Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

C/I---NATO is an independent international organization with international legal personality---that means it’s separate from its member states---prefer the best comparative ev.

David Nauta 17, 11-10-2017, "The International Responsibility of NATO and its Personnel during Military Operations", https://brill.com/view/book/9789004354647/B9789004354647_004.xml, Brill, Chapter 5, accessed 7-8-2022 \\SYang

This chapter examined the existence of international legal personality of NATO. Legal personality is relevant to the responsibility of NATO and its personnel during military operations. Without international legal personality, NATO cannot be responsible. Unfortunately, there is little jurisprudence on the concept of international legal personality. In 1949, the ICJ formed an Opinion on the personality of the un, but remained vague on how this was determined. This resulted in various theories on how legal personality is acquired. The two mainstream theories in academic literature are the ‘subjective theory’ and ‘objective theory’, which both give explanations on how international legal personality can be determined to exist, but also have received criticism. The practical approach of Klabbers’ ‘presumptive personality’ reconciles to some degree both theories.88 This theory presumes the existence of international legal personality of an international organization if it performs acts that can only be explained on the basis of international legal personality. This chapter has examined NATO’s legal personality on the basis of the two mainstream theories, but also inclined towards the ‘presumptive theory’ to give a practical answer. Some authors doubt whether the Alliance has legal personality.89 These authors argue that NATO has not acted on the international level. The often-used example in this respect is the compensation by the us (in lieu to NATO) to China for the damages suffered during NATO’s intervention in Kosovo. Other arguments denying the international legal personality of NATO is the fact that NATO takes its decision by consensus, leading to believe that the Alliance does not have any “will” of its own. These doubts would be to some degree valid, if the focus was on the earlier years of the NATO. During the Cold War – and probably during its first non-article 5 operation as well – it may have been difficult to consider that the Alliance has international legal personality. NATO’s static defence operations against the former Soviet Union did not require an autonomous role separate from its member States. The member States were fully capable to independently devise military plans and coordinate these with each other. The establishment of SACEUR in 1952, which integrated military forces, marked the beginning of a transformation, but NATO started to evolve into an organization with legal personality only after the Cold War. Since then, the Alliance has gone through a significant transformation, as described in Chapters 3 and 4. The Organization has concluded international agreements with States and other international organizations. NATO and its personnel enjoy privileges and immunities in its member States, but also in Afghanistan, Iraq, in the States of the former Yugoslavia and in various other mission areas. It should not be ruled out that the Alliance might bring and receive international claims in the future if the exercise of the jurisdiction by the courts would be made possible. It is not required that an international organization show all the indicia of international legal personality. If this were the case, barely any international organization would have such status in international law. NATO is presumed to have international legal personality on the basis of the fact that it has concluded international agreements and that the organization and its personnel enjoy privileges and immunities. This presumption may be rebutted if there is evidence to the contrary. Practice of States and international organizations, as well as the jurisprudence of international courts and tribunals, confirm the presumption that NATO has international legal personality. The military intervention in the former Yugoslavia gave rise to several claims for damages resulting from NATO military operations. Yugoslavia filed complaints against several member States of NATO, while individuals turned their claims for damages to individual member States of NATO instead to NATO itself.90 The respondent States in both cases argued that the claims should have been filed against NATO – on the basis of that it had international legal personality – instead of the individual nations. These early cases are not indicative of either the existence or non-existence of international legal personality, but of the absence of NATO’s locus standi in the courts. Claimants may have chosen to start their proceedings against individual States, so to avoid their claim being regarded non-admissible. International courts and tribunals have confirmed NATO’s legal personality. Both the ICTY and the ICC came to this conclusion in relation to NATO operations in respectively the Balkans and Libya. International organizations, including the UN, have addressed NATO in relation to alleged breaches of international obligations binding upon the organization. The UN International Commission of Inquiry, notably, addressed NATO – and not individual member States – with respect to airstrikes in Libya that may have caused incidental loss of civilian life and damage to civilian infrastructure.91 Finally, States have confirmed NATO’s legal personality in the ILC’s commentary to the Articles on Responsibility of International Organizations, where they stated that “NATO is an international organization within the meaning of draft article 2(a) of the draft articles, and as such a subject of international law. It possesses international legal personality as well as treaty-making power”.92 The scepticism regarding the international legal personality of NATO diminished gradually from the 1990s. Academic writers, States and international organization increasingly argue in favour of the Alliance’ status under international law. Even NATO itself had to become convinced of its own personality. The out-of-area operations required the conclusion of Status of Force Agreements (SOFAs) with third States. NATO aptly took the initiative and concluded SOFAs with Bosnia-Herzegovina, Afghanistan, Libya and other countries, thereby affirming its status in international law. In conclusion, NATO certainly meets several indicia of international legal personality as is evidenced by its performance of actions on the international level, notably treaty-making power and privileges and immunities. The existence of international legal personality is – in a way – also confirmed by the practice of States and other international organizations. Recent academic literature furthermore supports this conclusion.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.