Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The CP is going to inevitably happen – the aff isn’t key.

Csernatoni 19 [Raluca Csernatoni, PhD in International Relations from Central European University, 2019. The EU’s Technological Power: Harnessing Future and Emerging Technologies for European Security. Peace, Security and Defence Cooperation in Post-Brexit Europe, 119–140. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-12418-2_6 DOA: 6/20/2022 //ArchanSen]

This comes at a moment when National Defence Technological and Industrial Bases (DTIBs) in Europe have increasingly come under pressure to produce competitive defence capabilities, due to budgetary restrictions and defence market forces. There is no denying the fact that the centre of gravity for security and defence technology R&D and innovation has shifted from the national and military levels to the corporate and civilian ones, because of a variety of factors, such as economic austerity reasons and the sharp decline of national defence R&D investment programmes in the post-Cold War period in Europe. In this regard, the maintenance of a strong EDTIB was set out to become a top mission for the EDA and the European Commission, by improving security and defence capabilities, the military expenditure of member states and by focusing on enhancing European security via the development of innovative and competitive high-end technologies.

Political will has been developing in the EU concerning high-tech security and defence capacity build-up, as demonstrated by the policy initiatives and strategies recently spearheaded by the EDA and the European Commission to empower the European defence technology and innovation sectors. The rapprochement between the EDA and the European Commission has increased significantly as shown by their combined efforts to converge national strategic needs and advocate for a more coherent pan-European common defence policy. The 2016 policy initiatives, the Implementation Plan on Security and Defence (SDIP) and the European Commission’s European Defence Action Plan (EDAP), are prefiguring a new practice of collaboration between the EDA and the Commission to create a stronger European defence market, to revitalise the European defence industrial base and to encourage member states to spend more on defence research and emerging technologies. The European Commission’s launch of the Preparatory Action (PA) on CSDP-related research and in partnership with the EDA as the hub of defence research is indicative of such moves. The PA is a support programme in the form of a one-off and of limited duration budget (Crespo 2015), which shifts financing opportunities for the European defence industries from EU member states to the EU per se.

The European Commission has proposed the PA back in 2014 for testing the added-value of CSDP-related research within a permanent EU framework, outside the limits of the Horizon 2020—The EU Framework Program for Research Innovation type of civilian or dual-use R&D programmes. At the time, if proven successful in the time-frame of 2017–2019, the PA was heralded as a potential game-changer in the field of European defence research, paving the way for permanent funding from the part of the European Commission to support CSDP-related research. In an unprecedented strategic move, it also opened the EU financing machine for defence technologies research and development beyond the limiting constraints of civilian or dual-use R&D and Research and Technology (R&T) under the structural funds such as the Horizon 2020. The European Defence Fund (EDF), presented in the European Commission’s EDAP from 30 November 2016 is case in point, becoming the first supranational financial tool to directly and exclusively fund cross-border European defence research projects, with a view to developing innovative and high-end security technologies.

In light of the above, a clear and resolute direction can be observed, with conclusive steps taken in strengthening, deepening, and widening the EU-level defence collaboration. There is no denying the fact that the European Commission has had an agenda-setting role, taking important steps to improve efficiency and cooperation in the defence sector: it increased its efforts to complete the Single Market for defence; it strengthened the competitiveness of the European industry; and it bolstered the European defence research by maximising synergies between civilian and military research (European Commission 2014). These steps are also achieved through the SDIP and the EDAP, the European Commission and the EDA working closely together with member states to outline these initiatives. By taking into account such developments, the chapter proposes a two-tiered research strategy, by first exploring the emergence of a European trans-sectoral security field via a new configuration of power relations and a convergence of interests at the intersection of different national, supranational and corporate levels in the case of future-oriented and high-tech research and development. Second, it examines the role of EU-led innovation and governance of such technologies in the specific cases of artificial intelligence and autonomous robotics. The chapter builds on an interpretive methodology that mobilises qualitative content analysis of various types of textual data, such as official discourses, key reports, policy documents, speeches and declarations, press releases, academic research, grey literature from think tanks and expert evaluations. Consequently, the chapter investigates the EU’s agenda-setter potential as a key driver in galvanising the European high-tech and defence sectors to bridge the technological-innovation gap across intergovernmental-supranational, civil-military and public-private nexuses in Europe to bring about a ‘European comprehensive approach’ to future and emerging security technologies. In doing so, it also problematizes the possible implications of Brexit on the European governance and development of future and emerging technologies. Finally, it highlights the EU’s efforts in translating technological innovation in these fields into a potential governance edge and the transformation of the EU into a technological powerhouse.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.