Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The technology doesn’t even exist yet---no takebacks. [WE READ GREEN]

1AC Wilson 19 – J.R. Wilson has been a full-time freelance writer, focusing primarily on aerospace, defense and high technology, since 1992, when he finished a four-year assignment as North American Group Editor for the UK-based Jane’s Information Group. A 1971 graduate of the University of Missouri School of Journalism, he spent eight years with United Press International before joining McDonnell Douglas Astronautics Co. as head of public relations for the space sector. ("Unmanned submarines seen as key to dominating the world’s oceans," Military Aerospace, 10-15-2019, https://www.militaryaerospace.com/unmanned/article/14068665/unmanned-underwater-vehicles-uuv-artificial-intelligence, Accessed 7-1-2022, LASA-SC)

The Spanish and British empires dominated the world in large part by dominating the oceans. Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan were major sea powers during World War II by adding submarines to their surface fleets.

That combination remains the key to sea power today, dominated by the U.S. Navy, with 68 nuclear-powered submarines, 11 aircraft carriers, and more than 450 other ships like destroyers, cruisers, and support ships.

In recent years, China has overtaken the U.S. in numbers, with more than 500 ships, including 75 submarines and three aircraft carriers, of which about half has been built since 2010. Still, China’s open-ocean naval capability lags far behind the U.S. No other navy in the world comes close to the U.S. or China. Now a new era in naval power is emerging — unmanned vehicles.

Nearly two decades into the 21st Century, both nations are putting significant effort into adding autonomous and semi-autonomous platforms to their surface and subsurface naval forces. The underwater realm is the most difficult because of the limitations of underwater communications, which makes some form of artificial intelligence (AI) mandatory.

China has been uncharacteristically open about its intentions for AI, from an announced underwater city inhabited and operated entirely by robots to official government goals of capitalizing on AI to transform their military into the strongest in the world.

While Chinese government spending on AI research is far greater than that of the U.S., however, a large percentage of global effort is coming from the U.S. commercial sector, on which the Pentagon relies heavily for technology advances. Still, Chinese companies also are increasing their AI investments.

The influence of massive spending on developing AI for undersea systems portends the greatest change in military sea power since the introduction of nuclear-powered vessels.

“Equipping our military vessels with a higher-level of artificial intelligence is the answer to the increasing size and complexity of data to be processed as well as the need to reduce staff,” says Dominique Giannoni, an executive at Thales Underwater Systems in Valbonne, France.

China autonomous undersea efforts

In a rare July 2018 interview with the South China Morning Post, Lin Yang, director of a classified program at the Shenyang Institute of Automation in Shenyang, China, says her country has plans to develop new-generation military underwater robots by 2021. His 912 Project’s goal is to develop AI-driven unmanned submarines to handle surveillance, mine laying, and attack missions.

Western China-watchers say the Chinese navy has several AI-enabled vessels in development — with a focus on autonomous submarines — as part of a major push to overtake U.S. dominance in the Indo-Pacific region and beyond. That includes 100-foot long extra-large unmanned underwater vehicles (XLUUVs) intended for deployment early in the next decade.

Another civilian project is China’s most ambitious undersea AI effort to date, with significant military potential. In 2018, China announced it was working on an AI-run underwater base, equipped with autonomous submarines to extend its reach.

According to published reports, the submarines would deploy for investigation and scientific surveillance missions, then return to the unmanned base to download data and recharge. The base itself, located on the ocean floor as deep as 36,000 feet, also would conduct research on the immediate area, process and fuse all collected data, and transmit the results to a surface ship or land station.

No location for the base or a timetable for its deployment have been released, but, given the speed with which China is developing AI across the board, and especially for undersea applications, the first elements are expected in the near future.

While being promoted as a major advance in research on undersea life and topography, the military potential of such long-endurance unmanned cooperative systems cannot be ignored.

China must “grasp the changes of national security circumstances, speed up preparations for military struggle, including battle planning, capacity building and command system building,” Chinese President Xi Jinping said in a speech during a naval inspection in Qingdao, China, according to China Daily.

Russia also is putting considerable effort into AI, but is not believed to be anywhere near the level of the U.S. or China.

U.S. autonomous undersea programs

The 2020 Pentagon budget request cites advances of potential adversaries in asking for major funding increases for autonomous weapons programs. Requests include a ten-fold increase in spending on large unmanned surface vessels by the Navy and more than 50 percent more for Army robotics development. The requests total $3.7 billion on unmanned systems across the services, plus another $900 million on AI.

The Embracing Artificial Intelligence in Undersea Warfare session at the Navy Submarine League’s Submarine Technology Symposium in May summarized the U.S. Navy’s increasing focus on AI — especially undersea:

“As the current submarine force trusts mechanical and electrical technology to execute the mission, the future force will need to trust AI to extract and exploit actionable patterns among an ocean of data,” the session says. “The advent of big data and deep learning technology has rendered signal detection and classification an increasingly automated process. Furthermore, advances in autonomous navigation have enabled unmanned platforms to operate alone or in swarms.

“It will be critical for the 21st century that the undersea fleet advance in its AI capabilities, develop algorithms that are intuitive and explainable, cultivate users’ trust in AI, and design future systems around the use of AI. Meanwhile, we must also recognize our adversaries’ disruptive AI capabilities and develop appropriate countermeasures against them.”

Despite technological strides in AI, unmanned maritime vessels face a host of new and potentially disabling challenges — especially in underwater applications. A 2014 Rand Corp. research paper on Designing Unmanned Systems with Greater Autonomy looked at how AI is being implemented — and researched for future application — across the board for unmanned systems. The report also noted the unique challenges facing UUV autonomy.

“Achieving and maintaining communication with underwater vehicles and even with surface vehicles is technically challenging, especially at longer ranges. Water attenuates radio waves and other wireless signals that can easily be used at long range in air-to-ground or air-to-air communications,” the report stated. “This means that high-bandwidth communications underwater are largely impractical using traditional communication technologies.”

“Although there has been some experimentation with laser communications for underwater applications, laser communications systems are expensive and consume considerable amounts of power. Because of these communications limitations, UUVs that do not require continuous communications links are essential. For example, autonomous path planning is needed to avoid underwater obstacles and unanticipated terrain features.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.