Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Military cooperation with NATO is key---resources and expertise.

Glenn Alexander Crowther 17, Senior Fellow with the Transatlantic Defense and Security Program at the Center for European Policy Analysis, “The Cyber Domain,” The Cyber Defense Review, Vol. 2, No. 3, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26267386.pdf, cy

In addition to the Three Warfares, China has made advances in conceptualizing “strategic information war”. This concept “refers to the use of information and information technology in the political, economic, (science & technology), diplomatic, cultural, and military arenas to secure information advantage. In this broad sense, information war spans military and civilian spheres, peacetime and wartime, and has a global nature.” [35]  Although there are a variety of names for the Russian approach, the most accurate appears to be “new generation warfare” which “is manifested in five component elements: political subversion, proxy sanctuary, intervention, coercive deterrence and negotiated manipulation.” [36] Together these two approaches provide a significant threat to the United States, NATO Allies and like-minded partners around the world. This means that we all need to be competing in the information space. Information competition is so important that the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff recently designated “information” to be a joint function, co-equal with the existing joint functions of command and control, intelligence, fires, movement and maneuver, protection, and sustainment. [37]

The military has five functions that partially exist in the information environment and seven that exist entirely within the environment: Information Operations (IO), Military Deception, Psychological Operations (PSYOPs, also known as Military Information Support Operations or MISO), Public Affairs, and Strategic Communications are entirely within the environment. Communications & Signals, Cyber, Electronic Warfare (EW), Intelligence, Space operations and Operations Security (OPSEC) exist partially within. Physical operations also have an information effect, as when a US Army unit goes to a firing range in eastern Poland. All of these functions are legitimate military operations within cyberspace.

Conventional information operations are the age-old arts of persuasion. They are sometimes called propaganda (if your opponents are performing the operations), educational material (if your side is doing it) or even advertising via printed text, radio waves or television. Since tribes formed before history was captured, human beings have shaped the cognition of other human beings, both in the ‘in group’ and the ‘out group.’ Even though operations in the information environment have been central to civilization from the beginning, these operations expanded dramatically with the communications revolution inherent in the advent of the telegraph in the 1800s and accelerated with the further evolutionary additions of radio and television.

A new category of operations in the information environment is cyber-enabled information operations, which began with the arrival of the Internet. This takes the form of a traditional operation which uses cyber to magnify the Impact of the operation or to enable the operation itself. The hack of the Democratic National Committee would be an example of a cyber-enabled information operation. The information was obtained through cyber operations (the enabling function) but released via Wikileaks and thence to mainstream media outlets, a more traditional method of disseminating information.

Cyber information operations are a relatively new set of information operations that takes place entirely in cyberspace. An example would include Daesh recruiting videos. Videos are smoothly produced in a variety of languages and are aimed at global youth. As their target audience are digital natives, Daesh builds their products to be consumed as they do other digital materials. [38]

Countering these types of operations requires that the same techniques be used. As the Carter Center says, “The implementation of preventative community-based policies will equip trusted Islamic scholars and religious leaders with the necessary analysis and digital tools” [39] meaning that people hoping to counter them must use digital techniques to compete. This makes operations in the information environment a key cyber mission for militaries.

Military Operations and Cyberspace

Military operations can also be cyber-enabled or executed purely in cyberspace. This analytic framework discusses two types of military operations: conventional and special operations.

[figure 5 omitted]

Cyber can either enable an operation or can be the operation itself. As such, there are cyber-enabled conventional operations, cyber-enabled special operations, conventional cyber operations and special cyber operations. Cyber-enabled conventional operations happen on a daily basis while almost all special operations (due to the availability of resources) are cyber-enabled. It is probably safe to assume that cyber conventional operations happen frequently and regularly. Cyber special operations, like their kinetic namesake, probably do not occur often.

An example of a conventional or normal military operation would be the invasion of Iraq. An example of a special operation would be the raid to eliminate Osama bin Laden. Although these operations occurred with a minimum of cyber enabling, as time goes on and cyber capabilities suffuse militaries, more and more of these operations will become cyber-enabled. Eventually, all conventional and special operations will become cyberenabled unless specific counter-cyber operations negate that advantage.

