Policy cannot solve because policy changes misunderstand gender = women
Gentry 16, C. E. (2016). (Caron Gentry is Senior Lecturer in the School of International Relations at the University of St. Andrews and Chair of the Feminist Theory and Gender Studies Section of the International Studies Association, The ‘Duel’ Meaning of Feminisation in International Relations: The Rise of Women and the Interior Logics of Declinist Literature, Global Responsibility to Protect, 9(1), 101-124. doi: https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1163/1875984X-00901007)
Feminisation as Devalorisation ir scholarship, amongst other scholarship, has always valued masculine traits above feminine ones: rationality of capability over weakness (as well as the rationality of attitude over one informed by emotion); sovereignty over cooperation/dependency.86 Therefore, the discourse of progress and good governance is not only Western-centric but inherently masculinist as well. To demonstrate this I will unpack the feminist understanding of ‘feminisation’. It is not enough to think that simply by ‘including’ women in policies, solutions, or measurements means that progress is being made. This is the assumption that Chakrabarty pointed out as a hypocritical fallacy. Instead, a deeper grasp of what gender is and how it operates as a structure must be understood. The declinist literature is not manipulating women’s positions but it is replicating gender dynamics when it fails to pay attention to certain violence, like structural violence, sexual and gender-based violence, and violence against sexual minorities. Ann Tickner begins her seminal text on gender and international relations by working through a critique of how Morgenthau transposes the rational man onto the state. This has given mainstream ir scholars the presumption that states are (or ought to aspire to being) rational, sovereign actors.87 Yet, as Tickner points out, rationality and sovereignty are masculine attributes.88 In a logocentrism, such as the one that exists in the masculinity-femininity binary, one side is always valued over another. Particular masculinities are valorised— rational, wealthy, white, heteronormative ones;89 most if not all femininities are devalorised.
. The bias towards masculinity is what V. Spike Peterson refers to as feminisation.90 Peterson clarifies that Gender is not simply an empirical category that refers to embodied men and women and their material activities but also a systematically analytical category that refers to constructions of [privileged] masculinity and [devalorised] femininity and their ideological effects (emphasis true to text).91
She continues by adding that ‘the privilege and power attributed masculine qualities depends on the devalorisation of feminised qualities’ (emphasis true to text).92 The creation of gendered hierarchies depend on the ‘natural[isation], depolitical[isation], legitim[ated]…denigration of the feminine, and it is the feminisation of “others” that link multiple oppressions’.93 It is not that the declinist literature intends to oppress—this is more than likely the opposite of what is desired—but that due to its devalorisation of particular violences, this is an unexpected outcome.
Gender analysis can be used to undo feminisation. Gender analysis, or utilising a gender lens, means paying attention to what is socially constructed as masculine or feminine. Gender, like race or class, determines what is prioritised.94 This analysis acknowledges that gender shapes more than people, it shapes organizations, institutions, and states.95 Some feminists see this as an apparatus, a la Althusser,96 and others see this a laddering of sorts, where competing masculinities vie for the hegemonic position.97
Deprioritised Violences The critique of the implementation of ‘feminisation’ in unscr 1325 and development policies is illustrative here. Instead of fundamentally changing how the structural gender inequalities, these policies reified them. These policies fundamentally misunderstood what feminists believe gender to be. They see gender as women, as an operational variable instead of as the aforementioned way of ordering people, organisations, and international hierarchies. My fear is that a declinist understanding of ‘feminisation’ mirrors feminism’s ‘feminisation’. It does so, in the first instance, by minimising, if not deprioritising, violences that are not combat-related. In the second instance, by conflating gender with women and prioritising women’s rights, it fails to make actual change by challenging the very structures that subordinate women and other marginalised peoples. By only seeing gender as ‘women’ it fails to see gender as a hierarchical structure that organises international relations98 (both in what is studied and how it is studied).
When declinist scholarship prioritises the statistical measurement of certain types of violence, particularly combatant death versus non-combatant death, it then fails to see other forms. Specifically, John Gray criticises the declinist thesis for failing to recognise the deaths that happen under dictatorships or due to structural violence.99 Equally, Jacqui True discusses how the declinist literature fails to account for and take seriously sexual and genderbased violence.100 This paper is concerned with how it deals with the rights and empowerment of marginalised people whose identity lies outside of the gender binary that declinist’s modern Western focus cannot account for.
Feminisation in declinist scholarship is defined by rights, empowerment, and legal, if not social, recognition of these. Feminisation in feminist literature is about the deprioritisation of what is seen as the feminine. Feminisation in declinist literature thankfully takes individual security seriously, something feminist ir has championed for decades. Yet, it only pays attention, seemingly, to certain people’s rights, mainly women in the conflation of women and gender. This has led to an ignorance of the issues outlined above. Yet, if we take Hudson’s argument in Sex and World Peace or Pinker’s ‘rights revolution’ argument seriously, it is not just legal rights that matter, but the personal security of marginalised individuals. Since gender and gender identity is not a binary but a fluid and multifaceted spectrum, just looking at women as an indicator of changing norms or progress does not work. It is not just that declinist feminisation scholars omit homosexuality (because Pinker includes homosexuality within his rights chapter), but that the rise of women cannot be a stand in for gender progress. It has to be the rise of all people that ‘fail’ to live up to the hetero-masculine norms.
Among the many insecurities and violences we should then be very alarmed at includes the ongoing and quite likely rise of violence against the lgbtq and hiv-affected community in the us, Russia, and elsewhere.101 Even if lgbtqi rights are more secure, particularly in the West, they are still tenuous. Furthermore, rights, like the legal right to marriage, says little about social acceptance and being free from mental and physical harm. In order to illustrate the difference between secured rights and individual insecurity, the yearly publication of ‘The Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Map of World Laws 2015’ by the ilga is useful.102 The map colour codes each states based upon the strength or weaknesses of their laws recognizing gay rights. ‘Recognition’ is shaded in green—the darkest (highest) green indicates the right to marry or full recognition of same-sex unions. ‘Persecution’ is shaded in a red-scale that fades to yellow. Additional symbols are added to various countries: an exclamation mark in a triangle indicates ‘anti-propaganda laws’; a question mark in a triangle indicates unenforced death penalties; and a shield indicates laws that prohibit discrimination. Finally, a pale citrine colour is used to denote countries without specific legislation. Dark green states, those that recognize marriage or the equivalent, include all of North America, Uruguay, Argentina, Europe, Iceland, and South Africa. Yellow countries with anti-propaganda, or homophobic or homonegative propaganda towards non-binary people that encourages discrimination, but without other legislation persecuting on the basis of sexual orientation is imited to Russia and Lithuania. Algeria and Nigeria are a pale red but with a warning of anti-propaganda laws. India, Tanzania, and Guyana are a mid-tone red as they have laws that could mean imprisonment from 14 years to life for homosexual behaviour. The dark red states include Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Sudan, and Mauritania. Afghanistan and Pakistan have a non-implemented death penalty whereas Iran’s death penalty is carried out by non-state actors. Therefore, rights for the lgbtqi community are globally unsettled, but the main focus on ‘rights’ and particularly the securing of the right to marry are, in some ways, red herrings as the rights mask the continued violence against lgbtqi folk.