Conditioning allies solves – spurs behavior change and causes positive demonstration effects
Melissa Dalton 16, July 2016, assistance secretary of defense for homeland defense and America’s security affairs in the Biden Administration, senior fellow and deputy director of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, manager of the Nuclear Posture Review, M.A. in international relations from the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University, B.A. in foreign affairs from the University of Virginia, “Smart Conditions: A Strategic Framework for Leveraging Security Assistance”, https://csis-website-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/publication/160706_Dalton_SmartConditions_Web.pdf//tyei
The United States provides security assistance to international partners as a means to achieve its foreign policy and supporting defense objectives. These objectives include developing partner nations’ military capabilities to enable them to control territory, building interoperability with U.S. forces, and securing peacetime and contingency access to critical air, land, and sea nodes. 1 Security assistance also aims to deepen political and military relationships that can advance the U.S. foreign policy agenda. The outcomes and second order effects of security assistance cannot be easily separated from policy or politics, because they influence the partner country’s monopoly on the use of violence and thus its cohesion as a state.2
As a result, when the policies of countries receiving U.S. security assistance fundamentally diverge from U.S. interests, the United States faces a dilemma. If it cuts off assistance to demonstrate American displeasure, it may risk losing leverage in working with the partner on other security objectives or broader foreign policy priorities, although that leverage may be ill-defined or overstated. On the other hand, if the United States ignores the policy divergence, it may lose credibility with the partner, as it then becomes difficult to reasonably press for reform while continuing assistance flows. It may also diminish perceptions of U.S. moral leadership, thereby also putting wider U.S. foreign policy objectives at risk in that country as well as internationally. Security services are often the tool of authoritarian governments, and U.S. support for those security services can enable them to continue repressive tactics and reinforce perceptions that the United States is willing to choose a security relationship over the well-being and rights of a country’s citizens.
Conditioning security assistance may provide a middle ground with associated benefits, costs, and implementation challenges. Conditionality aims to leverage partners’ reliance on U.S. aid to incentivize them to take certain steps to reform their behavior and better align their policies with U.S. interests and objectives. Conditioning assistance might also provide positive demonstration effects to curb bad behavior among other foreign partners that are observing Washington’s response as an indication of how far U.S. tolerance may stretch. Interestingly, some empirical research shows that unconditional military aid recipients are less likely than other states to align policies with U.S. preferences.3