Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

They misunderstand NATO – only the CP solves.

Bennet 18 (Kirk Bennett, 7-5-18, retired U.S. Foreign Service Officer., American Interest, "NATO and European Security in the Trump Era," https://www.the-american-interest.com/2018/07/05/nato-and-european-security-in-the-trump-era/, [AB])

Much of the traditional American reserve toward European strategic autonomy has emanated from a concern that it would be EU-centric and would undermine NATO without actually creating any robust, effective EU alternative. Judging by recent statements from some American officials, this concern persists. It is misplaced, for a number of reasons. First, Western security simply requires a stronger European component, and the question of whether that component wears an EU or a NATO hat is tertiary. Indeed, because of the overlap between EU and NATO membership, there is no reason it could not be dual-hatted. It would be far better, especially for Washington, to have EU-centric security arrangements that could handle a Balkan crisis than to have an impotent NATO-centric Europe that relied completely on the United States for all hard-security measures. Second, European strategic autonomy could hardly undermine NATO more than the resentments engendered by the current imbalance in capabilities and political will. Third, if the Europeans manage to wreck NATO without creating any capable alternative, it is they, not the United States, who will bear the consequences. Donald Trump seems to grasp these considerations, and for all his bluster and seeming hostility toward America’s European allies, he is instinctively the greatest friend of European strategic autonomy ever to sit in the White House.

The rise of Trump prompted the intriguing idea of proclaiming Angela Merkel as the new leader of the Free World. Realistically, however, Germany’s atrophied military capabilities make such a suggestion risible. I remember some 15 years ago hearing Germany described as the Sick Man of NATO. Well, the patient hasn’t shown any improvement in the interim. In the absence of German/European strategic autonomy, Merkel’s devotees might aspire at best to elevate her to the leadership of some postmodern fantasyland devoid of hard-security challenges. Unfortunately, the real-life Europe—with an assertive Russia, unstable borderlands, disruptive immigration, and terrorism—bears little resemblance to such a vision. Moreover, with the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, selfless German multilateralism is very much taking a back seat to German economic interests, at the cost of seriously undermining both the economy and security of Ukraine and Germany’s easternmost EU partners. “Germany First” might not be the slogan, but at least as far as Nord Stream 2 is concerned, it is the reality.

In fact, the Free World would be best served not by having a leader at all, but by having a partnership. It need not be a fully equal partnership with respect to every facet of security, but something must replace the current relationship of radical disproportion and dependency, which is both corrosive and unsustainable. Instead of the United States taking the lead on European security and relying on its European allies as a force multiplier, we need to see Europeans safeguarding European security and calling on the United States as a force multiplier. We must dispense with the pernicious American conceit that Europeans cannot be trusted to manage their own security, and we must rid ourselves of the pernicious European illusion that Europeans need not be bothered to manage their own security. If Donald Trump manages to push us in this direction, he will have earned a hallowed place in Euroatlantic history.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.