Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The U.S. and China won’t fall into the Thucydides trap and will find a way to peacefully coexist

Jayathilaka 4/11/22 [11 Apr 2022, Jayathilaka, Aruna, Department of Social Sciences, Sabaragamuwa University of Sri Lanka, Lecturer in Political Science, “Are China and the USA Heading for a War ? (Can they Avoid the ''Thucydides Trap''?)”, SSRN, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4075526, AA]

Thucydides (460- 404 BC), finest of historical Greek historians and writer of the History of the Peloponnesian War, which recounts the war among Athens and Sparta within side the fifth century B.C. He was also named as the father of the school of political realism', which views the political behavior of people and the resulting effects of relations between states as ultimately mediated and based on "fear and self-interests'. As he explained, "It was the rise of Athens and the fear that this instilled in Sparta that made war inevitable." (Allison, 2015). Thucydides recognized key drivers of this dynamic: the growing power's developing entitlement, experience of its importance, and call for more say and sway, on the only hand, and the fear, insecurity, and resolution to protect the popularity quo this engenders within side the mounted power, at the other (Allison, 2017). 3.1 Graham Allison on the Thucydides’ Trap Graham Tillett Allison, an American political scientist and the Douglas Dillon Professor of Government at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, recognized Thucydides Trap as the best framework to understand why there is potential for conflict between the United States and China. (Allison, The Thucydides Trap, 2017) The Harvard Thucydides' Trap Project has identified sixteen cases over the last 500 years in which a major rising power threatened to dethrone a major ruling power.( Figure 01) Figure 01 : Thucydides’ Trap in the history Power struggle between China and USA Source : (Allison, 2015) Source: ( Harvard Kennedy School of Government, 2021) Twelve of these sixteen contenders resulted in warfare. Allison uses the cases to demonstrate how the tension between rising and ruling powers frequently leads to war and how the war was avoided in the four rivalries that did not result in violence. Allison views that China's attempt to challenge the US hegemony will create an avenue for a war. According to Allison, the Chinese government's action plan for achieving this goal includes: revitalizing the Party, restoring its sense of mission, and reestablishing its authority in the eyes of the Chinese people; reviving Chinese nationalism and patriotism to inculcate pride in being Chinese; engineering a third economic revolution, and reorganizing and rebuilding China's military so that it can 'fight and win.' (Allison, Avoiding the Thucydides Trap, 2018) In addition, Allison revives Samuel Huntington's classic thesis about the clash of civilizations. He argues that China's pursuit of its goals resulted from 'deep cultural' differences. (Table:01) Table 01 : 'Deep Cultural' differences between USA and China Source: (Allison, The Thucydides Trap, 2017) 04. Reponses on the ‘Thucydides Trap’ The concept of the "Thucydides Trap" and the debates around it have influenced academics, international media, including Chinese official media, and American and Chinese politicians. 4.1 Scholars views on ‘Thucydides Trap’ In comparison, international scholars are more diversified in the concept. There are generally three views; Pessimistic Views, optimistic, and Realistic Views. 4.1.1 Pessimistic Views The first view, mainly from Western and American scholars, is quite pessimistic. They believe that U.S.-China relations have fallen into or are about to enter the “Thucydides’ Trap.” For instance, in May 2015, American scholar David Lampton, who used to express much hope for a sound and lasting U.S.-China relationship, delivered a speech at the World Forum on China Studies, stating that “tipping point in U.S.-China relations is upon us. and that we are witnessing the erosion of some critical underlying supports for predominantly positive U.S.-China ties” (Lampton, 2015). Analysts and officials in Washington are fretting over “worsening tensions between the United States and China and the risks to the world of two superpowers once again clashing rather than cooperating”. (Michael Beckley and Hal Brands 2021). According to these analysis, a cold war with Beijing is already under way. Hence, it is not surprising that the Chinese continue to see the USA’s ‘hegemony,’ military presence, and alliances with others as major stumbling blocks for China’s attempts to maintain its sovereignty and territorial integrity (To, 2003) 4.1.2 Optimistic Views However, most Chinese analysts believe that the "Thucydides' Trap" cannot adequately characterize Sino-US ties. They have explored strategies for both countries to escape the trap by deconstructing the notion's flaws. Professor Qin Yaqing, for example, discovers that the Chinese philosophical paradigm of "Yin and Yang Dialectics" differs markedly from Western concepts of "conflict and confrontation." As a result, rather than viewing China's ascent as a zero-sum game, it should be seen holistically and historically. Professor Qian Shengdan stated unequivocally that the "Thucydides' Trap" was incompatible with historical events and may not apply to Sino-US relations. Several Western academics share this viewpoint. For example, Henry Kissinger claims no "Thucydides' Trap" between China and the US until individuals make it a "self-fulfilled prophecy" (Coker, 2015). In his essay "Beware the Thucydides Trap's Trap," James Holmes argues that the Sino-US relationship is fundamentally different from the Athenian-Spartan relationship and the Anglo-German alliance before World War I. Richard Lebow similarly disputes the inevitability of conflict between Athens and Sparta, arguing that the Peloponnesian War might have been averted if both sides had shown greater empathy and therefore taken a more moderate posture (Lebow, 2021). 