Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU tech autonomy is key to check back against Chinese tech supremacy.

Larsen 20 (Henrik B. L. Larsen, PhD and a Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies (CSS) at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, “Europe’s Awakening to China’s Tech Dominance,“ Harvard International Review, October 2020, https://hir.harvard.edu/europe-awakening-china-tech-dominance/)//JRD

The EU must be a tech superpower in its own right with a far larger number of large companies . The tech industry operates in an oligopolized world market with a handful of suppliers. Europe in most technologies faces a choice between either China or the United States. An exception is 5G where Europe has its own technological superstars, Nokia and Ericsson (the United States, by contrast, has no significant 5G market competitor). The increasing number of country decisions to discard Huawei already gives the two companies a strong foundation on the European home markets.

The EU must come to the realization that the only way to make European tech companies able to compete globally is to allow them to grow into global champions that can innovate at scale. China’s mercantilist methods and proactive promotion of its national tech champions compel a revision of the EU’s original focus to create the best possible conditions for competition on the internal market. It was arguably a strategic mistake when the European Commission  between a German and a French rail manufacturing company (Siemens/Alstom), a manifestation for the EU’s laggardness in prioritizing global competitiveness. The European Commission's decision is especially disconcerting when taking into account the risk of global dominance of Chinese state-owned or state-subsidized enterprises as well as China’s restriction of foreign access to its own domestic market. China-like subsidies can hardly come into question. However, Europe’s consolidated aerospace industry with Airbus stands out as a successful example of the use of infrastructure support, beneficial loans, and the advancement of research and development to gain global competitiveness.

Similar support measures today could boost European tech and manufacturing hubs, beginning with the existing telecom giants that need to remain competitive . Artificial intelligence requires both EU and national investments to  and should aim to , whose strong regulations in favor of ethics and human rights distinguishes it from especially China. The COVID-19 crisis has  about Europe’s digital sovereignty to the level of shortcomings of its own industrial-technological base that hinder its ability to innovate and compete at the global level. Building on this awareness, export control should become more strategic to prevent a proliferation of  where the EU still has an edge over China.

Battle over Global Standards

The geopolitical implications of China’s forwardness on 5G caught the Western community by surprise, even though China openly declared its ambition to pursue  five years ago. Chinese innovation is fast—in addition to the allocation of  to its high-tech sectors over the next five years, Beijing later is set to release its new plan ‘China Standards 2035’ to influence : the Internet of things, artificial intelligence, and 5G. The EU, the European countries, and their tech communities need to be forward-looking and understand that the competition with China is also a competition over global standards. Whereas China developed its own 3G and 4G standards to protect its domestic market from external competition, it clearly  with 5G for its own mercantilist advantage. The importance of global standards cannot be stressed enough: the standards for the Internet we use today were set by the leading US companies like IBM, Intel and Microsoft in the 1990s.

Recognizing the importance of standard-setting, the Chinese government and Chinese companies have  in contributing to and leading the global standards-setting bodies, notably the UN’s International Telecommunications Union (ITU) and the industry-led 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP), a key player in 5G. On the one hand it is positive that China, which has  of the 5G “standard-essential” patents, is engaged in the global bodies to set common standards. On the other hand, China could potentially  to give its own companies first-mover and perhaps a permanent advantage. The Chinese companies are under  and  by the Chinese Communist Party to vote against technologically superior standards when they disadvantage the Chinese industry. Shedding light on and pushing back against China’s practices requires global leadership. The EU, its member states, and tech companies need to  in the standardization bodies to maintain their still strong positions and ensure that the processes are politically neutral and that technologies remain interoperable.

The alternative to global standards may be competing standards that could divide the digital economy and, in the long run, underpin a beginning bifurcation between an old Western-led and a new China-led order. Not to forget, China  to its activism in the global bodies facilitates the deployment of its own standards bilaterally through the “Belt and Road” and other initiatives. It is hardly surprising that the consolidated autocracies around the world follow China’s technological leadership. However, it is worrying that the developing nations in Asia, the Middle East, and Africa tend to tag along, as they  and because China’s  satisfies their growing appetite for inexpensive connectivity.

The EU must adapt to what seems to be a new reality: the “”—the externalization of its regulations and norms through market mechanisms—works well within liberal democracies that cherish privacy protection and human rights as well as with the big tech companies that operate within them. However, the “Brussels effect” may not provide a crucial pull or competitive edge in the rest of the world’s digital economies. China’s cooperation with Greece, Hungary, and especially  speaks volumes about how easily even relatively well-developed countries in Europe fall for the temptation of the cheaper and faster rather than the safer tech options. Even if other countries have adopted legislation in line with the General Data Protection Regulation—the prime example of European rule setting—the reality of the digital economy is such that the EU cannot assume that the world around will purchase equipment with adequate safeguards to guarantee these rights. In short, the EU will need a more activist approach to promote its own standards and norms going forward.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.