The CP solves the entirety of case and creates broad EU-NATO coop – tech is key.
FOE 21 [Friends of Europe, Peace, Security & Defence Summit 2021 — Autumn 2021. “Strategic foresight: a zero-sum game? The EU Strategic Compass and NATO 2030” https://www.friendsofeurope.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PSD-summit.pdf DOA: 6/24/2022 //ArchanSen]
Building up defence capacity must focus on innovation, as new technological developments, such as artificial intelligence, hypersonic weapons, quantum warfare and increasingly complex cyber threats, present a growing challenge, the summit was told.
“Our competitors are shaping the environment, they are competing every day, the threats are permanent, they are boundless, and they are simultaneously used … we have to manage that,” cautioned General Philippe Lavigne, NATO’s Supreme Allied Commander Transformation.
“We need more and more innovation to adapt faster, to be agile and we need innovation coming from our societies, open innovation, in order to continue to get the advantage,” he said in a pre-recorded interview from Allied Command Transformation in Virginia.
The technology is moving fast and although NATO has what Lavigne called “the best military thinking package in a generation”, it still has to accelerate change to keep ahead of its rivals amid an increasingly complex tech landscape.
“The new plane will not be a new plane in the future. It will be a system of systems, it will be sensors linked to platforms, linked to space, linked to multi-domain. That’s collaborative welfare,” the general explained.
However, there was a word of caution against over-reliance on technology from Ian Bond, Director of Foreign Policy at the Centre for European Reform in London.
“Russia’s seizure of Crimea was low-tech; the Taliban’s victory in Afghanistan was no-tech,” he wrote on the summit’s chat line. “How does NATO avoid reliance on vulnerable technology like GPS, satellite comms and space-based sensors and how does it ensure that it can defeat adversaries that don’t rely on superior technology but on better tactics?”
Speakers underscored the importance of working with the private sector to ensure the latest technology is available to defend against offensive threats from authoritarian regimes and rogue players.
“We have complex issues to solve and the world is volatile, and it is in a state of disarray,” cautioned Jane Frankland, award-winning leader, best-selling author, speaker and women’s activist.
“National, international and online threats are becoming progressively integrated as our enemies develop new means to exploit vulnerabilities across borders, and between the cyber and physical worlds,” she added, naming China, North Korea and Iran among the countries developing more effective offensive cyber capabilities. “We have more threats, more costly breaches, and the speed and intensity of these attacks continue to challenge every part of our ecosystem.”
Technology presents a “great opportunity” for further EU-NATO cooperation, said Andrea G. Rodríguez, Research Fellow at the Barcelona Centre for International Affairs (CIDOB). She welcomed the Alliance’s push to set up the Defence Innovation Accelerator for the North Atlantic (DIANA) by 2023 to provide a network of technology test centres and accelerator sites to harness civilian innovation for security. It could cooperate fruitfully with the EU’s proposed innovation hub within the European Defence Agency, Rodríguez said.
Innovation efforts should focus on quantum computing, AI, hypersonic and some bio technologies, she added, “the technologies keeping me up at night”.
“We are entering a time in which everything is hyper-connected,” Rodríguez said. “With quantum computing and quantum communications and other quantum applications that may emerge, it will be like going to war with horses, instead of like going to war with tanks, because the capacity lead will be so big,” she cautioned. “The first one who gets it will have a strategic advantage. That’s something that, as NATO or as Europe, … we shouldn’t let happen.”