Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

2AC – Security – FW

Our framework is necessary to open up new pathways to solve complex security threats through citizen engagement

Bisogno 17 (Raymond Bisogno, June 2017, “Problem Solving in Homeland Security and Creating Policy Conditions For Enhanced Civic Engagement: An Examination of Crowdsourcing Models,” The Journal of the NPS Center for Homeland Defense and Security, ) nihara

This thesis begins with the premise that the world has become a more dangerous and complicated place due to the spread of terrorism, increasingly damaging weather events, and other threats to national and economic security. These threats (in their broadest sense) have become more diffuse, and the challenges the government faces to combat them more complicated. It may not be, at the end of the day, reasonable to expect government to address the entire threat landscape with existing resources alone and leave the public at large essentially unaffected, or perhaps more importantly, uninvolved. The conditions for tapping into citizens’ intellectual capacity for problem-solving, however, may not be present. This thesis explored the potential of crowdsourcing for this purpose, examining cases in various disciplines to discover what worked well and what did not. A principal focus of the research was crowdsourcing experiments and engagement models, as well as a strategy for leveraging technology in these pursuits.

This research did not attempt to identify problem areas (what is broken), dysfunctional programs, or reasons for low engagement. It analyzed the potential benefits of employing crowdsourcing models in homeland security and its related disciplines, using appreciative inquiry to evaluate how existing successful models may open new pathways between government and citizens. These pathways can lead to the generation of knowledge, the exchange of information, and innovation in approaches to problemsolving. In essence, this research focused on what is working well and looked for ways to apply those methods to homeland security organizations.

An examination of crowdsourcing models across a range of disciplines indicated that given the right conditions, citizens are willing and able to effect positive change and solve problems. Moreover, citizens are highly effective at contributing to projects in which they are engaged, such as environmental monitoring, the arts, hackathons, and space exploration. A number of potential homeland security applications emerged as well. These included developing core values for public participation to ensure equity and integrity, rapid production of new ideas for a time-sensitive problems, and broad information collection and reporting in a crisis. In nearly every case, non-professionals needed only the right conditions to be present for them to engage.

What this thesis discovered in the process was connective tissue—ideas for connecting the concepts found across the models examined—to endeavors in homeland security. A key idea discussed in an NPS lecture that also emerged as an observable theme across the research was the notion of viewing government in general as a platform for innovation rather than a mechanism for the provision of services.1 By understanding a citizen’s motivations to engage, government can begin to design more optimal opportunities for that engagement. By also considering business and customer-service sector models, government can discover new ways to increase knowledge and value creation.

In considering implementation of crowdsourcing and engagement models, organizations should consider ethical, legal, and social issues as they develop programs involving citizen contributors. This thesis advanced several specific recommendations intended to begin forming a framework for crowdsourcing in homeland security. First, convene a multidisciplinary commission under the auspices of FEMA and DHS to further explore and advance the issue. Second, have FEMA and/or DHS select several agencies to host pilot programs for crowdsourcing projects. Third and finally, dedicate inquiry and research to incorporating social science curriculum into homeland security education (or viewing homeland security as a social science) to better understand the human aspects of homeland security endeavors.

This research may help contribute to the discourse and literature by providing a theoretical policy framework that embraces non-traditional approaches to meeting homeland security objectives. It may help open new pathways to civic engagement or create the conditions in which that engagement can thrive.

Specifically true for geopolitical threats – inductive reasoning, cognitive flexibility, AND probabilistic analysis of geopolitical events – increases the accuracy of predictions – which solves their offense by checking the excesses of the security complex

Bisogno 17 (Raymond Bisogno, June 2017, “Problem Solving in Homeland Security and Creating Policy Conditions For Enhanced Civic Engagement: An Examination of Crowdsourcing Models,” The Journal of the NPS Center for Homeland Defense and Security, ) nihara

B. CROWDSOURCING FOR FORECASTING GEOPOLITICAL EVENTS

The Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity (IARPA) is the counterpart to the Pentagon’s DARPA. According to IARPA’s website, it invests in “high-risk, highpayoff research programs to tackle some of the most difficult challenges of the agencies and disciplines in the Intelligence Community.”47 IARPA sponsored a competition called the Good Judgement Project (GJP) to explore intelligence matters and the ability of people who are not professional intelligence analysts to forecast global political events. IARPA initially recruited graduate students, faculty, and practitioners from the political science realm.48 While a study from the University of Pennsylvania by Lyle Ungar et al. noted that strong forecasters exhibited higher levels of political knowledge and general intelligence, average citizens with modest training in probability and statistics and no access to classified material were able to predict geopolitical events with a success margin as much as thirty percent higher than career intelligence analysts who did have access to classified material.49 This uneven performance was not due to extraordinary abilities on the part of citizen-participants, nor was it a reflection of the career analysts’ skills; it was an outcome of the laws of probability and statistics. In an April 2014 report on the GJP, National Public Radio (NPR) explains that balancing a wide range of predictions can lead to a more reliable finding “at the center.”50 Philip Tetlock et al., writing about the GJP for the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, assessed forecasts over a two-year period. After more than 150,000 forecasts, 743 participants, 199 events, and two years, they described favorable performance predictors as follows:

The best forecasters … were better at inductive reasoning, pattern detection, cognitive flexibility, and open-mindedness. They had greater understanding of geopolitics, training in probabilistic reasoning, and opportunities to succeed in cognitively enriched team environments. Last but not least, they viewed forecasting as a skill that required deliberate practice, sustained effort, and constant monitoring of current affairs.51

In further examining participants’ profiles, Tetlock et al. explain that the best forecasters “benefitted from working environments with probability training and collaborative teams. And while making predictions, they spent more time deliberating and updating their forecasts.”52 Moreover, the predictors of effective forecasting persisted across multiple data sets.53 Some of the participants, based on their forecasting performance, came to be known as super-forecasters.54 One such “super” was a gentleman named Nick Hare. He noted that his success as a forecaster did not have as much to do with his own body of knowledge as it did with his open-minded approach as well as his ability to apply the scientific method in evaluating the data rather than accept a predefined narrative.55

As noted by Ungar et al., working in groups greatly improves prediction accuracy.56 The question of how to utilize the wisdom of the crowds, this study recognizes, is more difficult to answer than whether or not that wisdom is valuable: “Although the ‘wisdom of the crowds’ and the power of predictive markets are widely recognized, it is less clear how to best make use of that wisdom.”57 An important dynamic the study observes is the risk of group-think when experts are able to discuss their predictions. While the study acknowledges the inverse is also possible—that better arguments can be formed this way—this thesis theorizes there may be a risk of groupthink in homeland security and government enterprises unless outside perspectives are considered due to cultural biases and organizational tendencies. Replicating the GJP in the HSE may represent a viable pathway for the contribution of ideas to help solve the nation’s complicated problems.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.