Violation---UUVs aren’t even close to fully autonomous---we’re still in the process of transitioning and developing norms.
Dr. Alix Valenti 22, defense and security freelance journalist for Armada International, January 17, 2022, "Dead Reckoning – Pathways to USV/UUV Autonomy", https://www.armadainternational.com/2022/01/dead-reckoning-pathways-to-usv-uuv-autonomy/, Armada International, accessed 7-11-2022 \\SYang
‘Autonomous’, ‘unmanned’, ‘uncrewed’, ‘lean manning’… over the past few years, the defence world has seen a proliferation of terms emerge to refer to the progressive removal of humans from naval vessels. And, as is usually the case with most buzzwords entering a new domain, most of these terms have been used interchangeably to underpin the evolution of Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) and Unmanned Underwater Vehicles (UUV).
The reality, of course, is far more complex. Behind the concepts of USVs and UUVs lie different levels of autonomy, with different degrees of human involvement for different missions and with each degree of autonomy/human involvement comes a range of operational opportunities and technological challenges.
Unpacking Autonomy
“When we talk about ‘autonomy’ we need to have a common language,” Matthew Hunt, product line director Mine Warfare Systems at Thales, told AI. “This is important because if it is fully autonomous, capable of sensing and reacting to its environment, it is a totally different tool to an automated clockwork system following pre-defined patterns underwater.” Depending on the level of autonomy, the systems will be more or less complicated, will integrate different technologies and may be used in different operational contexts.
In a White Paper titled Navigating the Ethical Use of Autonomous Weapons Systems, published in June 2020, the BMT Group presents an overview of the different levels of control. It draws from the Maritime Autonomous Surface Ships (MASS) UK Industry Conduct Principles and Code of Practice, as well as from a number of other reports, to define six levels: manned, operated, directed, delegated, monitored and autonomous.
“Moving to fully autonomous, however, continues to present fundamental ethical challenges,” said Jake Rigby, research and development lead for Defence and Security at BMT.
For Hunt, it means that these systems must fulfil the three Ts: Trust that the system will work every time the way it is expected to; and, Technology and Time, that is, the ability for navies to quickly adapt to fast-paced technological advances by working closely with industry.
As such, presently, the increasing number of USV and UUV programmes undertaken by tier one navies across the world span across the first levels of autonomy. They feature systems that range from being remotely operated by navy crew to platforms that can be programmed to carry out pre-defined monitored missions autonomously. The latter does not, however, equal full levels of autonomy: the human is still in the loop and the parameters of each mission are very clearly defined in advance. Autonomy extends to navigation, data gathering and data transfer only.