Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff the engages in media framing that sees NATO as the savoir of Women as a alibi to western intervention, as seen in NATO bombing response in the Kosovo conflict

(Kozol 04, Wendy. , Wendy Kozol is a professor in the American Studies department at Oberlin College , “Domesticating NATO’s War in Kosovo/a: (In) Visible Bodies and the Dilemma of Photojournalism.” Meridians, vol. 4, no. 2, 2004, pp. 1–38. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40338878. Accessed 22 Jun. 2022.) // RB

Media Coverage of NATO Bombings Throughout the 1990s, the American news media represented the Balkans as a violent region rocked by ethnic cleansing following the collapse of communist regimes at the end of the Cold War. Reports on concentration camps, torture, mass murder, and expulsion of thousands from their homes reinforced a narrative about the failure of democracies rather than the failure of market economies to emerge. Moreover, by mid-decade, reporters began to discuss the extraordinarily high levels of sexual violence by Serbian and Yugoslav forces in this region, especially in Bosnia. Feminist analyses foreground the associations between Serbian national- ism, rape warfare, and ethnic cleansing in order to understand rape as a military and political tool (Milic 1993; B. Allen 1996; Rejali 1998). Lynda Boose, for instance, argues that the sexual sadism of Serbian brutality was crucial to this "orgy of nationalism" (2002, 74). Statistics vary widely but conservative estimates of women raped in Bosnia range from twenty thousand to fifty thousand. (Boose 2002) U.S. media attention turned to Kosovo/a in the late 1990s as violence escalated against Albanian Muslim populations. The moment of most intense interest in the region came during the NATO bombings when the United States was directly involved in the conflict through its military presence. NATO operations never achieved the popular support of the Gulf War, coming as they did shortly after the impeachment hearings of President Clinton. Instead, the bomb- ings provoked intense debates about appropriate methods of humanitarian intervention as well as exposed the problematic nature of NATO's very existence after 1991.

Television, newspapers, and the major newsmagazines all provided extensive coverage of the war. Even with the pervasiveness of television, Time, Newsweek, and U.S. News continue to influence a wide variety of Americans because "nearly every high school, public and academic library" purchases them (Ulrich's Periodical Directory 2003). Major media con- glomerates that own Time (Time-Warner) and Newsweek (Washington Post, Inc.) - U.S. News is independently published - are part of the powerful network of American and European news media that control "what much of the world reads, watches, and hears in its foreign news ..." (Shulman 1994, 108). Crucially, these newsmagazines frame global economic, political, and social conflicts through racial and gender categories that in turn justify the U.S. government's encroaching and imperialist notions of globalization.

The first two weeks of the bombings in April 1999 were a crucial period during which the news magazines established narrative conventions for reporting the bombings. The first week's coverage featured lengthy discussions of U.S. military and political strategies, as well as articles on Milosevic as the locus of nationalist violence and reports on ethnic cleansing. Photographs show U.S. military and political leaders, Milosevic, maps of the region that depict US/NATO strategies for attack, and some pictures of refugees. Coverage in the second week focused more exten- sively on the refugees with numerous photographs of people walking along roads or railroad tracks and in the camps, photographs of military and political leaders, as well as more maps and pictures of U.S. soldiers. Articles continued to focus primarily on U.S. and NATO policies and military strategies, although reporters included more discussion of Albanian Kosovars' experiences of Serbian brutality.

Visual culture scholars are increasingly exploring the power of the visual to shape and mediate knowledge beyond simplistic models of propaganda or image manipulation (Liss 1998, xviii). Frequently reproduced and revered photographs of war, like Robert Capa's "Death of a Loyalist Soldier" (1936) or Nick Ut's "Terror of War" (the 1973 photograph of a young Vietnamese girl running naked from a Napalm attack) are not those with the most detail but those with the greatest symbolic value (Griffin 1999). As Liss writes, "At stake are the ways in which photographs are set in motion, how they are employed to stand in for wrenching, almost unrepresentable events" (1998, xii). This study provides detailed visual analyses of news photographs in Time, Newsweek, and U.S. News & World Report to examine which photographs "stand in" or represent the bombing campaign. Because of publishing deadlines, weekly news- magazines function like a "news digest" that recapitulates television and newspaper reports on events of the previous week, using photographs as visual "highlights" (Griffin and Lee 1995, 814). These visual highlights are less important as factual reportage than they are for their symbolic function. I will analyze the similarities in topics of coverage, narrative strategies, and visual conventions, including some repetition of specific photographs.7 This article, however, does not address the interpretive audiences of these news reports, whose readings, of course, will always be plural.8

