EU strategic autonomy requires a willingness to engage —Key to EU-India relations
Lannoo 19 (Karel Lannoo is the Chief Executive Officer and Stefania Benaglia is Associate Researcher at CEPS. CEPS Commentaries offer concise, policy-oriented insights into topical issues in European affairs., “Could the EU and India jointly shape the world?”, https://www.ceps.eu/could-the-eu-and-india-jointly-shape-the-world/)
For the EU-India strategic partnership to reach its full potential, the EU needs to act as one in its foreign policy relations. The EU needs to convince its members of the added value of being the main – if not the sole – interlocutor for India, and demonstrate the limitations of bilateral relations. To persuade India of the benefits of dealing with the EU as a collective actor, the EU should leverage its soft power. The EU is finally beginning to grasp the importance of strong and coordinated public diplomacy and efforts to restructure and intensify it are ongoing. However, now is the time to define clear objectives and strategies to obtain them. Member states need to allow the EU the necessary strategic autonomy for it to take the lead in coordinating their actions in India. Moreover, for the EU to defend multilateralism, it needs to live up to it, which means some painful changes for its members in giving up their primacy at the table of multilateral organisations such as the IMF or the UN. Meanwhile, beyond the imminent appointment of a military attaché to the EU mission in India, the EU needs to shed its reluctance as a global security actor and work together with India on security cooperation. The Indian administration barely considers the EU as an actor, focusing its attention more on individual member states (notably UK, Germany and France, and, more recently and to a lesser degree, the Eastern countries). India turns these bilateral relations to its advantage in striking deals on better terms, playing on the occasionally prickly competition between member states. The strongest competitors of EU Members for tapping into Indian potential are Russia, the US, and China. Without robust and coordinated EU engagement, bilateral relations between EU member states and India may survive, but they will not thrive. There is, for example, no de-facto European chamber of commerce in India, only some national chambers. For the relationship to be deepened, both sides will need to take significant steps. The EU has to prove its added value, but the Indian government also has to act. India’s external trade position is still in its infancy. Its trade and regulatory environment remains relatively restrictive, with discriminatory and diverging standards. Its central government has limited powers, possibly even less than the EU. Many competences remain with its 29 states, which restricts its capacity for outreach. India has also a very limited external presence, with less than 1,000 diplomats abroad – similar in number to those of the Netherlands with a population of just 1% that of India.