Cybersecurity necessitates the use of electronic digital media
Nicholas Bartlett 21, law degree from University of Toledo, “HONING IN ON HARDWARE: DATA SECURITY CONCERNS OF LARGE COMPANIES”, Winter 2021, University of Toledo Law Review, Vol. 52, p. 545 /lg
I magine for a moment that you are interested in computers, and you purchase a couple of old used servers from a company. Once you get home and access the servers, you notice that one of them is completely full of sensitive consumer information. This includes names, addresses, contact information, etc. A few questions should circle your mind at that point. "What do I do now? How did this happen?" Well, in 2006, this actually occurred. Mark Morris, self-described used computer dealer, claimed to have found sensitive data on servers from Ernst & Young. Morris wanted to be paid to remove the data which should have been wiped before he came into possession of the servers, but Ernst & Young simply wanted the servers returned to them. This conflict unsurprisingly resulted in legal proceedings.
This event raises a significant issue: hardware security. Much of the news today revolves around data breaches that occur from hackers or people intruding networks remotely. The general public does not hear much about events like the scenario described above, where someone discovers a server that was not properly disposed of by the company. There are a few possibilities for why this is rarely known, but it is still an important aspect of data security that should be handled with competence. Failure to competently secure company data on hard drives may result in liability either from federal or state securities laws or common law fiduciary duties. The aftereffects of incompetence can be just as destructive as a remote security breach. Hefty fines can be issued if the information was required by law or industry standard to have been retained by the company. Further, the information may end up in the wrong hands. Morris was allegedly receiving offers to purchase the information on the purchased servers for up to $ 1.2 million. It [*546] would not be at all shocking for a court to be harsher on a company who negligently handles their hardware when the entity has complete, direct control over the process as opposed to a data hack by an outsider.
While most of the focus in the cybersecurity context today revolves around protecting the intangible data, directors need to pay equal attention to the physical devices this data is stored on. The Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) should be issuing further guidance specifying this need. This guidance should look similar to state statutes that require companies to develop comprehensive data security practices and procedures.
While many legal scholars have recently focused on liability resulting from data breaches, this note focuses exclusively on hardware and what the SEC should be doing to guide corporations. Specifically, this note will provide a more nuanced look at how large companies should be treating their physical hardware, i.e., servers, hard drives, and the like.
This note will examine what cybersecurity is and the related issues facing companies today. It will then transition to an elaboration on fiduciary duties and their relation to cybersecurity incidents and hardware concerns. A discussion of current federal and state laws will follow, along with examples of guidance from other organizations. Finally, the conclusion will provide a recommendation of how hardware security should be emphasized and what may be missing from federal guidance from the SEC. Specifically, the SEC should issue further guidance and potentially adopt a statute that is designed to meet the concerns related to physical data breaches.
I. BACKGROUND
a. Cybersecurity and Potential Liability
A cyberattack is a willful breach of a company's computer systems and networks. Code is often used to disrupt the normal operations that can compromise sensitive data and result in consequences such as identity and information theft. Cyber threats are constantly changing and require an expenditure of resources to continually update data security departments within corporations. Cybersecurity can be defined as "the protection of investor and firm information from compromise through the use -- in whole or in part -- of electronic [*547] digital media." The phrase "data has been compromised" refers to loss of confidentiality, integrity, or availability of that data. Specifically, a loss of confidentiality indicates disclosure of information, a loss of integrity means the destruction of information, and a loss of availability is the interruption of access to information.
The probability of cyber incidents occurring combined with their impact is referred to as Cyber Risk. Cyberattacks may be carried out in a variety of ways, such as by third parties or company insiders using complex techniques or through traditional social engineering. Attacks can come remotely in a more stereotypical sense similar to what is seen on television or they can come through more personal means by directly interacting with people and gaining information needed to conduct the cyber-attack. There can be many costs and negative consequences associated with a data breach: