Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU-NATO cooperation is key to cyber security.

Shea 19 (Jamie Shea, Senior Fellow at Friends of Europe and former Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges, “EU-NATO COOPERATION A SECURE VISION FOR EUROPE,” Spring 2019, https://www.friendsofeurope.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/dp_2018_web.pdf)//JRD

To strengthen inter-organisational cyber security and cyber defence cooperation, the EU and NATO should solve the political blockage, develop joint action plans to be implemented by member states and do away with technical issues such as the lack of formal agreements between institutions. The work done at staff-to-staff level must now be replicated at the national level by launching and investing in joint activities and projects that will increase member states’ capabilities. While top representatives spoke of ‘prioritising strengthened cooperation’ at the 2016 and 2018 NATO summits, more should be done to generate investments from the capitals. The following policy proposals aim to designate a number of joint activities with an aim to create more substantial cooperation among the member states of both organisations. A strong political support and prioritisation is necessary also from the key capitals. First and foremost, an EU-NATO working group on cyber security and defence issues must be established. These topics must also be regular agenda items in other joint working and high political level meetings, such as the EUNATO capability development group and the NAC-PSC meetings. This new working group should discuss policy themes where closer cooperation can create synergy (synchronising crisis response mechanisms, speeding political decision-making, developing joint response options to cyberattacks, etc). Joint working groups at the subject matter expert level should explore possibilities to develop joint research and innovation programmes and coordinate national and union-level activities in the area of emerging technologies (including 5G and artificial intelligence). Joint education and training courses should be created with the first step of opening all existing courses to each other’s officials and member states. The EU must be granted observer status at the Steering Committee of NATO’s Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCD COE), as suggested by the Allied Command Transformation. Formal cooperation – including technical arrangements for information sharing – must also be established with ENISA and other relevant EU bodies (such as the Cybersecurity Research and Competence Centre and EU-CERT) in order to facilitate participating in each other’s exercises. Closer cooperation between research and competence centres is needed to jointly develop doctrine and concepts, and launch common research projects in areas such as cyber activities in the grey space, supply chain security, military dependencies on civilian critical infrastructure (such as energy, transport and finance), including how do develop common methodology to assess inter-dependencies. The NATO Cyber Defence Pledge could also be applied to non-NATO EU countries and possibly in third countries. The resiliency requirements and cyber security standards of the EU and NATO should be complementary and ensure the minimum common level of protection in all countries. Information sharing between the organisations has been improved but more should be done to create joint threat assessments and intelligence sharing for attribution of cyberattacks. The EU and NATO should continue synchronising their hybrid threats playbooks with a view to creating joint responses. They must also synchronise cyber defence capabilities development roadmaps and experiences on improving civilmilitary information sharing. One way forward is through joint EU-NATO joint exercises, be they technical, crisis management or table-top style. The table-top exercises at the subject matter expert and ambassadors, foreign and defence ministers level should explore the application of EU’s cyber diplomacy toolbox and joint response options. More joint action is also needed to promote the application of international law, confidence building measures, and state responsible behaviour in cyberspace. Both organisations should create common cyber capability building programmes, including joint trust funds, for the third countries. In the area of cyber defence, the EU and NATO should explore options on how to use the sovereign effects of the NATO Cyberspace Operations Centre with a view to support future EU missions and operations. PESCO’s recent ‘Cyber Rapid Response Team’ initiative – comprised of nine participating EU member states – could be deployed to assist non-EU NATO countries and third countries to prevent, detect and respond to cyber incidents.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.