All three magazines promoted a narrative of American rescue of victims in a dangerous and unstable region.9 An April 12 photograph from US News, for instance, shows a white American soldier in full combat gear in the extreme foreground. He frames the picture so that the viewer looks with him into the background at several cars on a desolate road. The viewer thus "sees" what the soldier is there to protect (presumably these are civilian refugees although the people in the cars remain unidentified). Above the photograph, the headline "Can the Cavalry Ride to the Rescue?" aligns a racial ideal of hegemonic masculinity with U.S. military efforts in this visual rescue narrative. Although the question mark suggest ambiguity in the situation, the exclusive focus in the article on the relative merits of different military strategies raises questions about policy rather than social or ethical concerns. This tag line, moreover, invokes American narratives of the frontier, referencing the imperialist imaginary of the U.S. cavalry protecting white settlers from dangerous Indians. Here, the picture and the tag line connect whiteness and masculinity to the rescue narrative through a mythic temporality in which social actors enact historically defined roles (Fabian 1983).

The three newsmagazines reported on U.S. military and political leaders, military technology and strategies, and the political debates over the utility of air strikes. Other NATO political leaders were rarely dis- cussed, with only occasional references to the military capabilities of the allied countries.10 Reporters paid little attention to the reasons for the conflict, except to blame the violence on the nationalist ambitions of Milosevic, whom one U.S. official referred to as the "tinhorn dictator of Serbia" (Time April 5, 40). Like discussions of Saddam Hussein during the Gulf War (Shohat 1994), the U.S. news media focused almost exclusively on the national leader, turning this conflict into a personalized fight against the excessive evils of nationalism. News reports described him as a dictator, a thug, a communist party hack, and a man of no political convictions except to stay in power. Feminist scholars have challenged representations of the Balkan conflicts that focus solely on individual leaders through documentation of the collective and localized dimensions of ethnic/political violence. Mertus (1999a) and Boose (2002), for instance, offer analyses of how the gender and sexual rhetorics of Serbian national- ism played into and exacerbated local ethnic tensions and conflicts.

Instead of more complex historical analyses, news narratives typically provide American viewers with an easily identified enemy, a narrative of us/ them frequently structured on racial logics. This news strategy is apparent once again in George W. Bush's "war on terrorism," which initially focused almost exclusively on Osama bin Laden as the leader of Al Qaeda. When the U.S. military failed to capture him, the Bush administration then turned to Saddam Hussein. Milosevic's European and white identities precluded the racial logic that characterize representations of Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein. Rather, the media demonized the Serbian leader through references to World War II, associating ethnic cleansing with the Holocaust and Milosevic with Hitler.11 Drawing these parallels provides the symbolic connection to a historical genocide that in turn locates the Serbian leader, and by extension Serbia itself, as outside of civilized nationhood. Individualizing this violence, furthermore, dehistori- cizes the complexities of the situation (including European and U.S. historical involvement in this conflict). As Fabian (1983) argues, this symbolic association positions the other, in this case Milosevic, in a past distinct from the temporal space of the viewer. In the second week, for instance, all three magazines published the same photograph of a long train filled to overflowing with refugees, many of whom are hanging out of the windows. Extending across the entire frame of the composition from the left foreground into the right background, the train effectively blocks any view of the city behind. This keeps the gaze in the foreground where hundreds of people stand on the train platform.

