Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No alt causes. Russia’s diverse array of tactics magnifies the internal link.

Herbert Lin 19, senior research scholar for cyber policy and security at the Center for International Security and Cooperation and Hank J. Holland Fellow in Cyber Policy and Security at the Hoover Institution, both at Stanford University, June 2019, “The existential threat from cyber-enabled information warfare,” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, Vol. 75, No. 4, p. 187-196 //chico

At the same time, advances in information technology have a dark side. The same increases in the volume and velocity of information have created a louder and more chaotic information environment that stimulates fast, angry, reflexive, intuitive, and visceral thinking, reaction, and action in people and thus displaces more complex, reflective, and rational thought. In a chaotic environment of information overload, people are more likely to use mental shortcuts as a way to reduce the cognitive bur- den that such an environment places on their thinking.

In recent years, we have seen how the Internet, social media, and mobile devices (and other technologies) can be used by foreign adversaries to interfere in elections and to disrupt the democratic process. We have seen:

Social media exploitation of cognitive biases to increase their impact and reach – short messages of 280 characters and emotionally evocative video/ audio clips are nearly ubiquitous and much more the norm than they ever were two decades ago.

Disintermediation of established information sources that reduces the role and influence of those pre- viously responsible for providing factual information and proliferates information sources. The US Supreme Court noted in Associated Press v. US (1945) that “the widest possible dissemination of information from diverse and antagonistic sources is essential to the welfare of the public, that a free press is a condition of a free society.” Today, modern information technol- ogy has enabled the creation of a larger number of information sources than the 1945 US Supreme Court could possibly have imagined.

Search engines that return highly visible results for queries based in large part on the popularity of those results and the inferred desires of the user for specific information rather than their actual importance to those queries. Such functionality also makes it easier than ever for people to find information online “by doing their own research,” thus indulging in their confirmation biases by selectively finding and attend- ing only to information that confirms one’s beliefs. Search engine optimization techniques enable gam- ing of search algorithms to promote the visibility of false, misleading, or worthless information.

Many-to-many connectivity that enables the for- mation of echo chambers and media bubbles that reinforce pre-existing beliefs.

Large-scale data mining that allows adversaries to sift huge amounts of personal data on individuals to identify and target those most susceptible to customized, inflammatory, false, malign, or mis- leading messages – and also to keep such mes- sages away from public view.

Near-immediate data transfer, which enables pro- paganda and other malign information to spread far and wide quickly, while efforts to correct false information are more expensive, often fall short, and frequently fail altogether.

Inauthentic voices that are largely indistinguishable from authentic ones. Macedonian entrepreneurs dis- covered ways to monetize an affinity of Trump voters for fake news (Subramanian 2017). Paid human employees of the Internet Research Agency created and spread false information on behalf of the Russian government prior to the 2016 U.S. election (MacFarquhar 2018). And automated “bots”–accounts purportedly associated with human users but in fact managed entirely or mostly by machines – add further chaos to the information environment.

Is this state of information affairs really new? Haven’t adversaries of all stripes always employed propaganda and lies – otherwise known as information warfare (or at least a big part of it) – to advance their interests?

Yes. Information warfare indeed has a long pedigree that reaches into the past for at least the three millen- nia since the Trojan Horse enabled Greek warriors to breach the walls around the city of Troy. Much more recently, the rise of the Nazi regime in Germany relied on propaganda. As Hitler (1925, 155–56) wrote:

[I]ts purpose must be ... to attract the attention of the masses and not by any means to dispense individual instructions to those who already have an educated opi- nion on things or who wish to form such an opinion on grounds of objective study – because that is not the pur- pose of propaganda, it must appeal to the feelings of the public rather than to their reasoning powers. . . . The art of propaganda consists precisely in being able to awaken the imagination of the public through an appeal to their feel- ings, in finding the appropriate psychological form that will arrest the attention and appeal to the hearts of the national masses. ... The receptive powers of the masses are very restricted, and their understanding is feeble.

But more so today than at any earlier point in human history, human beings are vulnerable to information war- fare. At the same time that new information technologies have led to an increase in the volume and velocity of information available on Earth by many orders of magni- tude in the past few decades, the cognitive architecture of the human mind is more or less unchanged on the time scale of centuries or even millennia.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.