Securitizing the environment via the aff’s Western scientific discourse ignores structural issues in the environment – masculine domination over nature is the root cause, which makes the kritik prerequisite.
Breidlid 13 [Anders, Professor, Master programme in Multicultural and International Education, Oslo University College, “Education, Indigenous Knowledge, and Development in the Global South”, p. 23-25]Mr.Mr.
Philipp Pattberg (2007) discusses the ideology of domination over nature that is still with us today, how it is “|d]eeply rooted in our every-day beliefs, actions, reflections and hopes, it lies at the center of any attempt to transform the world into a more loveable, friendlier, lighter and safer place” (p. 7). By discussing what he terms the enslavement of nature and the enslavement of humans by other humans, he concludes that this has led to a global state which is not sustainable. Exploring its historical trajectory, the ideology of domination over the natural environment took hold, according to Pattberg, “in the context of . . . the decline of Christianity as a total explanatory structure for human existence, the scientific turn of Cartesianism and the rise of capitalism to a self-replicating structure of rational choice” (p. 8). Lynn White (1974) suggests that the ecological crisis is due to the orthodox Christian legacy, especially its Western branch, stating, “Christian- ity, in absolute contrast to ancient paganism and Asia’s religions (except, perhaps Zorastrianism), not only established a dualism of man and nature but also insisted that it is Cod’s will that man exploit nature for his proper ends” (p. 4). Moreover, White proposes that “(o]ur science and technology have grown out of Christian attitudes towards man’s relation to nature which are almost universally held, not only by Christians and neo-Chris- tians but also by those who fondly regard themselves as post-Christians” (p. 5). Interestingly, White suggests a return to unorthodox Christianity spearheaded by St. Francis, an idea I will return to later in this book. Max Weber’s thesis, 7he Protestant Ethic and The Spirit of Capitalism (1905/2001), is based on the assumption that there is a close relationship between Protestantism and capitalism, that capitalism’s basis is (what was interpreted as) the Christian work ethic, particularly in Calvinism. The idea is that domination over nature through hard work and frugality will be rewarded by God. There is therefore an important epistemological dimension to this crisis. As Kincheloe and Steinberg (2008) put it, “Some indigenous educators and philosophers put it succinctly: We want to use indigenous knowledge to counter Western’s science destruction of the Earth. Indigenous knowledge can facilitate the 21st century project because of its tendency to focus on relationships of human beings to both one another and to their eco-system” (pp. 136-137). The exclusion of alternative epistemologies and the privileging of rational science have meant the demise of ecological sustainability while the epitomization of scientific truth and rationality has excluded values that transcend the so-called rationality dogma of the West. This denial of epistemological diversity and the privileging of European epistemic mono-culture is still hegemonic and perceived as a sign of development and modernity. Ideological Pathology There is a naive belief among modernization theoreticians that since ecological problems are a result of the economic activities of modernization, further economic activities should cure these environmental problems. Due to the finiteness of the earth’s resources, the vicious circle of repair- ing the consequences of progress with further progress is not sustainable. Ronald Wright (2004) argues that the 20lh century was a period where unlimited growth in terms of population, consumption, and technology exploited the natural systems in an unsustainable way. Wright calls these activities of ecological unsustainability the very worst kind of “ideologi- cal pathology.” While colonialism and the capitalist world system have been beset with territorial, political, and economic conquest, Western science is based on the same idea of conquest, that is, not respecting the earth’s ecological limits. Moreover, in line with worid-systems analysis, there is an ecologi- cal unequal exchange here, as the core’s exploitation and utilization of the world’s resources is matched in the periphery with the burden of negative ecological costs imposed by the core. As has been discussed above, the issue of Western science and knowledge production is existentially important because the Eurocentric epistemology of knowing (mastering) and dominating the world is, despite its mer- its, dramatically problematic in a world where the majority of the world’s population not only suffers from hunger and malnutrition, illiteracy, and lack of work, but where the hegemonic epistemology upsets the relationship between [people] man and nature as it seeks to possess the earth in the same way as a master exploits his slave. The ecological challenges are closely intertwined with the current economic challenges in the West, and it is difficult to ignore that the aggressive ideology of exploitation and the maximizing of profits, which are so central to European hegemonic epistemology, is detrimental to the efforts to save the planet from ecological disaster. Vivas (2011) is right when contending that the difference between the present economic crisis and those of the 1970s and 1929 is “its ecological aspect. Indeed, we cannot analyze the global ecological crisis separately from the crisis in which we are immersed or the critique of the economic model that has led us into it.” Even if we do not agree that the crisis is due to capitalism’s inherent contradictions, the global economic crisis has long been there; the eco- nomic crises in Greece, Italy, and Spain are miniscule compared to the permanent crises in the South, where millions go hungry to bed every day and live on a dollar per day despite heavy interventions from the aid com- munities in the West/North. Even though economic hegemony is shifting to Asia (China and India) and Latin America (Brazil), there is no reason to believe that the hegemonic discourse of resource exploitation and profit maximization will change. On the contrary, China’s economic growth is based on the same Eurocentric discourse, and the ecological challenges in China are, as a consequence, enormous, not only for China, but for the world as a whole. Its emission of greenhouse gases is the highest (in volume) in the world. There is a shortage and pollution of water. Annual desertification of land amounts to an area of about 13000 sq km (the size of Connecticut), and economic growth and rapid development mean “increasing urbanization, consumerism, and pol- lution’' (Council on Foreign Relations, 2011). The failures of past climate summits in Copenhagen (December 2009), Cancun (December 2010), and Durban (December 2011) show the inertia of the governments in wealthy countries. Actually, there is no global leader- ship to fend off the ecological crisis, simply because the leaders of wealthy countries are entrenched in an economic system that prioritizes non-sus- tainable development. There seems to be no willingness or ability to find a solution that requires a comprehensive social and economic transforma- tion, such as the necessity to decrease consumption levels in the North (given that similar consumption levels across the globe would require sev- eral planets). Here there is no difference between Communist China (a capi- talist in economic matters) and the US. This is one important reason why “the critique of the epistemic foundations of Western academic discourse has triggered and nourished discussions on the possibilities of construction of an alternative to capitalism” (Santos et a!., 2008, p. xxxiv). It was the universalist claims of Europe’s hegemonic epistemology (as discussed earlier in the chapter) that was employed to justify Europe’s “civi- lizing mission,” which is still hegemonic globally. As Griffiths and Knezevic (2009) state: This scientific universalism, the most recent manifestation of European universal ism, asserts objectivity across all phenomena and time . . . Such claims of universalism, or assertions of universal truths, function as meta-narratives that encapsulate the ideology of those groups with power in the world-system . . . (pp. 67-68).