Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AI weapons are gendered to become an archetype for “warrior virtues” and embody hegemonic masculinity as it paints humanity as vulnerable, and thus feminine

Roff 16 (Heather, Gendering a Warbot, International Feminist Journal of Politics, 18:1, 1-18, DOI: 10.1080/14616742.2015.1094246)

Finally, and the most likely reason for intended gendering of AI, the purpose of gender is to reconstitute the gendered practices of the sending state’s military. As militarized masculinity is well known, the construction of a masculinized robot would act as an archetype for other human soldiers. The warbot would embody all of the “warrior virtues” and would surpass all of its human compatriots because it would never fatigue, require food, sleep or suffer from the trauma of war.23 As Goldstein (2001) points out, suppressing emotions, shaming and refusing to acknowledge wartime trauma are consistent practices across cultures to socialize men to war. A gendered warbot would act asa norm generator, and militaries, instead of trying to mold human soldiers to suppress their human tendencies by denying their physical limits through training, shaming and abuse, can instead create machines that embody all of these qualities. The humanoid robot fighter does not sleep, is “rational” in its calculations, is aggressive and can fight in the most dangerous of situations. It is Barrett’s (2001) vision of hegemonic masculinity in military culture. The result is that all humans become subordinated as weak, incapable and emotional; that is, feminized. One may object here and claim that all I have shown is that the creation of gendered humanoid robots perpetuates militarized masculinity. In a way, this is certainly true. Recall that Harding (2011) observes the mutually dependent relationship between the military and science/technology/engineering is coconstituted. If the producers and consumers of the technology co-constitute one another, then they will perpetuate already existing gendered practices. Humans gender because they are gendered. However, if I am correct, and the first-generation robots in the DRC portend a future of gendered autonomous warbots, then those machines will be hypermasculinized AIs in oversexed bodies. Technology is not going to free us from gendered practices and hierarchies, as Haraway (1990) suggests, but will instead reify those very practices and power relationships. I have suggested here that no human warfighter will be capable of living up to the standard set by these machines. To be sure, many of the “warrior virtues” are idealized, and human warriors often fall short of those standards. Humans will always be subject to the realities of fatigue, limitations of physical strength, hunger and emotion. Yet creating gendered autonomous machines entails that those machines will always live up to the ideal, and humans can never (and have never) met those standards. “Virtues” will not be “excellences” any longer; rather they will be the standard behavior for warbots. In turn, this will solidify a version of hegemonic masculinity, and further factionalize and subordinate all other masculinities and femininities. Thus I agree with Manjikan (2013) when she worries that “autonomous technologies might actually prove harmful to both genders” (12).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.