Turkey within NATO enables Russian aggression–cohesion makes Russia worse
MICHAEL RUBIN 19, resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, “It’s Not Us—It’s Him,” https://www.the-american-interest.com/2019/12/03/its-not-us-its-him//BVN SC
Turkey’s recent turn toward Russia is a reflection of Erdoğan’s animosity toward America. To suggest Erdoğan pragmatically seeks to get the best deal for his country by forcing Washington and Moscow to bid for Turkey’s affection misses the point. First, the idea of NATO is collective defense in times of crisis, not an opportunity for members to launch bidding wars for cash, concessions, or contracts. Second, to apologize for Erdoğan’s tilt toward Russia ignores his embrace or promotion of pro-Russian aides and allies like military counselor Adnan Tanrıverdi or politician and activist Doğu Perinçek, a paramount influence among Turkey’s top brass, an unabashed critic of NATO, and a supporter of both Russia and a Eurasian alliance. After Israel intercepted the Mavi Marmara, a Turkish-owned ship seeking to run Israel’s blockade and support Hamas, killing nine Turks in the process, Erdoğan threatened to use every international forum to undercut Israel. Erdoğan now uses the same tactics against the United States and NATO: Rather than simply withdraw from an alliance that he appears to despise, Erdoğan seeks to cripple it from within. NATO is a consensus driven organization, so Turkey and its Russian backer gain more leverage from filibustering its processes than by simply leaving the alliance. That there is no mechanism within NATO to expel a member only strengthens Turkey’s leverage. Turkey may remain a member of NATO, but its strategic pivot toward Russia shifts the balance toward Moscow across the entire Black Sea region, allowing Russia to further solidify its strategic encroachment on Georgia and Ukraine.