is expected that the dispute over the mission’s future will return to the fore again, especially concerning the issue of appointing a UN envoy.
In a direction opposite to the expected West-Russia escalation over the mission’s future, and specifically on the UN envoy job, some African countries with considerable clout in the African Union cling to the demand of appointing an African diplomat to the position of UN envoy following the resignation of former envoy Ghassan Salame in March 2020. Re-introducing this demand in the coming period may be the best way to shield the mission’s mandate against the repercussions of international escalation. Even the parties to the conflict seem willing to maintain the ceasefire and reduce escalation to preserve the gains achieved.
Military Deployment
There are many indications about how the Russia-Ukraine war will affect Russia and its allies’ military deployment in Libya. A large-scale military escalation is unlikely in Libya during the next stage for several reasons:
Russian President Vladimir Putin has agreed to bring in fighters from the Middle East to participate in military operations in Ukraine. On March 11, Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu said that 16,000 fighters from the Middle East were ready to volunteer for the war. [6]
On March 20, the Ukrainian Ministry of Defense announced that Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar had sent fighters to fight alongside the Russian forces, among the forces announced by the Russian Defense Minister. Wagner would supervise the transfer of fighters. [7] However, the General Command in Libya officially denied these statements. [8]
The British Ministry of Defense announced that the fighters of the Russian company Wagner were deployed in eastern Ukraine, which came at the expense of the company’s operations in Africa and Syria. [9]
The “Syrians for Truth and Justice” organization has published a report confirming that Russia has transferred Syrian fighters fighting in Libya alongside Haftar forces to fight in Ukraine. The report was based on testimonies from Syrian fighters and records of flights from Benghazi and Damascus to Russia. [10]
British Ambassador to Libya Caroline Harrondale met Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar at the General Command headquarters in Benghazi on March 27. The ambassador said that the meeting focused on the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the importance of withdrawing all mercenaries from Libya, and the need to avoid war returning to the country. [11]
These indicators suggest a plan to reduce the support provided by Russia to Haftar’s forces at the level of human resources and prioritize the war in Ukraine, which naturally means that there will be no large-scale military escalation in Libya. However, in light of the escalation of the conflict between Russia and the West led by the United States and the increase in pressures on Russia, the Russian-Western conflict will possibly not remain confined to Ukraine but rather erupt in other flashpoints including Libya.
Therefore, foreign fighters wholly loyal to Russia are expected to remain in Libya, given that Russia controls the oil negotiating card in Libya.
Impact on the Political Track
The Russo-Ukrainian War had impacts on Libya’s political process as follows:
1. Fathi Bashagha as the New Prime Minister: The project to install Fathi Bashagha as the new prime minister is no longer enjoying significant momentum, despite the man’s alliance with the Russian-backed parties in eastern Libya. Moscow was among the few capitals that openly called for Bashagha to be able to exercise his new position in the capital, Tripoli. On March 13, a group of residents of the cities of the so-called Libya Oil Crescent threatened to shut down oil facilities in the region and stop the export of oil if the UN mission continued to support the Dbeibeh government, demanding that Fathi Bashagha be able to take power in the capital. [12] This threat was already put into practice in mid-April. The use of the oil card in support of Bashagha sends negative messages to Western countries regarding attempts by the eastern Libyan camp to justify Western concerns about oil management in Libya and Russia’s support for Bashagha taking power.
Contrary to expectations, on March 2, Bashagha publicly condemned the Russian invasion of Ukraine and met the Ukrainian ambassador to Libya on March 26, stressing his position in support of Ukraine. [13] On the other hand, Bashagha is aware of the sensitivity of using the oil card for political influence at this stage and that the United States would reject this. Bashagha openly announced his refusal to use the oil card to enable him to take power in Tripoli [14], which reflects his commitment to keeping a distance from Moscow to avoid the political price he might pay in his relationship with Western powers. He is also keen to settle for a local alliance with the eastern Libyan camp. At the same time, the control of its headquarters in the eastern and southern regions has mounted pressure on the Dbeibeh government.
If the situation escalates around the Oil Crescent region within a US-Russia conflict, and if Moscow decides to make Libya an arena for settling accounts with the West, this would become the main challenge for Bashagha. Part of the forces loyal to him is located in the country’s center, in an area separating the forces loyal to Haftar and those affiliated with the Dbeibeh government in the western region. Thus, in this case, Bashagha may find himself compelled to break up the political partnership with the eastern Libyan camp, especially if the conflict escalates in a way that undermines his chances of becoming prime minister.
The only case that would make Bashagha accept a military escalation is for his forces to storm Tripoli by force. On the other hand, he is unlikely to accept that his forces will be involved in any confrontation between Haftar’s forces and the camp in western Libya, against the backdrop of the US-Russia conflict.
2. The Drawing Up of a New Constitutional Rule: Due to the new military balance, primarily temporary, owing to the decrease in the number of foreign fighters supporting Haftar, Moscow’s Ukraine preoccupation, and the decline in the chances of Bashagha being appointed prime minister, the UN adviser could work on a draft constitutional rule. It was achieved through a consensus between the House of Representatives and the State Council, based on which the elections might be held next June.
UN Adviser Stephanie Williams seeks to achieve a fundamental breakthrough to break the political deadlock, thus preventing the eastern Libyan camp from installing Bashagha for a new transitional period. The objective is to prevent Dbeibeh from achieving his goal of staying in power for a more extended period, as was the case with the Fayez al-Sarraj government. Williams is under the pressure of the time factor, whether the vote on the mission’s mandate takes place at the end of April or the end of the roadmap term comes at the end of June.
The House of Representatives is aware of the current international balances following Western sanctions against Russia and the latter’s failure to provide sufficient support to the eastern Libyan camp. This explains the Parliament’s attempt to play on the time factor and not respond to Stephanie’s efforts to thwart and wait for a new international order. Until then, the Parliament will continue to adhere to the roadmap it adopted, which calls for the appointment of Bashagha as prime minister.
On the other hand, Dbeibeh seeks to sabotage Stephanie’s plans. He declared that he was committed to his plan “to return the trust to the people,” based on which he formed a committee to draft an election law to hold the vote during June. However, the chances of this plan becoming a reality are almost non-existent. Dbeibeh wants to stay in power for a more extended period, especially when Libya is no longer an urgent priority on the international community’s agenda.
Conclusions
Although the crisis between Russia and the West is poised for further escalation, it is unlikely to see the conflict spill over to Libya due to differences over oil management and military deployment. Still, the two sides might clash over the appointment of a new UN envoy. The Libyan parties are seeking pragmatically to exploit the current international situation to avoid any political losses regarding the conflict over the transitional authority or the future of the settlement process. In this context, the main actors are working, in various ways, to thwart the efforts of the UN adviser to hold elections before the middle of this year and to buy more time in anticipation of any new developments.