Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cybersecurity involves market-based approaches

Ebrahim 20 [Tabrez Y. Ebrahim is an Associate Professor of Law, California Western School of Law; Visiting Associate Professor, University of California, San Diego; Ostrom Visiting Scholar (Program on Data Management and Information Governance) & Affiliate (Program on Cybersecurity and Internet Governance), Indiana University (Bloomington); Visiting Fellow, University of Nebraska (Lincoln): Nebraska Governance & Technology Center; Thomas Edison Innovation Fellow & Leonardo da Vinci Fellow, George Mason University Antonin Scalia Law School;ARTICLE: NATIONAL CYBERSECURITY INNOVATION. West Virginia Law Review, 123, 483. https://advance-lexis-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/api/document?collection=analytical-materials&id=urn:contentItem:61X5-YX61-JX8W-M4YS-00000-00&context=1516831.]//LP

National cybersecurity involves tradeoffs with government intervention and market-based incentives for technological innovation, and theoretical reformulation of innovation mechanisms towards this lens is the subject of this Article. The patent system has been considered as supporting the establishment of a market of new technologies by providing incentives for invention, promoting the financing of innovation, and stimulating competition through exclusion. As such, while the patent system is a government-driven mechanism, the market foundation role of patents supports the market development of new technologies. [*488] The parsing out of the government's need to provide national cybersecurity versus the private market in being able to provide national cybersecurity raises the question as to whether the patent system provides sufficient incentives for national cybersecurity innovation. A variety of innovation mechanisms could promote national cybersecurity innovation, and a comparison of the role of government and the market presents innovation policy considerations for society. Implicit in this analysis is that the patent system has some role in technological advancement for national cybersecurity. However, inventors and patent holders lack inadequate incentives from the patent system for national cybersecurity inventions, for which the guarantee of the reward is too small, the possibility of the reward is uncertain, or the transaction cost is too high. As a result, the patent system is inadequate to promote national cybersecurity innovation. Such limitations may push some national cybersecurity innovators towards trade secrecy, which presents a different set of problems, including whether and how they can help foster technological advancement to protect the critical infrastructure. The purpose of this Article is to assess how important the patent system is to national cybersecurity. If one unequivocal conclusion follows from this Article in addressing this tradeoff for achieving national cybersecurity, it is that patents may not be a good match when their disclosure is kept secret or when their interests can be taken by government, and technological innovation for critical infrastructure protection can be better oriented through prize funding or a better way to encourage public-private research and development ("R&D"). Innovation mechanisms for technological advancement present unique challenges for national cybersecurity, including market failure, government failure, and co-mingled public-private infrastructure elements. At a theoretical economic level, inventors and innovators will not make investments in national cybersecurity R&D and individuals hope to reap its benefits without contribution to its technology development - a conundrum that warrants government intervention. 17Link to the text of the note

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.