Cybersecurity requires opinio juris and governmental processes
Shackelford et al 16 [Scott J. Shackelford is the Assistant Professor of Business Law and Ethics, Indiana University; Senior Fellow, Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research; W. Glenn Campbell and Rita Ricardo-Campbell National Fellow, Stanford University Hoover Institution. Scott Russell is a Post-Graduate Fellow, Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research, Indiana University. Andreas Kuehn is the Zukerman Cybersecurity Predoctoral Fellow, Center for International Security and Cooperation, Stanford University; PhD Candidate School of Information Studies, Syracuse University. An earlier form of this article was published as Defining Cybersecurity Due Diligence Under International Law: Lessons from the Private Sector, in ETHICS AND POLICIES FOR CYBER WARFARE (Maria Rosaria Taddeo ed., 2016). We would like to thank Springer Nature for allowing the republication and expansion of this chapter as an article for the present volume. https://advance-lexis-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/document/?pdmfid=1516831&crid=e47f4f66-6c70-48c4-9602-c14f3a18937d&pddocfullpath=%2Fshared%2Fdocument%2Fanalytical-materials%2Furn%3AcontentItem%3A5KG5-HR00-00SW-413V-00000-00&pdcontentcomponentid=237721&pdteaserkey=sr4&pditab=allpods&ecomp=rz2yk&earg=sr4&prid=94d3703c-3bc6-4a1c-8516-5ccfa8a69fd6]//LP
A. An Introduction to Customary International Cybersecurity Law One precedent informing customary international cybersecurity law was articulated by the ICJ in the Nicaragua v. United States case (Nicaragua), which involved a dispute over the United States' involvement with the Contra rebellion in Nicaragua. 11Link to the text of the note In Nicaragua, the ICJ held that customary international obligations would arise from the consistent, widespread practice of States engaging in specific acts or omissions, performed out of a sense of obligation that such acts or omissions were required by international law (opinio juris). The combination of opinio juris and State practice performed by a significant number of States and without the express disavowal of a significant number of other States, gives rise to international obligations under customary international law. The underlying rationale is that this combination reflects a consensus in the international community that the actions taken represent an international obligation. Despite Nicaragua's clear articulation of the rule, in practice, the development of customary international law presents a temporal dilemma. For a State to engage in actions out of a sense of legal duty, this decision presupposes the existence of such a duty, and therefore the prior existence of customary international law on a certain issue. 14Link to the text of the note To help resolve this dilemma, Professor Frederic Kirgis argued for what he calls a "sliding scale" approach. 15Link to the text of the note Professor Kirgis argues State practice and opinio juris need to be understood on a spectrum, wherein the requirement for opinio juris increases as the evidence of State practice decreases. Rather than [*6] impose strict requirements for both State practice and opinio juris, the sliding scale approach argues that a strong history of State practice can give rise to international obligations absent opinio juris. 16Link to the text of the note Likewise, compelling opinio juris could give rise to international obligations with little evidence of State practice. 17Link to the text of the note The sliding scale approach may prove particularly important in the cybersecurity realm as these novel technologies have developed too rapidly for evidence of widespread State practice to emerge, yet compelling opinio juris may still form the basis for international obligations. Proving opinio juris, however, is a difficult task, especially in the cyber context. The temporal dilemma makes pointing to existing rules challenging, so the preferred method is to identify broad principles that enjoy widespread international agreement, which the ICJ suggests may be evidenced by treaties. 18Link to the text of the note Indeed, most courts rely on treaties to identify opinio juris, often exclusively so. 19Link to the text of the note Yet in the cyber realm, treaties have largely focused on implementing domestic cybercrime laws and have done relatively little to address cybersecurity standards, leaving such decisions to the private sector and standards bodies such as the NIST Framework, discussed below. 20Link to the text of the note So using cybercrime as an example, international agreements like the Budapest Convention, the African Union Convention on Cybersecurity and Data Protection, and the various Association of Southeast Asian Nations working groups on cybercrime all could serve as opinio juris that States have an obligation to enact and enforce cybercrime laws within their territories and to cooperate to prosecute and extradite cybercriminals. Even though these agreements often lack binding language, they nonetheless suggest a growing international consensus that the establishment of domestic cybercrime laws is an international obligation. 21Link to the text of the note Similarly, the Organization of American States has also encouraged Member States to join the Budapest Convention and to increase regional cooperation to mitigate cybercrime, whereas a nonbinding U.N. General Assembly Resolution calls on States to "eliminate safe havens" for cybercriminals. 22Link to the text of the note Declarations like [*7] these, although non-binding, serve as further evidence of international consensus regarding cybercrime. While it is unlikely that a non-signatory State would be bound to the specific terms of a treaty to which it did not sign--particularly in the short term--that treaty may still serve to identify broad principles that form opinio juris and thereby can build a foundation for international obligations. The search for cybersecurity opinio juris is further complicated by the multifaceted cyber threat comprising cybercrime, espionage, terrorism, and war. While the classification of State cyber-activities is a well-known problem, 23Link to the text of the note the fact that these activities are so widespread suggests a lack of opinio juris against aggressive State cyber-activity below the armed-attack threshold. The ambiguity surrounding State cyber-activities is further reinforced by discussions of the international law relating to espionage, which is largely unregulated outside the law of war context. 24Link to the text of the note Similarly, domestic cybersecurity practices are highly variable and can involve the surreptitious installation of malware--as alleged of Chinese telecommunications providers and the National Security Agency (NSA) alike--discussed further below. 25Link to the text of the note Given the relative lack of multilateral progress, claiming a widespread consensus for an underlying cybersecurity norm is challenging: a situation that can only be marginally mitigated by investigating related ICJ jurisprudence on the subject. B. ICJ Jurisprudence as It Relates to Cybersecurity Due Diligence Although the ICJ has never directly addressed cybersecurity due diligence requirements, its cases discussing due diligence generally can serve as broad guideposts to infer cyber-specific applications. It is worth noting that these cases all arose prior to the proliferation of cyber attacks, but some of the principles that underlay the cases, including Corfu Channel, Trail Smelter, and Nicaragua, may still have some applicability. 26Link to the text of the note Before reviewing these cases though, it is first important to define "cybersecurity due diligence." In the transactional context, this term has [*8] been defined as '"the review of the governance, processes and controls that are used to secure information assets."' 27Link to the text of the note The concept as it is used in this Article builds from this definition and may be understood as the customary national and international obligations of both State and non-State actors to help identify and instill cybersecurity best practices and effective governance mechanisms so as to promote cyber peace through enhancing the security of computers, networks, and Information and Communications Technology (ICT) infrastructure. Cybersecurity due diligence obligations may exist between States, between non-State actors (for example, private corporations, end-users), and between State and non-State actors. Applicable instruments include technical standards, legal requirements born from treaty or custom, as well as national policies and private-sector industry norms, discussed below. 28Link to the text of the note We will proceed by highlighting three international obligations identified by the ICJ: the duty to warn, the "no harm" principle, and non-intervention, which we will use to infer cyber-specific applications and identify potential problems. We will then go on to address the law governing countermeasures for when an international obligation is violated, address its applicability to cyber-operations, and consider the implications for cyber due diligence.