Describing economic issues in existential frames militarizes the economy—results in structural inequalities and acts as a mental justification for war.
Skilling 14 [3/1, Senior Lecturer in the Department of Management @ Auckland University of Technology, “Everyday Emergency: Crisis, Unease, and Strategy in Contemporary Political Discourse,” http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/19460171.2013.862504#tabModule retrieved 5/19/14] Mr.Mr.
Narratives of crisis often invoke the specter of existential, physical threats to the body of the nation such as terrorist threats (Huysmans and Buonfino ); it is in this physical sense of security that Bigo (, p. 63) notes that human migration is ‘increasingly interpreted as a security problem’. Importantly, however, the production of unease also draws on everyday and (especially) economic challenges in a competitive global economy. Indeed, key aspects of contemporary economic life (tax and welfare regimes, productivity and innovation, and employment law, for instance) are increasingly interpreted as problems of national security. In the realm of immigration policy, for instance, national security no longer simply requires keeping out the dangerous, the poor and the sick. Rather, national security is also achieved by actively attracting and retaining desired, ‘talented’ migrants. Hence the contention of the Singaporean Prime Minister (cited in Ong , p. 188) that the successful attraction of ‘foreign talent will be a matter of life and death’ for the nation, where he clearly had in mind not the physical security but the continued economic viability of the nation. As Ong (, p. 5) suggests, the state of exception occasioned by neoliberalism ‘can be deployed to include as well as to exclude’ (emphasis mine).¶ Economic viability within a global economy is thus increasingly constructed as a matter of national security problem. As Agamben (, p. 13) notes, while the idea of the state of emergency was normalized during World War I, after the war, ‘military emergency … ceded its place to economic emergency’. The key discursive move in constructing economic viability as an issue of national security is the application of the metaphor of war to economic challenges. Agamben () cites Franklin D. Roosevelt’s response to the Great Depression (‘I shall ask the Congress … for broad Executive power to wage war against the emergency, as great as the power that would be given to me if we were in fact invaded by a foreign foe’ (p. 22)) to ground his claim that ‘the metaphor of war [became] an integral part of the presidential political vocabulary’ (p. 21). The metaphor of war is deployed within a narrative of constant crisis in which national economies are engaged in an unending global contest for resources, trade access and investment. As we shall see, the challenges of neoliberal globalization are not constructed primarily as crises of environmental degradation or political sovereignty, but – overwhelmingly – as a pervasive crisis of economic competitiveness.¶ The state-at-war metaphor is one of the main ways in which an economically based ‘shared purpose’ is naturalized and used to suppress alternative conceptions (Skilling , p. 78). It is during times of war that the state can most easily call for an almost endless degree of loyalty and sacrifice in the name of a clearly defined shared objective. It is during times of war that it becomes most acceptable to ask what citizens can do for their country, and to recognize and reward them on that basis. And, in a context of permanent crisis, the criteria of individual contribution to national viability can be used to justify massive inequalities of outcome.¶ Neoliberalism, then, can be understood as a mode of ‘governing through freedom’ that institutes the danger and uncertainty that lies at the far side of that freedom. And within a neoliberal global economy, the external environment is constructed as a fluid and potentially hostile realm of opportunity and challenge. The pursuit of global economic competitiveness, in turn, is justified as the urgently necessary response to that danger and uncertainty: as the salve for unease. It is thus essential to its legitimacy that the state is seen as offering a credible and coordinated response to that challenging environment. Far from eroding state power, neoliberalism provides the conditions that enhance the status and legitimacy of the state (and other actors) as the producer and implementer of strategy (see Thrift , p. 95), even if that strategy stipulates a decreased scope of direct governmental action or control. As Kim McKee (, p. 469) notes, ‘less direct government in society does not necessarily entail less governing.’ In neoliberalism’s recasting of politics as a ‘problematizing activity’ and its ‘transforming [of] situations of uncertainty into calculative strategies’ (Ong , p. 178), a dialectic emerges between problems and strategies. Problems call forth a ‘necessary’ strategic response; strategy produces correlative problems. The practice of strategy validates and empowers those experts able to formulate, implement and assess the technical solutions that the discourses of crisis, risk, unease and (in)security require.