Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Prefer debatability---there’s no expert consensus on the definition of the term---that means there is no most precise definition and you default to evaluating which model is better for debate.

This card includes the section cut for the 1NC/2AC biotech = production card

Elena Myshak 18, linguistic researcher specializing in the term biotechnology, xx/xx/2018, “DEFINITION OF THE TERM “BIOTECHNOLOGY””, https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=884606, published by Editura Pro Universitaria, 2018 issue 4, pg. 142-149 \\SYang

The concept of “biotechnology”

The formation of the terminological system of the innovation-technical discourse is directly related to the term biotechnology, which comes from the Greek words bios — life, techne — art, logos — word, teaching, science. Today, this concept underlies a significant part of innovative research and it is present in the overwhelming majority of scientific papers in this disciplinary segment. The concept of “biotechnology” appeared in our language relatively recently. The term “biotechnology” proposed in 1917 by K. Ereki meant “types of work in which certain products are produced from raw materials using living organisms”. Despite the capacious reflection of the essence of the technology, such an understanding did not stick, and therefore the term was used in two ways for a long time: some used it in connection with the fermentation process, others meant the person and his practical activity in order to optimize tools, conditions and the labor process. Until 1971, this term was used mainly in the food industry and agriculture. At the moment, there are many interpretations of the concept, but in general they all boil down to one thing: in the traditional understanding of biotechnology, this is an interdisciplinary field that has arisen at the junction of biological, chemical and technical sciences; it is the use of living organisms and biological processes in industrial production. Thus, biotechnology is an integration of natural and technical sciences that studies the possibilities of using living organisms and biological processes for the production and processing of various valuable substances and products. Today, biotechnology is among the top priorities of scientific and technological progress, being a vivid example of “high technology”. As noted above, there is no consensus in the literature regarding the definition of biotechnology as a science. M. Bekker (1979) in his book “Introduction to Biotechnology” defines biotechnology as a section of the science of obtaining biosynthesis products. A. Sasson defined biotechnology as a technological process implemented using biological systems – living organisms and living cell components. By definition, the European Biotechnology Federation (1980), biotechnology is the combined use of biochemistry, microbiology and chemical technology for the technological (industrial) use of the beneficial properties of microorganisms and tissue cultures. In other words, biotechnology is a humandirected complex of methods for obtaining society-friendly target products using biological agents of microorganisms, viruses, animal and plant cells, as well as using extracellular substances and cell components. These definitions are mostly correct, but the range of sciences, the practical results of which are embodied in biotechnology is much broader. In 1983, at the congress of the socialist countries on biotechnology in Bratislava, the following definition was made: “biotechnology is a science that develops the scientific basis for large-scale implementation of the processes of obtaining various substances and means of environmental protection using biocatalysts”. At the moment, there is no consensus in understanding biotechnology. It is interpreted as a set of methods and techniques for obtaining products and phenomena that are useful to humans with the help of biological agents; special social activities of human transformation of the world and himself through the use of biological processes and agents; the science “about the methods of obtaining target products using biosynthesis, controlled by environmental parameters or genetic engineering manipulations, or a combination of these effects”. Based on the analysis of existing definitions, it can be concluded that the definition of biotechnology given in the late 1970s is basically correct. As we can see from the presented definitions, the term “biotechnology” has two meanings: on the one hand, it is the science of using biotechnological processes in production, on the other, it is a complex scientific and technical direction that studies these processes. Thus, in the mid-70s of the twentieth century, the term “biotechnology” appeared, which immediately filled in the pages of academic and popular publications. It should be noted that biotechnology science is served exclusively by English terminology, although the development of scientific research in the field of biotechnology is not a priority for the Anglo-American community. The analysis of English biotechnology terminology causes a growing interest of scientists, since it is a young term system, which is at the stage of formation due to the high level of innovation and dynamism of biotechnology. Therefore, the study of the general tendencies of the definition of the term “biotechnology” in the English and Russian languages and its individual features is interesting, in our opinion, from both theoretical and practical points of view. As noted above, the term unit biotechnology (biotechnology), despite belonging to the basic terms of innovative technical discourse, does not have an established definition in either English or Russian. Despite the fact that one of the basic requirements for the term is its uniqueness, examples of definitions of the term unit biotechnology (biotechnology), selected from dictionaries and glossaries, can cast doubt on this condition for the existence of special lexical units. Consider the following definitions: 1) Biotechnology – the use of a living organism to solve an engineering problem or perform an industrial task. 2) Biotechnology is the use of biological processes, organisms, or systems to manufacture products intended to improve the quality of human life. 3) Biotechnology – the manipulation (through genetic engineering) of living organisms or their components to produce useful usually commercial products (such as pest resistant crops, new bacterial strains, or novel pharmaceuticals); 4) Biotechnology – techniques that use living organisms or parts of organisms to produce a variety of products (from medicines to industrial enzymes) to improve plants or animals or to develop microorganisms to remove toxics from bodies of water, or act as pesticides; 5) Biotechnology – the use of bacteria and plant and animal cells for industrial or scientific purposes, for example to make drugs or chemicals; 6) Biotechnology – techniques that use living organisms or parts of organisms to produce a variety of products (from medicines to industrial enzymes) to improve plants or animals or to develop microorganisms to remove toxics from bodies of water, or act as pesticides; 7) Biotechnology is technology that utilizes biological systems, living organisms or parts of this to develop or create different products; 8) Biotechnology: the fusion of biology and technology, the application of biological techniques to product research and development. 9) Biotechnology, the use of biology to solve problems and make useful products. The most prominent area of biotechnology is the production of therapeutic proteins and other drugs through genetic engineering.

Conclusions

As we can see from a small number of examples, the term biotechnology is by no means unambiguous, and the reason lies not only in the difference in the wording and its prevalence, but also in the selection of the relevant features of the concept when creating the definition. In most of the definitions, the definition is based on the use of living organisms or their components for the production of products designed to improve the quality of life of people. Other definitions emphasize that biotechnology is a technology that combines biology and technology that uses biological systems, living organisms or their fragments to develop or create various products. In almost all definitions, the idea of the benefits of biotechnology is expressed, namely: biotechnology is used to obtain useful products for society with the help of biological agents of microorganisms, viruses, animal and plant cells; creating useful products (from drugs to industrial enzymes); to improve plants or animals; to solve engineering and industrial problems, etc. It should be noted that almost all definitions have a different nuclear seme or genus and species trait: science (science); technology; manipulation; techniques; use; area. Such differences in the definition of the key term of the biotechnology sphere confirm the proposition that the definitions of concepts in any science are temporary and, depending on the development of the latter, can be transformed. So, in the presented examples of the definition of one term “biotechnology”, we tried to demonstrate the diversity of definitional variations of the term in its static (vocabulary) manifestation at the initial stage of the formation of terminology, i.e. on the way to the formation of the term system. This fact indicates the dynamic structure of the term, the development of the denotation, the concept and signification. The terminology of biotechnology is not fully formed and needs to be standardized in order to provide the recipient with information about the concept reflected in the definition.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.