An example of a cyber-enabled conventional military operation would be Russian operations in Georgia in 2008. Although Russia previously conducted purely cyber operations against Estonia in 2007, Georgia was different in that Russia conducted cyber operations against targets in Georgia to affect Georgian command and control in support of conventional military operations on the ground and air. [40]

An example of a cyber-enabled special operation would be the Mumbai attacks of 2008. Planners used a Go-Pro camera and walked the route so everyone could see videos of their routes during their preparation for the operation. Planners used Google Earth during their planning process. The command and control element monitored Indian social media

and traditional media (such as radio and television) to track the response by Indian security forces and steered the attacking force away from reacting Indian forces, enabling the operation to continue much longer than expected. [41]

As mentioned, cyber military operations also come in two flavors: conventional and special operations. A conventional cyber operation would be like “dropping cyber bombs on Daesh”. Secretary of Defense Ash Carter explained at an event at US Northern Command that “We’re using these tools to deny the ability of ISIL leadership to command and finance their forces and control their populations; to identify and locate ISIL cyber actors; and to undermine the ability of ISIL recruiters to inspire or direct Homegrown Violent Extremists,” [42] Although the operations may be classified, mere classification would not be sufficient to label this a special operation. This is a conventional operation in that it does not require special techniques or unique modes of employment, and does not require a covert approach to the operation.

According to Joint Publication 3-05, Special Operations, these operations require: … unique modes of employment, tactics, techniques, procedures, and equipment. They are often conducted in hostile, denied, or politically and/or diplomatically sensitive environments, and are characterized by one or more of the following: time-sensitivity, clandestine or covert nature, low visibility, work with or through indigenous forces, greater requirements for regional orientation and cultural expertise, and a higher degree of risk…Special operations may differ from conventional operations in degree of strategic, physical, and political and/or diplomatic risk; operational techniques; modes of employment; and dependence on intelligence and indigenous assets. [43]

A cyber special operation would be the Stuxtnet attacks on Iran. It meets many of the criteria for a special operation as defined above. It required unique modes of employment, tactics, techniques, procedures, and equipment. It was conducted in a hostile, denied, or politically and/or diplomatically sensitive environments. It was a low visibility operation characterized by a clandestine or covert nature, as manifested by the fact that no one has yet proved who conducted the operation.

As militaries routinely conduct conventional and special operations, these types of operations involving cyberspace are appropriate for militaries to conduct. All operations will eventually be cyber-enabled while there will be more and distinct cyber operations.

CONCLUSION

Because cyberspace is so large, and so much cyber activity occurs in the private sector, militaries do not have any business operating in most of cyberspace. Although militaries should be able to range anywhere throughout cyberspace to complete appropriate missions, most cyber activity should not involve the military at all.

There are pressures for the military to become more involved in cyberspace. DoD leaders have thus far managed to avoid being dragged into additional areas, mainly by sticking to DoD’s three cyber missions: Defend DoD networks, systems, and information; Defend the U.S. homeland and U.S. national interests against cyberattacks of significant consequence; and Provide cyber support to military operational and contingency plans. These are legitimate cyber missions for any military. These have been clearly articulated by the U.S. military; however, other militaries probably have not thought this through as they are busy building their cyber forces.

As manifestations of these legitimate cyber missions, there are four areas in cyberspace that are appropriate for the military to operate in crime, intelligence, information operations and military operations. This article has provided examples of how the military would be involved in all four of these areas. Although military forces are involved in these areas, they are not involved in all operations in these areas (for instance, the Department of Justice handles most cybercrime) but are involved in these areas. This, then, is the circumscribed area that should be called the military cyber domain. Militaries and Alliances like NATO around the world would do well to conceptualize these missions as appropriate for military cyber forces, understand why they should not be performing cyber missions outside of these areas, and inform their political masters that expanding cyber operations away from those four missions risks frittering away cyber combat, which would put at risk the overall mission of the military, the defense of the nation. 

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.