Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Focusing on hegemony diverts attention away from the economy

Jackson 2/12/22 {Van Jackson is a professor of international relations at Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand. Before entering academia, Van was a foreign policy practitioner, working as a strategist and policy adviser in the Office of the Secretary of Defense in the Obama administration Van Jackson, “The Threat to Economic Hegemony is Economic Hegemony: Part II”, Duck of Minerva, https://www.duckofminerva.com/2022/02/the-threat-to-economic-hegemony-is-economic-hegemony-part-ii.html //KS}

For one thing, I think the popular impression of America as the world’s economic hegemon is overstated. Yes, the United States has many economic advantages. Its domestic market is still the destination of choice for manufacturing exports. It has the world’s reserve currency (which means it enjoys the “exorbitant privilege” of running crazy deficits). It has veto rights at the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (which it shouldn’t have, but that’s a separate argument). And it has unique control over the “pipes” of the international financial system.

But in Asia — the world’s wealthiest and most populous region — China established economic centrality years ago. America’s economic throw-weight in Asia is far less than China’s, in part because of trade volume, but also because America’s large investments in Asia are not state-backed or centrally coordinated, which makes them somewhat un-leverageable. And US exclusion from Asia’s dense financial architecture makes it likely that things will continue trending in that direction. That means what’s going on is the economic equivalent of “uni-multipolarity” or “multi-multipolarity” — system level hegemony, perhaps, but regional level contested hierarchy for sure.

Nevertheless, pointing out that the United States isn’t as dominant as we think doesn’t answer the why-no-strategy question. It might be that the United States has a habit of overemphasizing the military as a tool of policy, which has diminished policymakers’ ability to think seriously about connections between security and political economy. As somebody who was a maker of strategy in the Obama era, I think there’s something to this.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.