4.1.3 Realistic Views Rather than agreeing or disagreeing with the concept, the third point of view is concerned with finding a replacement parallel to represent Sino-American ties. For example, Professor Yan Xuetong suggests that the battle between China and the United States is "more like a football game than a boxing fight," implying that it is not always a zero-sum game that ends in a knockout. Indeed, the term "new type of major-country relations" has become more widely used in recent years; despite their current trade disputes and increasingly intense competition, both China and the United States are aiming for a reciprocal relationship of "no conflict, no confrontation, mutual respect, and win-win cooperation." (Bondaz, 2015) 4.2 Responses of the Leaders As the "Thucydides' Trap" concept grows in popularity, it is frequently discussed by prominent Chinese and American leaders and officials. Both Chinese and American leaders are hopeful about their countries' ability to avoid the "Thucydides' Trap." China's President Xi Jinping declared in 2014 that "we all need to work together to avoid the 'Thucydides' Trap." In his address in Seattle on September 24, 2015, he said unequivocally that "[t]here is no such thing in the world as the so- called Thucydides' trap." However, if powerful countries repeatedly commit strategic miscalculation errors, they may build such traps for themselves." (Ling Shengli and Lv Huiyi, 2018) In response, then-US President Barack Obama stated in 2015 that he did not agree with the concept of "Thucydides' Trap" and its significance to US-China ties. Although President Trump has not said firmly if there is a "Thucydides' Trap" between China and the United States, he has often stated that both nations should preserve cooperation while managing their disagreements. President Trump stated at his meeting with President Xi at Mar-a-Lago in April 2017 that the US "is eager to further deepen cooperation with China in business, military issues, and people-to- people exchanges... ". He also stated, "[i]n the next months and years, I look forward to developing an even stronger partnership between our two nations, China and the United States of America, as well as even deeper friendships and interactions amongst our people. Clearly, neither the Chinese nor the American leaders believe their country will fall into the "Thucydides' Trap" (Ling Shengli and Lv Huiyi, 2018). Even though Chinses and American leaders have been shown an optimistic viewpoint on the Thucydides' Trap, some world leaders have shown a pessimistic view on it. President Lee Kuan Yew is a case in point. As he stated, “Unlike other emergent countries, China wants to be China and accepted as such, not as an honorary member of the West. The Chinese will want to share this century as co-equals with the United States.” ( Allison, Lee Kuan Yew: The Sage of Asia, 2015). Further he views that China “is the biggest player in the history of the world,” and the United States and others will have to adjust to this reality. But this adjustment may not be peaceful. (Richard N. Rosecrance and Steven E. Miller, 2014) 05. Pushing and Pulling Factors of the Thucydides Trap Analysts have warned that the South China Sea could be the tipping point for a military conflict between the two. As always, the USA is seeking military dominance and superiority in Asia- Pacific and elsewhere. Notably, while supporting the US-led war on terror for its reasons, China still criticized the USA for increasing its military presence across the world after the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 (Straits Times, 2002). It appears that the Trump administration is conscious of the unfavorable aspects of its foreign policy ("interventionism" and "unilateralism" in international politics), notably in the Middle East. However, the United States cannot alter the global system as China seeks to grow its strength and influence globally and reform the old liberal international order (Yahuda, 2019). Some analysists view that the military tension between US and China was declining under the Joe Biden administration. These analyses show that, after former President Donald Trump launched his trade war with China, indications are that President Joe Biden’s administration is continuing his confrontational approach to the bilateral relationship while rallying Western and regional allies around calling out Beijing for its flouting of international norms (Yang X. , 2021). Nevertheless, agreements as, AUKUS will enhance the war tension between US and China while providing a fertile ground for a ‘Thucydides Trap’. On September 15, 2021, Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States signed AUKUS, a trilateral security treaty for the Indo-Pacific region. According to the deal's provisions, the United States and the United Kingdom will