Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU guidelines on AI regulation maximize ethical guidance and competition

Smuha ’19 – Natalie A., Legal scholar and philosopher at the KU Leuven Faculty of Law, where she examines legal, ethical and philosophical questions around Artificial Intelligence (AI) and other digital technologies., (“The EU Approach to Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence”, Computer Law Review International Vol. 20; iss. 4; pp. 97 – 106.) – sel

1. The Revival of AI Ethics It is becoming ever more clear that, contrary to the hope some may hold, AI systems are not a miracle solution to all our problems. Rather, much like any type of technology, they represent a double-edged sword that can be used both in a beneficial and in a harming way. To offer but a few examples; AI systems can be used to help us achieving more objective decisionmaking, yet they can also perpetuate and even exacerbate unfair biases. AI systems can be used to offer us more personalised and qualitative services, yet they can also hamper our decisional autonomy. And while AI systems can be used to enhance our security, they can also be deployed as a means of illegitimate surveillance and stifle our freedom. The multifaceted impact that AI systems (along with other modern ICTs) have on our lives – which is not only ethical, but also legal, social, economical, political, cultural and psychological in nature – enables those systems to shift more than one paradigm in our society. The transformative force they exert on the world may not be as brisk and theatrical as some movies portray, but is rather expected to generate changes in more slow and subtle ways, which nevertheless have the potential to alter our habits, processes and lives profoundly. Governments and policy-makers around the world are starting to wake up to these important concerns. Besides adopting national strategies to boost the development and uptake of AI systems to reap their benefits, they are also assessing the technology’s potentially harmful impact and exploring which policy measures are best suited to address it. This occurs not only at national, but also at European level. Indeed, given that the concerns raised by AI do not stop at national borders, coordinated action is needed to tackle them. 2. Europe’s Response In April 2018, following an invitation by the European Council to put forward a European approach to AI5 , the European Commission presented its strategy for AI in the Commission Communication “Artificial Intelligence for Europe”.6 The strategy evolves around three pillars, aiming to tackle AI’s challenges and opportunities through a holistic approach: (1) boosting investments in AI, (2) preparing for socio-economic changes and (3) ensuring an adequate ethical and legal framework. At the same time, the strategy emphasised the need for coordination with Member States, so as to leverage joint efforts and maximise the impact of individual states’ action. This resulted in the adoption of a second Communication in December 2018, containing a Coordinated Plan on AI that sets out around 70 actions that Member States and the Commission have committed to undertake in order to implement the European strategy. 7 To ensure continuity of action, the Plan will be updated on an annual basis. Both of the Commission’s Communications stressed the need to assess the adequacy of existing legal rules to protect individuals from potential adverse effects of AI systems, and to establish ethical guidance to ensure that the development, deployment and use of AI systems do not occur at the expense of fundamental rights and European values. It is against this background that in June 2018 the High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence (AI HLEG) was established. Bearing in mind the holistic approach of the European strategy, the AI HLEG was tasked with the preparation of two deliverables: (1) AI Ethics Guidelines and (2) AI Policy and Investment Recommendations.8 The documents are meant to complement each other. While the Guidelines provide guidance to AI practitioners9 on how they can bring their AI systems in line with ethical principles (on top of any legal obligations they already have), the Recommendations are addressed to European institutions and Member States, offering them advice on which policy measures to adopt in order to ensure Europe’s competitiveness in AI as well as an adequate regulatory framework, beyond ethical guidance. On 8 April 2019, the AI HLEG published its Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy AI. On the same day, the Commission adopted its third Communication on AI within a year, in which it welcomed the work of the AI HLEG and expressed its support for the ethical framework it put forward. 10 This paper focuses on the creation of the AI HLEG “Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy AI”, starting with a contextualisation of their aim and purpose (II). Next, some insights on their drafting process are provided, which spanned not only expert group deliberations, but also over 500 comments received through an open consultation (III). Particular attention is devoted to the questions on the respective role played by ethics and law (IV.), and to the challenges that had to be overcome throughout the drafting process (V). Subsequently, the Guidelines’ next steps are set out (VI), and their relevance against a background of international AI policy-making is examined (VII). Finally, some concluding remarks are offered (VIII).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.