Pictures like this one accentuate the cultural and geographical distance from the United States to Kosovo/a. As other analysts of American news practices have noted, the media typically represent distant places, espe- cially outside of the West, as a "world of trouble" where disasters, wars, and the breakdown of the social order occur (Morley 2000, 183). The train photograph explicitly historicizes the scene through the visual allusion to the trains used by the Nazis to bring the Jews to the death camps. Such references (and there are many in these reports) render the scene familiar, and presumably sympathetic, to Americans who have at least a popular understanding of the Holocaust. Written texts further link ethnic cleansing to a historical narrative of fascism and ethnic hatred through references to Neville Chamberlain and Czechoslovakia. Using the historical specter of appeasement as a plea for intervention, reporters quoted political leaders who spoke of the possibility of violence spreading to the rest of Europe. Western commentators supportive of the NATO air strikes often warned of the dangers of appeasement as part of a larger appeal on behalf of human rights. The problem, however, is that "this purely humanitarian-ethical legitimization . . . depoliticizes the military intervention" (Zizek 2000, 57). I2 Specifically, the narrative of "humanitarian" military intervention depoliticizes the racial selectivity that determines such intervention. A racialized narrative is evident in the photographs in which Albanian Muslims look white, like the presumed reader, if a little backward. Critical commentators at the time identified NATO's racial selectivity in contrast to the lack of international military campaigns to stop the genocide in Rwanda, or other sites of ethnic/political conflict such as Sierra Leone and Palestine (Chomsky 1999; Haynes 1999).

Throughout the 1990s, American news media extensively reported on genocidal acts of ethnic cleansing and other forms of oppression by Serbian nationalists against ethnic populations in Bosnia, Kosovo, and elsewhere in the former Yugoslavia. Beginning in 1998, Serbian and Yugoslav forces began an increasingly escalated campaign against Alba- nians in Kosovo. According to some critics, however, mass expulsions and killings associated with ethnic cleansing did not occur until after the bombings started on March 24. In the words of NATO Supreme Allied Commander Wesley Clark, it was "entirely predictable" that Serbian violence would escalate once the bombings started (Chomsky 1999, 37). Critics have charged that NATO and the United States did not wait to exhaust diplomatic and economic options, but instead retrospectively used evidence of ethnic cleansing to justify the bombings (Chomsky 1999; Haynes 1999). While humanitarian issues were of concern to many, NATO prestige was also on the line. Since the end of the Cold War, to reconfigure its legitimacy as an international institution. Interventions in the Balkans were part of a larger effort by NATO to extend its reach to a wider geopolitical arena than the original purpose of the European Alliance. As British Prime Minister Tony Blair of Britain explained, "To walk away now would destroy NATO's credibility" (Chomsky 1999, 40).

Arguments about humanitarian intervention also ignore the substantial material interests at stake for NATO and the United States. These interests include investments by arms manufactures and Western businesses, oil companies' efforts to secure pipelines across the Balkans, and the role of the IMF-World Bank in the region. In the late 1980s and 1990s, for in- stance, IMF-World Bank policies that demanded austerity programs to secure debt repayment increased the economic instabilities of the region. Moreover, as the former Yugoslavia broke up, recognition or non-recogni- tion of states by Western countries had a significant and unequal impact on their political economies. Pressure on the Clinton administration also came from expatriate groups in the United States as well as businesses advocating international policies that increased their access to global markets (Haynes 1999).

Penezic argues that Western news depictions of nationalist conflict in post-communist states reproduce a Cold War paradigm that blames ethnic violence and the rise of economic disasters on the former communist regimes and on nationalist overreactions. "Whether or not this was true for the Eastern Bloc, Yugoslavia's situation was not quite that simple. The country has been decentered and federal, with multilingual education, publishing, press, television, and so forth. While this regulated and strictly controlled ethnic tolerance might not have been enough to assuage nationalist hungers, reducing the causes of war to nationalism only is, in my opinion, overly simplistic" (Penezic 1995, 63). None of the news coverage of the NATO bombings discussed the unstable economic and political conditions in the post-communist period, especially the region's relationship to the West and to global economic forces. Instead, all three magazines displayed a U.S. -centered analysis that reproduced a familiar narrative of Western rescue of victims in a dangerously unstable region. As Koshy points out, the American media "still remains primarily oriented to a national context and is thus unable to generate a transnational frame- work of understanding adequate to the complex problems of globaliza- tion" (1999, 20).

