The perm is just the affs attempting to normalize the precarious that the liberal state has pushed to the margins, just like neoliberalism
Lorey et al 15(Lorey, Isabell, et al. , Lorey is a Queer Studies Professor at the Academy of Media Arts in Cologne, works for transversal texts, the publication platform of the European Institute for Progressive Cultural Policies. , “Biopolitical Governmentality .” State of Insecurity: Government of the Precarious, Verso, London, 2015, pp. 36–39.) //RB
Within the framework of its welfare-state paradigm of protection, liberal governmentality was based on multiple forms of precarity as inequality through othering: on the one hand, on the unpaid labour of women in the reproduction area of the private sphere; on the other hand, on the precarity of all those excluded from the nation-state compromise between capital and labour - whether as abnormal, foreign or poor - as well as those living under extreme conditions of exploitation in the colonies.31 All those who did not meet the norm and normalization of the free, sovereign-bourgeois, white subject, along with his concomitant property relations, and all those who threatened this norm, were precarized. Western modernity, along with its conceptions of sovereignty and biopolitics, is unthinkable without a ‘political culturc of danger’,34 without the permanent endangerment of the normal, without imaginary invasions of constant, everyday threats such as illness, filth, sexuality, criminality or the fear of ‘racial’ impurity, which must be immunized against in various ways.35 The presumed paradox of biopolitical governmentality is evident here in a further aspect: this mode of governing makes it possible, as Cornelia Ott has aptly phrased it, ‘for human beings to learn to consider themselves as unique “subjects”, while uniting them at the same time as an amorphous, standardized “population mass” . .. The reverse side of the “right to life” here is always the exclusion or destruction of life.’36
The liberal mode of governing produces precarities as economic, social and legal relations of inequality through systematic categorizations and hierarchizations according to ‘body’ and ‘culture’. In this sense I use precarity as a structural category of ordering segmented relations of violence and inequality. This dimension of structural inequality, however, is missing in Foucault’s conception of governmentality.-37
Helped by a hierarchizing and discriminating culture of danger, the contradictions of liberal political economy are reinforced in the interplay between freedom and security, self-empowerment and compulsion. As an immanent contradiction of liberal govern mentality, precarized deviance has repeatedly distorted and disturbed the stabilizing dynamics between freedom and security and has frequently triggered collective counter-behaviour and struggles.
From the nineteenth century on, hegemonic economic modes of subjectivation and self-government were not practised in liberal-capitalist societies independently from social protection techniques and institutions. The latter were intended to reduce social insecurity and keep the risk of unemployment, illness, accident and social exclusion calculable for an increasing number of the national population.™ At the same time, the institutions of the welfare state did not primarily serve the protection and ecurity of the workers, but rather supported economically productive self-government techniques among obedient and cautious citizens,3* who ensured themselves and precarized others simultaneously. This governmental dynamic involves attempts to control the precariousncss shared among all by stria ting and positioning dangerous ‘others’ as the precarious ones at the ‘margins’.
In neoliberalism the function of the precarious is now shifted to the middle of society and normalized. This means that the function of bourgeois freedom can now also be transformed: away from dissociation from precarious others and towards a subjectivizing function in normalized precarization. Whereas the precarity of the marginalized retains its threatening and dangerous potential, precarization is transformed in neolibcralism into a normalized political-economic instrument.