Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Layne was right—US primacy failing new strategy is necessary

Nye 12 [Joseph S., "Twenty-First Century Will Not Be a “Post-American” World", OUP Academic, https://academic.oup.com/isq/article/56/1/215/1940537?login=true// KS]

Where I suspect that Layne and I might agree is on the need for a new American strategy in a world marked by “the rise of the rest.” We should learn from the prudence of Dwight Eisenhower. The number-one power does not have to man every boundary and be strong everywhere. The attempt to do so would violate Ike's prudence in resisting direct intervention on the side of the French in Vietnam in 1954. Also relevant today is Ike's conviction that it is essential to preserve the strength of the American economy to undergird our military strength. Applied to today's world, an Ike-like strategy would avoid involvement of ground forces in major wars on the Asian continent, even if there was not a fiscal deficit. Counterinsurgency is attractive as a military doctrine in the way that it pays careful attention to the tactical balancing of hard and soft power, but in a strategic sense, it should not lead us into imperial occupation of weak states and “nation building” in places that are beyond our limits. The maxim of avoiding major land wars in Asia or other poor countries does not mean withdrawing a forward military presence from places like Japan and Korea, or ending military assistance of various types to countries like Pakistan or Egypt. Some analysts call this a strategy of “off-shore balancing,” but that term must mean more than just naval and air force activity. An American land presence that is welcome and supported by allies should not be ruled out by a slogan. Eisenhower also understood the limits of what is possible in terms of American domestic institutions and public attitudes. The British historian Niall Ferguson, an enthusiast for empire, lamented at the time of the Iraq War that the United States lacked the capacity for empire because of three domestic deficits: manpower (not enough boots on the ground); attention (not enough public support for long-term occupation); and financial (not enough savings and not enough taxation relative to public expenditure). He was correct. A stomach for empire or colonial occupation is one of the important ways in which American political culture differs from that of imperial Britain. Whether worthy of applause or lament, such are our domestic limits. At the same time, universalistic values are also in the nature of our political culture, but we often promote these values best by being what Ronald Reagan called “a shining city on a hill.” The global information age of the twenty-first century will be different from the past century and will require a better strategy than America used in the past decade, but it will not be a “post-American world.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.