Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Consensus goes aff---it’s indisputable that the NATO has ILP---Portugal, France, Ottawa Treaty, and more.

Marten Zwanenburg 5, professor of Law During Military Operations at the Faculty of Law at the University of Amsterdam, April 15, 2005, “Accountability of peace support missions”, https://brill.com/view/title/11419 \\SYang **corrected for typos

There is no similar international judicial authority with regard to the international legal personality of NATO. The constitutive instrument of the organization does not expressly provide that it has legal personality in international law. Explicit recognition is not the only way in which international legal personality is conferred on international organizations. Application of the objective as well as application of the subjective theory of international legal personality leads to the conclusion that NATO is an international legal person." The organization is a permanent association of states established by the 1949 North Atlantic Treaty with the lawful object of collective self-defense. It is equipped with organs, the most important of which is the North Atlantic Council. The functions of the organization are distinct from those of the member states. The most recent statement of these functions is in section 10 of the 1999 Strategic Concept of the organization.'? The organization exercises powers on the international plane, notably treaty-making power. Article 25 of the 1951 Ottawa treaty on the status of the organization for example provides that the North Atlantic Council acting on behalf of the organization may conclude supplementary agreements with member states. The organization also concludes international agreements on other issues with member states" and with non-member states." There is also state practice supporting legal personality of the organization. In the Banliouic case before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) the French government argued that a bombardment during Operation Allied Force was not imputable to its member states but to NATO as an organization with an international legal personality separate from that of the respondent states. The challenge of the admissibility of the case by all the respondent states on the ground that the ECHR would be determining the rights and obligations of NATO itself also points in this direction. This challenge assumes that NATO itself has rights and obligations under international law, which can only be the case if the organization has international legal personality. Trial Chambers of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) have also treated NATO as an international legal person separate from its member states. Trial Chamber I in the Todorovic case ordered the NAC to disclose to the defense copies of documents and the identity of certain individuals in connection with the arrest of the accused." The order was based on article 29 of the ICTY Statute which provides that states shall cooperate with the Tribunal. The Trial Chamber stated that: A purposive construction of the Statute yields the conclusion that such an order should be as applicable to collective enterprises of States as it is to individual States; Article 29 should, therefore, be read as conferring on the International Tribunal a power to require an international organization or its competent organ such as SFOR to cooperate with it in the achievement of its fundamental objective of prosecution of persons responsible for serious violations of international humanitarian law, by providing the several modes of assistance set out therein.?" In the Legality of the Use of Force cases before the IC] several of the respondent states explicitly mentioned that NATO is an international legal person during the hearings held in April 2004. Portugal drew attention to NATO's development since its establishment, in particular the institutionalization of the organization." It maintained that "NATO is an international organisation in the strict sense, with its own international legal personality."> France referred to the criteria for international legal personality identified in the Reparations for Injuries case. It submitted that under these criteria NATO possesses international legal personality." The applicant accepted NATO's international legal personality. However, it maintained that this personality is "limited" on the basis of NATO's founding instrument and other NATO documents.:"

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.