assist Australia in deploying nuclear-powered submarines (Biscop, 2021). Cooperation in "cyber capabilities, artificial intelligence, quantum technologies, and more subsea capabilities" is also included in the pact. Australia's air force, navy, and army would all gain enhanced long-range attack capabilities as part of the arrangement. Instead of the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing cooperation, which includes New Zealand and Canada, the alliance will focus on military capability (Oxford Analytica, 2021). China has criticized the new agreement as "extremely irresponsible." Zhao Lijian, a foreign ministry spokesman, stated that this agreement "seriously undermines regional peace and stability and intensifies the arms race." In Washington, the Chinese embassy accused the countries entering this agreement of having a "Cold War mentality and ideological prejudice" (BBC, 2021). Nevertheless, some analysts argue that neither China nor the United States intends to reorder the world by winning a decisive war. Because they both know that a confrontation of this magnitude might be disastrous, they are attempting to win without fighting, relying on international laws and rule-making to confine their opponents and mold the world in their favor. Unlike previous great power competitions, the United States and China are competing over the content of international laws. As a result, both camps will rely on "new global norms and agreements” (Scott, 2021) 5.1 Is the Thucydides Trap a replacement of Churchill Trap? Winston Churchill made his now famous "Iron Curtain" speech at Westminster College, Fulton, March 5, 1946, an event that many have seen as the symbolic inauguration of the Cold War. (Kluge, 2003). The term “iron curtain” had been employed as a metaphor since the 19th century, but Churchill used it to refer specifically to the political, military, and ideological barrier created by the U.S.S.R. following World War II to prevent open contact between itself and its dependent eastern and central European allies on the one hand and the West and other noncommunist regions on the other (Trust, 2021). US diplomat George Kennan came to a similar conclusion and became the architect of the “containment” policy. He argued that the Soviet Union was determined to spread of communism throughout the world and was fundamentally opposed to coexistence with the West. Kennan doubted the potential effectiveness of attempts to reconcile and pacify the Soviet Union, but Kennan was confident that the Soviet Union would understand the logic of military power and temper its ambitions in the face of strong Western opposition (George Frost Kennan and John Lukacs, 1997). According to some experts, the' Thucydides trap exaggerates the possibility of war between emerging and dominant powers in the modern era. The most significant difficulty for China and the United States, according to this viewpoint, is to avoid falling into the 'Churchill trap.' By repeating the follies of the Cold War between the US and the Soviet Union, both camps will be involved in a long-term struggle. The 'old' history of the ancient East Asian bipolar system, as well as modern Sino-US interactions in East Asia, suggest that, in addition to hegemonic war and the cold war, the two poles have a 'third type of great power relationship.' This third kind is known as 'co-ruling .' The two superpowers jointly lead most small and medium-sized states rather than being geographically divided according to their separate domains of influence. (Yang Y. , 2018). 06. Is there a Way Out? According to Graham Allison, there are some possible avenues for both the China and USA to avoid possible war-tension. Firstly both the camps should realize that the 'War between nuclear superpowers is madness'. Both China and the USA own robust nuclear arsenal; hence leaders must recognize that war would be suicidal. The second lesson for both parties is to 'Leaders must be prepared to risk a war they cannot win'. It is clear that if war occurs, both nations lose, and millions die — an option no rational leader could choose. (Allison, The Thucydides Trap, 2017). Nevertheless, if a nation is unwilling to risk war, its opponent can win any objective by forcing the more reliable power to yield. Consequently, leaders must be willing to select paths that threaten destruction. The third lesson defines the new "precarious rules of the status quo." These rules include arms- control treaties and precise road conventions for air and sea. The fourth lesson is that parties should understand that 'Domestic performance is decisive.' Domestic issues of a country will have an impact upon international matters. (Allison, The Thucydides Trap: Are the U.S. and China Headed for War?, 2015). By establishing compromises on problematic areas, the US and China might clear the way for cooperation on challenges like global terrorism and climate change, where the two countries' shared national interests outnumber their differences. Overall, leaders must recognize that their existence is contingent on prudence, communication, limitations, compromise, and cooperation. As Allison points out, dwindling civic involvement, institutionalized corruption, and a general lack of faith in politics are all concerning indicators of the American democracy. Both countries' leaders would do well to emphasize their domestic issues by improving residents' quality of life. Finally, parties need to understand that