Rescue narratives emphasized the vulnerability of Kosovars and the humanitarianism of military intervention. Crucially, the newsmagazines characterized the Balkans as an agricultural area that still relies on primi- tive farming techniques and a place of historic ethnic rivalries. Pictures show people fleeing in primitive modes of transportation, walking in single file on railroad tracks to avoid land mines or walking in desolate landscapes. In Newsweek, for instance, an April 12 photograph shows a man in the foreground pushing a wheelbarrow in which sits an elderly woman wrapped in a headscarf, winter coat, and blanket. Behind them another man also pushes an elderly person in a wheelbarrow and two others walk along the road. This primitive mode of transportation underscores the refugees' vulnerable status while the desolate landscape offers no clues to specific geographical, temporal, or cultural locations. Old helpless women, cared for by men, all of whom appear white, with limited re- sources (wheelbarrows) create a sympathetic portrait. It also renders men solely within a subordinate masculinity that depends on the protection of outside forces while women are visualized as vulnerable and needy because of their age, race, and gender. The exclusive gaze at peasants in a pre- modern setting, of course, also erases the range of material resources and cultural experiences of the Albanian Kosovars.13

Physically locating the conflict in this nightmarish space, pictures like this one and the one of the train station participate in creating what Zizek refers to as the "imagined cartography" of the Balkans that depicts this region as a "terrain of ethnic horrors" still fighting centuries-old battles presumably in contrast to the advanced democratic status of the West (Zizek 2000, 4-5). While this perhaps raises the question of what is the West, it also resecures a cultural map that defines Europe as the countries of Western Europe while the Balkans remain somewhere on the fringes of civilization. These images also play into Cold War narratives that visualize socialism as a failure of modernity. Such narratives deny how transnational dependencies and determinations shape the region's economy. Hyper- inflation, austerity measures, and other economic constraints since the collapse of communist regimes in the region have intensified social and political unrest. Escalating debt increasingly weakened the region's economies, led to worker protests, and fostered the prestige of nationalist solutions by Milosevic and his supporters (Haynes 1999). Yet, news media ignored or minimized local, regional, and transnational factors that have shaped ethnic conflict in the Balkans in favor of representations of NATO heroics.

The lack of references to Albanian politics ignores the complicated and hybrid nature of Albanian identities and political activisms. Moreover, it promotes American national interests at the expense of local and regional factors. The only coverage of Albanian responses to Serbian violence was reports on the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA), a small militant group. None of the magazines, for instance, discussed the nonviolent agenda of the Albanian intellectual and political leader Ibrahim Rugova (Chomsky 1999; Mertus 1999a, 6). Photographs instead featured male soldiers of the KLA in combat uniforms, yet there are no signs of actual combat.14 Compared with detailed discussions of American military equipment, strategy, and personnel, reports on the KLA emphasized the lack of equipment, training, and even incompetence of these fighters. This contrast further eliminates political alternatives to the spectacle of victim- ization. Zizek argues that NATO intervened to protect Kosovar victims while making sure they would remain victims; that is, no international support backed the Albanians to become full political agents, or to sustain an armed resistance. He describes this as the "paradox of victimization: the Other to be protected is good in so Jar as it remains a victim" (2000, 59, 60). News coverage of victims waiting to be rescued erases U.S. and European nations' complicity in the economic and political instabilities in the region. Petras further argues that innocent victimization also ignores the violence perpetrated by the KLA. He writes that the "triumphal returns and euphoric rhetoric of the NATO leaders covers up the brutal reality of massive ethnic cleansing, systematic assassinations, pillage and destruc- tion of churches, houses, farms, and businesses by NATO-backed Alba- nian KLA terrorists and their paramilitary supporters" (1999, 13).

