Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Jurisdiction: vagueness means that you vote negative even if the violation is minor

Shannon 2 – Professor of Law

(Bradley Scott, Associate Professor of Law, ARTICLE: ACTION IS AN ACTION IS AN ACTION IS AN ACTION, Washington Law Review, January, 2002, 77 Wash. L. Rev. 65, pg. ln)

The first answer to this question is, why should we not care? If proper terminology (of whatever type) is readily available and comprehendible, why should one not want to use it? Does one really need a reason for not misusing any word, technical or otherwise? In other words, though many misuses of Rules terminology might not seem to cause serious problems, surely that is not an argument in favor of a disregard of proper Rules terminology, particularly where the cost of using proper terminology is negligible. n79 The second answer to the question why we should care about the use of proper Rules terminology goes to the cost of using improper terminology even in seemingly trivial contexts. Understanding legal concepts is difficult enough without the confusion created when an inappropriate term is used to represent those concepts. And this is true regardless of how minor the misuse. In some sense, every misuse of legal language impedes the understanding - and, consequently, the progress - of the law. There are at least two additional reasons, somewhat unique to the law, why one should always strive to use proper Rules terminology. The first reason relates to the nature of the Rules as law (or, as some prefer, a source of law). Many bodies of professional terminology might be considered in some way authoritative, in that reliance thereon not only is widespread, it is almost viewed as compulsory. n80 But the Rules [*86] essentially are of the same character as a federal statute. n81 And despite the fact that there is often no direct penalty for the misuse or disregard of Rules terminology, n82 the Rules, by their nature, nonetheless command respect and, in some sense, obeisance. n83 Another reason for using proper legal terminology goes to persuasion. As most good attorneys know, using proper procedural terminology is almost as important as using the Rules themselves properly, as the use of proper terminology enhances the perceived credibility and competence of the proponent, and helps convey the image of the proponent as the giver of the truth. n84 Though this is probably true of every profession, the [*87] stature of argument, and thus of persuasion, in legal discourse magnifies its importance in the law. n85

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.