Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The DOD CAN do ‘security cooperation’ and ‘security assistance’ under Title 10 and Title 22

Congressional Research Service ’16 [08/23/16; "DOD Security Cooperation: An Overview of Authorities and Issues," CRS, https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R44602.html#_Toc459893458 //smarx, AZG]

Over the past decade, the increasing scope, pace, and cost of Department of Defense (DOD) security cooperation missions have raised many questions about appropriate DOD and State Department roles and responsibilities in and the utility of such efforts. For some policymakers, DOD's new and expanded missions enable the United States to meet the challenges of the complex global security environment more effectively. As such, congressional approval of new DOD security cooperation statutes represents a necessary response to perceived shortcomings of the overarching legal regime through which, for more than 50 years, Congress has largely authorized and funded the State Department to lead and DOD to administer security assistance to foreign countries. Other policymakers, however, question whether DOD's growing emphasis on and authority to conduct security cooperation missions undermines the State Department's lead role in assisting foreign security forces and "militarizes" U.S. foreign policy.

Since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, Congress has given DOD increasing authority to conduct a wide array of security cooperation programs under Title 10 of the U.S. Code, which governs the organization and operations of DOD and U.S. military forces, as well as through the annual National Defense Authorization Acts. DOD may conduct activities such as training, equipping, and otherwise supporting foreign military forces to fight terrorist groups or to enable them to participate in coalition or other operations. DOD may also conduct humanitarian assistance, military and government educational programs, and other initiatives to assist foreign militaries, as well as their governments and populations. Such activities are intended to encourage better relations between DOD personnel and representatives from foreign militaries, governments, and populations.

This report provides a general overview of current DOD Title 10 authorities to assist foreign governments, militaries, security forces, and populations funded by the DOD budget. It presents background information on the evolving DOD security cooperation mission and the recent development of the statutory framework through which DOD conducts security cooperation activities. It provides summary overviews of nine categories of security cooperation assistance and activities, including the amounts of congressionally authorized funding, where available, and any legislatively required State Department input.1 It discusses recent issues related to the development, implementation, sustainment, and coordination of security cooperation to support continuing congressional oversight. Two tables in the appendix provide information on current Title 10 security cooperation authorities. The first catalogs current security cooperation authorities, noting legislative mandates for State Department input and notification and reporting requirements. The second provides a snapshot of authorized and/or appropriated funding levels for select security cooperation authorities.2

Congress has several avenues of influence in the design, implementation, and oversight of U.S. security cooperation activities. Congress determines which activities and operations will be conducted, and it provides input on the selection of recipient countries, organizations, and groups. It defines the division of labor between DOD, the State Department, and other agencies, including specifying the modes of interagency collaboration. It determines the levels of assistance and appropriates funds. In addition, Congress sets conditions on how the funds may be used and, through its committees, oversees security cooperation activities by instituting reporting and assessment requirements.

Terminology: Security Assistance and Security Cooperation

"Security assistance" and "security cooperation" are two terms that refer to U.S. activities to train, equip, and otherwise assist foreign partners. The term security assistance is a generic term used throughout the U.S. government to describe assistance provided to foreign military and security forces, regardless of the agency providing that assistance. However, DOD uses the term security assistance to refer specifically to assistance provided under Title 22 authority, funded with monies appropriated to the State Department and managed by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA), an agency under the Office of the Secretary of Defense, Policy.3

DOD defines "security cooperation" as a broad set of activities undertaken by DOD to encourage and enable international partners to work with the United States to achieve strategic objectives. Included in the definition are DOD interactions with both foreign defense and foreign nonmilitary security establishments. Security cooperation includes all DOD-administered security assistance programs that (1) build defense and security relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, including all international armaments cooperation activities and security assistance activities; (2) develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations; and (3) provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to host nations.4 According to DOD, security assistance is a subset of DOD's security cooperation portfolio.

Authority for DOD to conduct security cooperation activities is enacted in two primary places: Title 10 (Armed Forces) U.S.C. and National Defense Authorization Acts.

Background

The DOD role in U.S. assistance to train, equip, and otherwise support foreign military (and at times other security) forces has evolved over recent decades. Since military aid became a major component of U.S. foreign assistance to counter the rise of the Soviet Union after World War II, the State Department has historically exercised the lead in security assistance activities.5 Since 1961, Congress generally authorized military and other security assistance under Title 22 of the U.S. Code, funded it through the State Department budget, and charged the Secretary of State with responsibility to provide "continuous supervision and general direction" to ensure its coherence with foreign policy.6 With certain exceptions, security assistance was largely a secondary DOD mission.

Beginning in the 1980s, Congress began to expand gradually the scope and character of the statutory framework by authorizing DOD to directly train, equip, and otherwise assist foreign military and other security forces through new provisions in annual NDAAs, some codified to Title 10 of the U.S. Code. Following the September 11th attacks, U.S. government periodic planning documents indicated that the changing security environment presented a new set of challenges.7 Instead of combating nation-states, the U.S. military would increasingly face networks of non-state actors in areas where the United States was not necessarily conducting combat operations. To achieve success in these areas, successive Administrations judged that countering decentralized networks of violent extremists would require long, complex operations involving the U.S. military, other government agencies, and international partners.8 Accordingly, many in DOD and elsewhere maintained that the U.S. military needed to adopt an indirect approach that increased partner capacity (better known by the term "building partner capacity," or BPC) for a variety of purposes, to include: the more effective prosecution of counterterrorism operations, increasing the capacity of states to manage their own regional security challenges in order to prevent an eventual U.S. or international crisis intervention, and as an exit strategy for post-9/11 military campaigns.9 To implement such concepts, DOD requested that Congress grant new authorities to build the capabilities of partner nations and enhance interoperability with U.S. forces, some of which Congress granted.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.