Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

2AC – Security K – Scenarioplanning

Evaluating conflict dynamics through scenario analysis that applies political-strategic analytical requirements aids development of more rigorous, transparent, and realistic scenarios to avoid militarized crises escalation of hybrid warfare – BUT, does NOT limit effective response

Heath & Lane 19 (Timothy R. Heath, Timothy R. Heath is a senior international defense researcher at the RAND Corporation. Prior to joining RAND in October 2014, he served as the senior analyst for the USPACOM China Strategic Focus Group. He has over twenty years of experience researching and analyzing military and political topics related to China. In addition to his publications with the RAND Corporation, Heath has published numerous articles and one book. Fluent in Mandarin Chinese, he has extensive experience analyzing China's national strategy, politics, ideology, and military, as well as Asian regional security developments. He has a Ph.D. in political science from George Mason Unversity and an M.A. in Asian studies from George Washington University. Matthew Lane, 2019, “Science-Based Scenario Design A Proposed Method to Support Political-Strategic Analysis,” RAND Corporation, ) nihara

CHAPTER ONE

Introduction

How do major conflicts start and how can we tell when a crisis might escalate to a military confrontation? These questions have long confronted U.S. policymakers, but they take on new urgency as great power competition intensifies with China and Russia and flash points fester across the Middle East and elsewhere.1 Understanding the dynamics of crisis escalation and conflict occurrence are necessary to help intelligence analysts and policymakers understand whether particular crises are more or less likely to escalate and how U.S. actions, such as the deployment of additional forces to a crisis, might ameliorate or exacerbate those dynamics. In addition, understanding the underlying causes of crisis escalation and military conflict, and how those dynamics are affected by emergent geopolitical trends, can help defense planners to more effectively anticipate and prepare for potential contingencies.

The challenge of anticipating a military contingency is further compounded by the increasing reliance on ambiguous forms of interstate conflict favored by states like China and Russia that blur the line between military and nonmilitary actions. These tactics, labeled “gray zone” or “hybrid warfare,” often feature state-backed forces who engage in coercive or violent actions but below a threshold that typically triggers U.S. military combat operations on behalf of an ally.2 These tactics allow adversaries to incrementally advance state aims while minimizing the risks of conflict. They also offer the advantage of rapid fielding relevant capabilities with minimal warning to U.S. forces, requiring the United States to act quickly in ambiguous circumstances. Moreover, these tactics, while effective, invariably carry a risk of sparking militarized crisis and subsequently, the potential for escalation to conventional military conflict.

In some cases, hybrid warfare operations could be deliberately planned as when “snap exercises” by Russia disguise movements of military forces.3 If the United States is ill prepared to respond in such cases, there is a possibility that U.S. and Allied forces could be surprised and suffer losses.4 Similarly, the development of artificial islands in the South China Sea effectively masked, until recently, China’s military intentions to gain greater control of the maritime region through a fait accompli.5 These actions threaten U.S. allies and raise the risk that a crisis could escalate into a military engagement that could draw in U.S. forces. The challenge of responding to these threats is compounded by constrained defense resources that have led to reductions in deployed forces abroad. These realities have increased the imperative to accurately anticipate and effectively respond to the threat of conflict in a timely manner.

In this report, we aim to achieve four things. First, we distinguish between politicalstrategic and military decisions in the work of defense planning. We argue that many of the questions regarding the onset of conflict, management of crises, and escalation or de-escalation of conflict are primarily political-strategic in nature and thus have analytic requirements distinctly different from those for military decisions. Second, we explain why the current practice of employing scenarios to support political-strategic decisions is problematic. Current doctrine articulates a rigorous methodology to support military decisions, but guidance on how to develop assumptions and address nonmilitary factors remains largely undeveloped or absent. Accordingly, existing methods favor the development of scenarios that feature problems of opaque methodology, unfounded assumptions, and implausibility when applied to politicalstrategic concerns. These defects not only impair efforts to develop more rigorous analysis to support political-strategic decisions, but they can also impede analysis to support military decisions. Third, we argue that recent findings in social science regarding variables related to crises and conflicts offer the potential to remedy these defects and aid the development of more rigorous, transparent, and realistic scenarios. We survey some of these key, albeit tentative, findings regarding both the structural, or underlying, factors, and the proximate, or immediate, factors responsible for militarized crisis and conflict. Finally, we show how scenario designers can incorporate these factors into more holistic, rigorous, and politically realistic assumptions, a process that we call “science-based structured scenarios.” We also show how these sciencebased structured scenarios can be tailored to flexibly suit the specific needs of defense planners. To illustrate how this methodology might be applied, we provide an example centered on a hypothetical China-Taiwan conflict.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.