hope is not a strategy. Allison views that if the USA hopes to avoid catastrophic war with China while protecting and advancing American national interests, lessons of the Cold War should be well studied. Both the camps need to be aligned with strategic thinking rather than relying on hope. (Allison, Avoiding the Thucydides Trap, 2018) Most of the scholars view that, a new structure for the bilateral relationship is required, taking into account key areas of rivalry and collaboration. Harvard Professor Joe Nye expressed hope that the United States will have enough time to handle China's ascent without falling into the second element of the trap: overreaching out of fear (Coker, 2015). According to Allison, the US and China have significant national interests in preserving the survival of their respective countries and must work together to resolve concerns that have clouded the economic relationship. This means coming up with new laws to account for China's unparalleled economic growth and global power status. In addition, policymakers should consider the appeal for a world that is "safe for variety" followed by the ' Cuban Missile Crisis '. This development would allow countries with diverse political systems, economic development methods, and philosophies to peacefully coexist (Allison, Avoiding the Thucydides Trap, 2018). 07. Summarizing the Findings The first research question of the paper was: 'is the 'Thucydides Trap' a correct metaphor to examine the present global power structure?' The study finds diverse viewpoints on the validity of the 'Thucydides Trap' for a proper analysis of the US-China relationship. The 'Pessimistic' scholars recognize Thucydides Trap as an accurate metaphor for analyzing the present tension between USA and China. Nevertheless, 'Pessimistic' and 'realistic' scholars have not identified 'Thucydides Trap' as an ideal metaphor to examine the current development between USA and China. According to some analysts, other metaphors are more suitable to elaborate US-China relations than the 'Thucydides trap.' For an intense some analysts' view that the 'Churchill trap' is a more present risk to China and the US than the 'Thucydides trap,' and consequently one to which both should pay due to heed and take precautions to avoid (Yang Y. , 2018). Nevertheless, Graham Alison provides a strong argument for using the 'Thucydides Trap' to explain several scholars later admitted US-China relations and this notion. Consequently, the paper finds that the Thucydides trap provides an avenue to examine the current development between the USA and China with data analysis. The second research question was: 'Can China and USA escape the Thucydides Trap?’. Avoiding the trap might be difficult indeed, yet not impossible. As being describe by Graham Alison, 'Thucydides Trap' can be avoided with huge and painful adjustments by the super powers. Hence, 'pessimistic' and 'realistic' scholars have shown some of the avenue for avoiding the trap. Further, as being states by the 'Thucydides Trap', when Sparta attacked Athens, it forced the other Greek city-states to pick a side, and a massive Greek war ensued that lasted for decades. Great power dynamics may undoubtedly cause tensions, but the judgment is still on whether a 'conflict in Asia is unavoidable'. Smaller states play disproportionate roles at times, but not always. For example, during the conflict, Athens subdued Melos, a city-state that had wanted to remain neutral in the Peloponnesian War. Based on these findings, it is clear that the 'Thucydides Trap' is not an ‘unavoidable' circumstance. Graham Allison suggests that the main five lessons that both superpowers should learn to avoid the trap are: 'realizing the destructiveness of nuclear superpower war', 'preparing to risk a war they cannot win', defining the new "precarious rules of the status quo", realizing that 'domestic performance is decisive', and understanding that hope is not a strategy. Most other scholars also suggest that drastic changes should be made by both the camp to escape from the trap. Hence, 'the USA and China need to make serious adjustments to avoid the trap'. 08. Conclusion War, as Thucydides explains, is preventable. Since individuals can do little to address power imbalances, the only obstacle they face is poor decision making. So suppose war can be prevented. In this case, it implies that in making decisions, individuals, leaders, and people avoid interpersonal interactions creating the "real trap" that the ancient thinker warned us. As for the future of Sino- American relations, no one knows precisely. However, we can predict the future based on the current development of the two great powers. The United States has used hard power in several world crises. However, China has only used soft power at the most critical moments. This trend reduces the risk of war between the two countries. To deal with China's ascent, it appears the United States will employ a mix of commitment and containment. Similarly, a military clash with the United States will negatively impact China's economic progress. But, on the other hand, limitations and flaws in China's regional accent, notably its rising reliance on Middle Eastern oil, will push Beijing to stick to its "peaceful development" approach. All in all, in a bipolar system, the United States and China will find a way to coexist, thus avoiding the 'Thucydides trap.'

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.