Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perm fails- strategic autonomy’s a precondition to EU sovereignty

Grevi 19 (Giovanni Grevi, a Senior Associate Fellow of the European Policy Centre, 7-19-2019, European Policy Centre, "Strategic autonomy forEuropean choices: The key to Europe’s shaping power" )//guyB

Paul Timmers frames strategic autonomy as “the ability, in terms of capacity and capabilities, to decide and act upon essential aspects of one’s longer-term future in the economy, society and their institutions.”28 This paper’s author has argued that strategic autonomy requires “the ability to set objectives and mobilise the necessary resources in ways that do not primarily depend on the decisions and assets of others” and that it rests on four pillars, namely the Single Market, the euro, the capacity for technological innovation and the capacity to provide for Europe’s security.29 In a recent contribution, Mark Leonard and Jeremy Shapiro propose to replace the concept of strategic autonomy with ‘strategic sovereignty’, which subsumes geoeconomic and geopolitical issues within an overarching approach and allows “Europeans to decide their policies for themselves and bargain effectively within an interdependent system.”30 Pursuing strategic autonomy is therefore part of a renewed effort to strengthen the basis for European sovereignty. Taking a step back, the political, institutional and functional components are common to practically all the definitions of strategic autonomy and are relevant to all areas where it can be pursued. Politically, strategic autonomy requires a common understanding of large goals, which is predicated on mutual trust and a sense of shared destiny. In a political system of 28 countries, the EU’s adequate institutions are also crucial in enabling decision-making, setting rules and managing pooled resources in flexible, effective and legitimate ways. The functional dimension includes both the material and immaterial resources that are to be aligned to fulfil major goals and enable autonomous action when necessary, whether they be adequate funds, military capabilities or cutting-edge technological expertise. 11 Strategic autonomy should also be related to the question of European sovereignty and considered a precondition for it, with the understanding of sovereignty as “the ability to control outcomes and respond to the fundamental needs of the people”.31 This is the heart of European integration: sharing sovereignty in some domains to become more effective in its exercise. Pursuing strategic autonomy is therefore part of a renewed effort to strengthen the basis for European sovereignty in changing international and domestic contexts. Given the serious internal and external challenges to Europe’s cohesion as illustrated in this Discussion Paper, the requirements for European sovereignty are not those of the past. In this sense, strategic autonomy contributes to sovereignty in three ways: in terms of responsibility, resilience and peer partnership. Firstly, advancing strategic autonomy implies taking responsibility for Europe’s future to a further extent than is the case today. This requires creating the conditions for Europeans to make shared decisions about critical issues (e.g. the application of new technologies, a sustainable development model, major foreign policy matters) and be equipped to implement them. q Secondly, strategic autonomy is about strengthening the EU’s own resilience to the challenges of globalisation (from financial shocks to massive migration flows) as well as to the political and economic tactics employed deliberately by others to divide Europe. q Thirdly, strategic autonomy is not about isolation, but rather building a stronger platform for cooperation and partnership. In a world where big powers are more assertive, strategic autonomy is necessary to enter into peer partnerships with the heavyweights; and to avoid asymmetric relationships, where isolated EU members lack bargaining power. Concerning the scope of strategic autonomy, this should be assessed against the background of the large shifts and challenges outlined above. As the EU faces multilevel competition – of which economic statecraft, technological prowess and hybrid tactics are critical dimensions –, delimiting the pursuit of strategic autonomy to defence and security affairs is out of sync with the new strategic environment. Strategic autonomy entails the mobilisation of all relevant EU resources to strengthen Europe’s global role, which is, in turn, essential to meet the needs and expectations of its citizens. Two final elements must be stressed to articulate the concept of strategic autonomy as applied to the EU. For one, autonomy is not a binary concept but a matter of degree. Full autonomy is, in many cases, unachievable and not necessarily desirable, but progress can be achieved to make Europe more self-reliant in advancing its interests and values. For another, strategic autonomy takes time. Where Europe lags, such as in completing the Single Market, developing some technological sectors or defence capabilities, it will of course not catch up overnight. However, a clear sense of direction should drive efforts over time, and its progress should be regularly and seriously assessed. Bearing that in mind, some of the building blocks of strategic autonomy are illustrated in the following sections. 4. Strategic autonomy across the board A meaningful approach to Europe’s strategic autonomy should encompass three principal domains – the economy, technology, and security and defence matters. Progress in all three is essential in order for Europe to take more responsibility not only for its security and prosperity, but also for a stable, rules-based international order. The EU agenda for the next five years and beyond should focus not only on advancing strategic autonomy in distinct areas or policy fields but also, and crucially, on taking an overarching approach to strategic autonomy, assessing how progress in some fields (or lack thereof) impacts others. For example, it is hard to envisage the EU maintaining its economic clout and therefore regulatory power if it falls behind the curve of technological innovation. Likewise, the capacity to protect critical infrastructures from cyberattacks is essential not only to the defence and security of the Union but also to its broader economic resilience and competitiveness. Adequate military capabilities to uphold stability in Europe’s extended neighbourhood and protect the openness of the global commons – notably the sea, outer space and cyberspace – are also critical to the security of the flows that Europe depends upon for its prosperity and stability. Furthermore, it is only by taking an encompassing view of strategic autonomy that the EU will be able to leverage it for a larger, positive global agenda and narrative in support of rules-based cooperation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.