Oil wars cause disease, disability, environmental destruction, violence, and humanitarian disasters--extinction.
Klare, PhD, 11
(Michael, Five Colleges professor of Peace and World Security Studies, The Public Health Implications of Resource Wars )
Competition for resources between or within nations is likely to become an increasingly common cause of armed conflict. Competition for petroleum is especially likely to trigger armed conflict because petroleum is a highly valuable resource whose supply is destined to contract. Wars fought over petroleum and other resources can create public health concerns by causing morbidity and mortality, damaging societal infrastructure, diverting resources, uprooting people, and violating human rights. Public health workers and the organizations with which they are affiliated can help prevent resource wars and minimize their consequences by (1) promoting renewable energy and conservation, (2) documenting the impact of past and potential future resource wars, (3) protecting the human rights of affected noncombatant civilian populations during armed conflict, and (4) developing and advocating for policies that promote peaceful dispute resolution. War has enormous tragic impacts on people's lives and the environment. War accounts for more death and disability than many major diseases do. It destroys families, communities, and sometimes entire nations and cultures. It siphons human and financial resources away from health and other human services. It damages the infrastructure that supports the health of society, such as systems that provide safe food and water, electrical power, transportation, and communication. War violates human rights. It uproots people, forcing them to migrate to other countries or to become internally displaced persons within their own countries. It contributes to the spread of infectious disease. The mindset of war—which endorses the notion that violence is the best way to resolve conflicts or disputes—contributes to domestic violence, street crime, and many other kinds of violence throughout the world. War, and the preparation for war, contaminates and damages the environment and uses vast amounts of nonrenewable fuels and other resources. In sum, war damages not only the health of people but also the very fabric of society.1 Wars today tend to be fought within nations (civil wars) instead of between nations. They are fought mainly with small arms and light weapons, and they usually involve attacks on civilians. In the past 20 years, since the end of the Cold War and withdrawal of US and Soviet military assistance to many less developed countries, military forces and armed groups in some countries have had to become more self-reliant, for example by engaging in illicit enterprises and exploiting local natural resources. As the International Committee of the Red Cross has demonstrated, insurgent groups frequently acquire weapons by trading resources (such as minerals) that are under their control, often illegally.2 Such resources have come to be called “conflict minerals” or “conflict resources.” Also in the past 20 years, control over armed forces has become decentralized, with military power deriving from control of resources, arms, or drugs, or from the intensity of fear created in the local population. The US government has recognized a clear link between illegal resource extraction and contemporary conflicts on the one hand and humanitarian disasters with resultant public health consequences on the other. The preamble to Section 1502 of the Wall Street Reform Act of 2010 states: It is the sense of Congress that the exploitation and trade of conflict minerals originating in the Democratic Republic of the Congo is helping to finance conflict characterized by extreme levels of violence in the eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo, particularly sexual- and gender-based violence, and contributing to an emergency humanitarian situation therein.3 In an effort to combat this trade, the act requires US corporations to take appropriate measures to identify the source of minerals used in their products and to eliminate those deemed to be conflict minerals. The sale of diamonds to finance other military activities of this type has contributed to additional humanitarian disasters, prompting additional efforts to curb illicit trafficking. Resource wars are violent conflicts that are largely driven by competition for control over vital or valuable natural materials, such as oil, water, land, timber, animals (or animal products), gold, silver, gems, and other key minerals. Resource wars can occur between states as (1) wars of conquest, in which a state or empire employs force to acquire resource-rich territories or colonies; (2) territorial disputes, in which 2 or more states fight over a border region or offshore territory with valuable resource deposits; or (3) access wars, in which a state fights to gain access to a critical resource deposit in another country. Resource wars can also occur within states, when groups fight for control over key sources of raw materials or over the allocation of the fees and royalties (or “rents”) obtained by governments from private entities that extract resources from areas owned or controlled by the state. A desire to gain control over a valuable resource supply or the wealth it generates is a dominant factor leading to war; however, conflicts over resources are usually driven by other factors as well, such as ethnic animosities and historical grievances.4,5 In the current article, we examine what makes resource wars distinctive and an important issue for public health, and we outline ways in which public health workers and the organizations and professional associations with which they are affiliated can minimize the consequences of these wars and contribute to their prevention. Much of this article is focused on wars fought over petroleum; in a recent commentary we examined armed conflicts over water and what public health workers can do to address them.6 Go to: WHY RESOURCE WARS ARE RELEVANT TO PUBLIC HEALTH We believe that resource wars are relevant to public health because of their profound consequences for public health and because public health workers have potential roles and responsibilities to minimize these consequences and to help prevent resource wars. Public health has been defined as what we, as a society, do collectively “to assure the conditions in which people can be healthy.”7 Resource wars threaten the conditions in which people can be healthy. Although public health is a societal function, it is a function performed mainly by public health workers in government agencies, academic institutions, nongovernmental organizations, and private-sector entities who work to assure the conditions in which people can be healthy. Although most public health workers do not address resource wars, some have the opportunity—and the responsibility—to help document the health consequences of resource wars, to raise awareness of these consequences, and to advocate for policies and programs for minimizing these consequences and for helping to prevent resource wars. Public health has a responsibility to address the fundamental causes of disease and to prevent adverse health outcomes.8 War is a major cause of disease, disability, and death; thus, war is a major public health problem.1,9 The Public Health Oath, which some public health students recite at orientation and graduation, includes the declaration: I will work to ensure that people have the chance to live full and productive lives, free from avoidable disease and disability.10 Resource wars threaten people's ability to live full and productive lives; they also provide opportunities for public health workers to help prevent avoidable disease, disability, and death.