Traditional IR sees small states and those on the margins as irrelevant, prioritizing “great powers” over and silencing violence against women and other minorities.
Sjoberg 2013 (Laura Sjoberg, Professor of Political Science at U Florida. Gendering Global Conflict: Toward a Feminist Theory of War (Print Book)) CL
This card has a bunch of stuff in it and it can be recut to make any of those args
In addition to having a narrow conception of what states’ relationships are, the literature on dyadic causes of war often focuses on a narrow subset of states that have relationships. While much of the quantitative work on dyadic causes of war includes either all dyads or all politically relevant dyads,20 many of the case studies look at great powers, and most of them do not dig significantly deeper than the (assumed rational, unitary) governments of those great states. By contrast, feminist analyses have come to see individual welfare rather than great power stability or even how governments interact as a central factor in global politics. The security of the least powerful women in the least powerful states in the world is not only a key security issue for feminists but also a key unit of analysis, given that many feminists see the margins as a crucial and inseparable part of local, global, and international politics. Feminist research shows how those at the political margins can be made insecure even while states are being made more secure. Women’s bodies have been considered the means to an end in debates over the U.S. security force in South Korea, the prevalence of and possible solutions to AIDS, and debates about refugee camp composition and makeup, to name a few, at the state and system level.21 Research into women’s lives in war and conflict has shown that they are often made insecure when military operations cut off households’ access to food, water, or electricity; when soldiers rape them; when crime and “domestic” violence increases as a result of war; and when severe economic deprivation leaves them vulnerable to disease.22 These threats are often, both statistically and existentially, more vicious than the threat of great power war.23 Feminist work has demonstrated a link between what happens to women in wars and the gendered dynamics of the making and fighting of wars.24 Because feminists often see individual security as a central issue in global politics, their work has critiqued the hierarchy that many liberal approaches to war(s) identify and espouse in global politics. Feminists have recognized that the least fortunate and the least free in global politics are often the people whose needs are neglected by policy decision makers and policy analysts.25 Additionally, “feminist scholars have repeatedly shown that gender operates at various levels at which it intersects with class, ethnicity, race, nationality, and sexuality to produce and reproduce an intricate web of inequalities between and among men and women.”26 Feminist theory, then, is critical of social and political hierarchy for the pressure that it puts on the “bottom” of that hierarchy.27 Many dyadic theories of war, like many system-level theories of war, do not share feminist theorists’ interests in identifying, critiquing, and deconstructing hierarchies in and among states.28 Instead, I argue that dyad-trait accounts of war value hierarchy by valuing the domestic organization of states (and how that organization affects peoples’ lives) as a means to the end of interstate peacefulness without particular regard for how what happens inside the state affects the people inside the state. Some “mainstream” war theorists concede that those left out of the planning of the international system “consider the system to be unfair, corrupt, biased, skewed, and dominated by hostile forces” but often do not give significant attention to the possibility that such a perception is true and normatively problematic.29 Feminist work has provided critiques both of the narrow definition of power (as domination)30 and the narrow view of whose power and security matters in these accounts. Arguing that it is possible to recognize through gender lenses the normative value and empirical impact of lives on the margins of international security, much feminist work looks for alternative ways to analyze war. This is important because, as Fiona Robinson notes, “those who care for others, and those who are most in need of care, are among the world’s most marginalized people.”31 While some characterize small powers as irrelevant because they “pose no threat to the dominant nation’s leadership in the international system,”32 many feminist perspectives express concern that this view justifies political and social oppression for the good of peace among great powers. Likewise, while some would ignore the concerns of the weak within states, because they do not make decisions or change policies directly, many feminist scholars have seen such a move as not only empirically problematic but also discriminatory: A concept of national security which gives priority to military threat rather than to dangers in the economic and social sectors of society can be bought only at the cost of poverty and misery and the violation of human rights—a cost borne by all poor people but especially by women and future generations.33 As referenced above and discussed in more detail in chapter 9, wars tend to have a number of gendered and sex-differential impacts in a number of areas, including direct material destruction, the implications of infrastructural damage, interactions with patriarchal militaries, the fallout of economic downturn, and the problems associated with environmental destruction.34 These harms are often distributed disproportionately on the basis of not only sex but also race and class to the margins of societies,35 and those people’s suffering is often ignored in dyadic and state-level war theorizing. Feminist theorizing, on the other hand, often looks for what happens at the margins.