Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Specifically true in tech regulation

Grevi 19 (Giovanni Grevi, a Senior Associate Fellow of the European Policy Centre, 7-19-2019, European Policy Centre, "Strategic autonomy forEuropean choices: The key to Europe’sshaping power" )//guyB

Technology has always been a primary source of prosperity and power. Today, new and emerging technologies are reshaping the domains, terms and tools of cooperation and competition on the international stage. Technological innovation is simultaneously accelerating and increasingly diffused. The acceleration of digital innovation particularly creates unprecedented opportunities for sustainable human development and well-being, civic and political participation, and international cooperation. However, it also affects the distribution of power at all levels, expands the grounds for economic and political competition and creates new vulnerabilities. The diffusion of technological innovation to new economic powerhouses and the major advances made by China in key sectors, from fifth-generation mobile technology (5G) to AI, will carry far-reaching implications for economic growth, normative reach, political influence and security in different parts of the world. As noted above, much of the current competition between the US and China is about employing technological primacy as an enabler of international leadership. The EU will fail to advance towards strategic autonomy if it is not at the forefront of both technological innovation and the efforts to regulate the applications of new technologies in ways that are consistent with its interests and values.49 As a recent paper by Timmers put it, “mastery of digital technologies is an essential capability for future competitiveness, protecting society’s values and bridging the ‘sovereignty gap’.”50 From this standpoint, the capacity for technological innovation is also a major requirement for Europeans in order to be able to make basic choices on their future economic and social models, as opposed to living with the choices made by those who drive innovation outside of Europe. For example, in 2018 the European Commission launched a series of initiatives to shape a European 14 approach to AI, directed to not only support technological development but also deal with the impact of AI on labour markets, develop talents and skills, and shape a governance framework for the multiple applications of this emerging technology. The Commission has established a High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence (AI HLEG), tasked with supporting the evolution of the EU approach to the ethical, socioeconomic and legal implications of AI. This Group delivered a report on ethics guidelines for trustworthy AI in April 2019 and another on policy and investment recommendations, including on a suitable governance framework, in June 2019.51 These are the first steps in shaping a distinct European approach to AI, which is essential both to enable Europe’s future competitiveness and to prevent dangerous uses of this technology, such as for mass surveillance. According to some estimates, the application of AI could raise global GDP by 14%, or $15,7 trillion, by 2030. In particular, the economic impact of AI would lift China’s GDP by 26%, that of North America by 14.5%, that of Southern Europe by 11,5% and that of Northern Europe by 9,9%.52 The EU holds strong assets in facing the technological innovation challenge, such as excellent research institutions, a wide pool of talent and a large internal market. According to the Reuters’ list of the 100 most innovative universities in the world, 46 (and eight of the top ten) are in the US, 27 in Europe and 23 in Asia.53 However, there is a need for urgent action in preserving and expanding these assets. Europe has failed to meet the objective of spending 3% of its GDP on research and development (R&D), with investment at around 2% (about the same share of GDP as in China) in 2017; compared to 4.2% in South Korea, 3.3% in Japan and 2.8% in the US.54 The competition for global talent is in full swing between academic institutions and corporate actors, while the Single Market is failing to deliver its full potential, whether through larger access to venture capital or the free flow of digital services. Besides, the EU is falling behind major competitors in the US and China on various fronts of innovation.55 The EU holds strong assets in facing the technological innovation challenge, such as excellent research institutions, a wide pool of talent and a large internal market. China is leading in setting the standards for 5G, even though EU companies such as Nokia and Eriksson have a strong track record too. Furthermore, China benefits from the largest domestic market in the world, which will in turn generate massive volumes of data, further empowering Chinese companies in the digital economy. Europe’s delay in the development of a competitive 5G industry implies that EU countries will face problems concerning both the security of their networks – as the current controversy surrounding Huawei shows – and the control of the data generated by hyper-connected economies and societies.56 These are both central requirements for strategic autonomy. When it comes to AI, China and the US are leading in R&D and host the largest shares of high-value AI start-ups by far. The more advanced AI is, the more performing the millions of devices connected through the IoT will be. In 2018, the EU was home to 132 of the 500 most important IoT companies in the world, while 236 were based in the US and 27 in China.57 Low levels of venture capital are another major obstacle. Despite growing quite fast in the last five years, venture capital in Europe stood at only $17.6 billion in 2017, against $71.9 billion in the US and $70.8 billion in Asia.58 Besides, the average size of venture capital funds in Europe is €60 million – half the US average – and they mostly operate within individual member states.59 The scarcity of growth funding for companies past the launch phase is particularly problematic, as promising European digital start-ups are often acquired by non-EU (mostly American) companies and funds. Supporting Europe’s technological leadership and therefore strategic autonomy will require decisive action at three levels: Firstly, Europeans should decide what priorities to concentrate their resources on, from fundamental research to the full innovation cycle. A recent report by the High-level Strategy Group on Industrial Technologies has updated a previous list of six “key enabling technologies”, defined as the essential technology building blocks underpinning EU industrial leadership. The new entries on this list are AI, digital security and connectivity.60 In parallel, the work of the Strategic Forum for Important Projects of Common European Interest – identifying and supporting strategic European value chains – is one of the vectors of Europe’s fledgling industrial policy approach. Alongside areas of ongoing cooperation on batteries, high-performance computers and microelectronics, six additional areas have been selected for pooling resources. q Secondly, larger resources must be available to support innovation policies. 61 Member states will soon face a moment of truth in the next phase of negotiations on the upcoming MFF, when they will have to decide on the Commission’s proposal to raise the share of the budget dedicated to innovation, including Horizon 2020 (H2020), by over 40%. While this is necessary, it will be equally important to ensure that the EU and national funds and initiatives work hand in hand to maximise impact. This will require better coordination between national strategies concerning the major sectors of technological innovation (e.g. AI), which are often developed in separate national silos. There will also be a need to build on the pilot experience of the European Innovation Council to target the most promising start-ups for funding under H2020. Crucially, Europeans must devise tools to provide more flexible financing to EU firms, particularly 15 high-potential start-ups that struggle to move from the research phase to market access. q Thirdly, the regulatory framework must be updated or even established to enable the deployment and leveraging of new technologies and maximise the advantages of the Single Market, while ensuring security and seeking to establish a level playing field with external partners. As mentioned above, the EU’s experience with the regulation of the free flow of data is a case in point. Besides, the AI HLEG’s recent report fleshes out recommendations for a European approach to the governance and regulation of this crucial set of technologies. It calls for shaping regulation according to different types and levels of risk, reviewing existing legislation across various domains (from civil and criminal law to consumer protection and competition), expanding institutional capacity and expertise and fostering a Single Marker for trustworthy AI in Europe.62 Additionally, building on the March 2019 Commission recommendations on the cybersecurity of 5G networks63, a much stronger pan-European regime should be established to ensure that all member states and providers meet high security requirements.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.