As important as it is to publicize the horrors of war and ethnic cleans- ing, these photographs elide any representations of the subjectivity and agency of the Albanians. Cameras do not depict the diversity of experiences and cultures in Kosovo/a (Mertus 1999a). No pictures show people working in an urban setting or creating a makeshift home or treating the injured.15 Nor do readers encounter photographs of Albanian doctors, social workers, community leaders, etc. Instead, photographs depict fearful and/or exhausted refugees.16 In a half-page picture featured in U.S. News on April 12, for instance, the photographer used a high angle shot of a group of refugees. The high angle makes the crowd appear very large as people spread out to the very edges of the background. In the center foreground, a woman holds out her hands in a supplicant pose with the , "Pleading. A woman from Kosovo asks Macedonian police officers to let her cross the border. Thousands waited without food or water." As the focal point of the composition, the female supplicant stands as the representative of the "waiting" group. Women such as the suppli- cant become, in Zizek's words, the "ideal subject-victim in aid" (2000, 57- 58) who do not struggle for their own survival or fight back but remain the feminized object of the Western gaze.

These pictures provide the visual alibi for U.S. and NATO intervention by establishing a national narrative about U.S. power and political good in contrast to Milosevic and his Serbian forces. The racial logic is here reinforced because few signs recognizable to Western viewers would identify the refugees as Muslim. Racial and religious differences are elided in this portrayal of Albanians as allies. Instead, gender is foregrounded through prominently featured photographs of mothers with small chil- dren, namely on two magazine covers and as the opening two-page spread in all three magazines the second week. Collapsing the body with experi- ence and identity, photojournalism relies on the bodies of mothers and babies to function as metonyms for the Kosovo/a crisis. Recent feminist scholarship on embodiment has explored with great insight how identity, especially sexual, gender, and racial identities are produced and repro- duced through visible bodies.17 In the news coverage of the NATO bomb- ings, the visual embodiment of white motherhood, however, does not so much produce knowledge or understanding of trauma as it turns subjects into spectacles of suffering.

As metonyms for victimization, photographs of women and children collapse motherhood with the home (Morley 2000, 65) and in so doing become the visible symbol of what is being threatened and what needs to be saved. For instance, a tightly framed photograph in U.S. News from April 12 shows a group of refugees enclosed in an space that appears to be surrounded by barbed wire (the caption explains that the wire is part of the back of a truck) (fig. 2). In the center of the composition, a woman throws her head back in anguish while a child next to her stares soberly at the camera. This highly emotional expression of innocence and vulnerability establishes the face of suffering for the viewer. In such pictures, sub- jectivities are elided as visible bodies rearticulate racialized gender ideals of domesticity familiar to American audiences (Williams 1994). Despite late twentieth-century social developments that include post-communism, globalization, and new technologies, idealized domesticity continues to {{Fig.2 ommited}} Fig. 2. Photograph by Santiago Lyon. Courtesy of AP/Wide World Photos. have enormous ideological resonance (Morley 2000, 56). Since the Cold War period, the American media have aligned an ideal of the white middle class family with national interests and desires (Kozol 1994). These pictures of refugees from Kosovo/a reveal the powerful place that the racialized mother-child ideal continues to hold in the U.S. cognitive grid. Whiteness, furthermore, contains the otherness of Albanian Kosovars who, like this anguished Albanian mother, lack racial, ethnic or religious markers of difference. If class, racial, gender, and heteronormative ideals shape the cultural alignment of family and nation, what happens when domesticity, that powerful sign of stability and tradition, is figured as the sign of social disorder or breakdown?

Media portrayals of the ideal family typically establish boundaries of identity that exclude all those who do not fit these racial, sexual, and class categorizations. Morley, however, compellingly argues that not all representations of domesticity are so intentionally exclusive. Instead, he writes, "it is not the presence of otherness per se which is problematic but only that of undomesticated otherness," pointing out examples of the incorpo- ration of Others, or what he calls, "domesticating alterity" (2000, 223). In other words, the logics of racialization are often dependent upon incorpo- rating otherness within "the relation of domination" (Taguieff 2001, 121). News photographs of Kosovar refugees foreground racialized gender ideals of domesticity in this moment of profound crisis and social disor- der. Narratives about conflicts in the Balkans have historically been mapped onto ethnic rivalries and hostilities that stereotype populations as violent and backward. During the Cold War, for instance, the American media typically collapsed ethnicity and communism in characterizations of Albania as one of the most repressive communist regimes. In contrast, news coverage of refugees in 1999 turned the camera's gaze to mothers and children to figure Albanians as the innocent victims of Serbian aggression. Ideals of domesticity that feature attractive, white looking, mothers elide differences to establish instead the moral position of the refugees.

