Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

An Artificial intelligence weapon is the gold standard for hegemonic masculinity—free of vulnerability

Roff 16 (Heather, Gendering a Warbot, International Feminist Journal of Politics, 18:1, 1-18, DOI: 10.1080/14616742.2015.1094246)

Jean Elshtain (1987) notes that the narrative of men as “Just Warriors” and women as “Beautiful Souls” does not “denote what men and women really are in time of war, but function[s] instead to re-create and secure women’s location as noncombatants and men’s [location] as warriors” (4). Identifying this “trope” is one way to see the power of gender hierarchies and to question and break down that power relation. The masculine male as ideal solider, the feminine female as ideal noncombatant (innocent, victim, powerless) is something we should, and have more recently started to, question in practice.1 Indeed, with the United States repealing its exclusion of women for direct combat roles (United States Department of Defense 2013), one might hope that breaking down the gender hierarchies is on the horizon. However, as one hand gives, another takes away. While women are now de jure permitted to engage in combat roles, and thus all roles in warfighting, there is another movement afoot which threatens this process of gender balancing and mainstreaming: the creation of humanoid robotics. While some might view the creation of autonomous robotic warfighters as emancipatory, potentially freeing the military of gendered practices, I argue that this viewpoint is incorrect. Rather, the creation of humanoid robot fighters further entrenches a hegemonic masculinity that subordinates all humans. The humanoid robot fighter is the ideal of masculinity in western culture, for it represents an “independent, risk-taking, aggressive, heterosexual and rational ”being free from any weakness, particularly irrationality, frailty, emotion or desires (Barrett 2001, 79). The article traces three potential avenues for the construction of gender in a “warbot,” or humanoid robot warfighter. First, I look to hardware, or the physical constructions of humanoid robots. I utilize the United States Defense Advanced Research Project Agency’s (DARPA) Robotics Challenge as current evidence of these physical design choices (and potential trajectory for future designs).2 Second, I look to the naming of these systems, as well as their intended roles. I argue that the way research teams currently name and task these systems perpetuates and reifies gendered roles and power hierarchies. I caution that without a critical examination on the part of researchers and engineers, the current practice may lead to an accretion of gendered practices that threatens inclusion and mainstreaming. Third and finally, I look to the software of a potential humanoid robotic warfighter. Using feminist critiques of the philosophy of science, epistemology, technology and artificial intelligence (AI), I argue that the AIs created will not only emulate and/or co-opt the biases of their creators, but that the creators will actually distill gender into hegemonic masculinities and femininities for these machines. Taken together, these three gender vectors will produce an artificially intelligent, artificially gendered, lethal autonomous humanoid robot. Instead of using technology to free us from gendered practices and hierarchies, a` la Haraway’s (1990) conception of the post-human cyborg, this machine will perpetuate domination and subordination.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.