The cover photograph in U.S. News for April 12 exemplifies the process of domesticating alterity. Above the headline, "Balkan Hell," three figures in the center of the composition look out at the camera. With a somber but calm gaze, a young attractive woman holds a small child while an older son leans against her. Although the caption does not identify her religious affiliation, the coverage repeatedly characterized the violence in Kosovo/a as an ethnic conflict between Serbian Christians and Albanian Muslims. That this woman is not specifically identified as a Muslim reinforces the process of incorporation within an American ideal of domesticity. Even more than other mother and child images, this photograph evokes the Western Christian art historical tradition of the Madonna and child flanked by one or more saints. In the extreme foreground a woman with her head covered in a white cloth moves toward the picture plane. Her forward posture suggests movement outside of the camera's frame and into the viewer's space. The triangular position of the main figure group creates a stability that counterbalances the dynamic movement of this foreground figure. The compositional and iconographic stability signified by this Madonna and children, as Morley suggests, domesticates the refugees' alterity. This process occurs through foregrounding heteronormativity, albeit normativity at risk. During the Balkans wars, reporters often told of Serbian detention and killings of fathers and husbands. To see the family without the male figure underscores the social crisis and reinforces the call to rescue the mothers and children. Even as this woman is incorporated within an American cognitive ideal of domesticity, however, she remains other in her (unlabeled) ethnicity and in her state of crisis. She is thus both like and unlike the viewer. Looking at how photographs mobilize domes- ticity reveals the ways in which narratives of war incorporate alterity as part of justifications for military intervention.

In the newsmagazines, scenes of destroyed houses, rather than pictures of military battles, further configure the Albanians visually within the private sphere. In American hegemonic culture, the private sphere signifies the privileges of privacy, intimacy, and protection from the external world. On April 5, both Time and Newsweek featured a photograph of a Serbian army tank in front of a destroyed house with signs of still smoldering fires. A Serbian soldier holding a rifle, caught mid-stride in profile, looks defiantly at the camera. Masculinity and militarism foreground the threat to private life and to the vulnerable bodies of the Albanians. The accompa- nying report discusses the invasion of private homes by paramilitary forces where people were either tortured or removed from families and then tortured. Domesticity, as the sign of what is at risk, and hence as the justification for intervention, locates the Albanians within terms recogniz- able to American audiences.

In a region such as Kosovo/a, many reasons compel photojournalists to report on the violence that persists there despite juridical and humanitar- ian interventions by international agencies like the UN or military interven- tions like the NATO air strikes. In domesticating alterity, however, Ameri- can news coverage of Kosovo/a relied on conventions of photojournalism, in particular the figure of vulnerable white maternity, to depict the human casualties of violence in the Balkans. News coverage that represents Albanians only as victims ignores their struggles and experiences while promoting narratives of Western benevolent support for needy and inno- cent refugees. Representations of crises outside the United States, as in this case, are typically mediated through the lens of national concerns, such as security or economic interests. As Koshy writes, "On human rights issues, in particular, the statist perspective obscures and distorts the perception of the problem and the construction of the solution . . ." (1999, 21). Thus, what is at stake in media coverage is the relationship between how social crises are represented and how they are managed within a transnational context.

Given this critique of photojournalism, how can photographers main- tain the moral imperative of political visibility? The challenge of reportage in this case is made particular acute by the problematics of representing trauma. How can photographers visualize trauma without inevitably turning people into spectacles? If photographers attempt to avoid the spectacle of embodied suffering, what happens if we do not have an embodied victim to pity?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.