Deliberative norms increase complexity of thinking which decreases dogma and increases self-reflexivity.
Jennstal 19 – Researcher in the Department of Government at Uppsala University focusing in deliberative theory and political participation. [Julia. “Deliberation and Complexity of Thinking. Using the Integrative Complexity Scale to Assess the Deliberative Quality of Minipublics.” Swiss Political Science Review, vol 25, issue 1, pgs. 64-83. Feb 06, 2019.]
Deliberative Conversational Norms and Complexity of Thinking
Deliberative democracy is supposed to be, at its core, inclusive, consequential and authentic (Dryzek 2009). While inclusiveness and consequentiality rely on design features and are critical in systemic approaches to deliberation, the authentic requirement refers to what takes place inside the ‘black box’ of deliberative conversations (Gerber et al. 2016). It denotes the quality of deliberative exchanges and is contingent on citizens’ actual adherence to, and internalisation of, deliberative norms in political exchanges (Rosenberg 2014).
Even though the specifics of the nature of deliberative conversations are still the subject of debate (Bächtiger et al. 2010), there is general agreement on the significance of reasoning and listening dimensions in deliberation (Black et al. 2010; Mansbridge et al. 2012; Morrell 2010; Steiner et al. 2004).
The reasoning dimension specifies how deliberative citizens should engage with the topic of discussion. Deliberative citizens are expected to state their claims and be ready to explain and justify them when asked to by other participants. But deliberation involves not only claim-stating but also encountering novel information and facts about the topic of debate, including fellow citizens’ standpoints and beliefs. Citizens are expected to carefully weigh and consider new information, even information and claims that contradict the own opinions. Through this process citizens improve their understanding of the issue and get new insights into competing opinions and perspectives. As a result, citizens’ preferences become updated and well informed, and citizens acquire a greater understanding of the complexity surrounding political issues, which in turn opens up for balanced and nuanced reasoning on the topic of debate (cf. Black et al. 2010; Steenbergen et al. 2003).
The listening dimension involves norms of interpersonal conduct. Citizens and politicians alike are supposed to engage in deliberative exchanges in a respectful manner characterised by listening, perspective taking and empathy (Goodin 2003; Morrell 2010). Deliberative listening goes beyond simply hearing the other (for instance, by being silent when others speak), as it demands a particular open-minded, responsive stance in discussions (Dobson 2012). Through listening, citizens develop a deeper understanding of others and learn to empathise with their experiences and situations, which stimulates them to recognise the complexity and multidimensionality of political and social issues (cf. Bohman 1996; Dryzek 2016).
Some scholars have already recognised the conceptual correspondence between deliberative conversational norms (involving reasoning and listening dimensions) and complexity of thinking in the way both theories ’attempt to capture the epistemic weight and quality of human thought and communication’ (Wyss et al. 2015: 641; see also Brundidge et al. 2014). When deliberative citizens constructively deal with the uncertain, tentative and contingent nature of political communication, without reverting to dogmatic, closed-minded and prejudicial thinking (reasoning), while continuously listening and being responsive to others (listening), they demonstrate complexity of thinking (Wyss et al. 2015). Thus, complexity of thinking is here claimed to be an underlying component in both reasoning and listening performances in deliberation.
The conceptual correspondence between the deliberative norms and complexity of thinking is relevant to deliberative scholars as the construct of complexity can be used to inform how to conceptualise and operationalise deliberative norms in a way that makes it empirically observable and measurable on an individual level of analysis.
Below, I present a more detailed description of the method of integrative complexity, which is a validated measurement of individuals’ complexity of thinking. This is followed by a discussion that seeks to establish why the IC approach is particularly promising when it comes to conceptualising and measuring deliberative quality.
Integrative Complexity Scale
Overall, the psychological construct of complexity of thinking draws on a cognitive theory of individuals’ (verbalised) information processing, reasoning skills and decision-making. Broadly defined, complexity of thinking is a cognitive style associated with ‘flexibility, high levels of information search, and tolerance of ambiguity, uncertainty, and lack of closure’ (Suedfeld 2010: 1670). There are various theories and instruments available to assess complexity of thinking, and the one preferred in this context is the theory of integrative complexity (IC).
IC assesses the constitution of individuals’ thought processes and belief systems, especially when dealing with information containing inconsistent, competing views. The IC measure is used to reflect two major components of cognition: differentiation and integration. These dimensions are building blocks, which means that differentiation must be in place before integration can emerge. Differentiation denotes the ability to recognise more than one legitimate point of view and/or relevant dimension of the topic of debate. Integration refers to the ability to identify and make sense of conceptual links, trade-offs and similarities among perspectives, and the ability to reconcile or incorporate the information within a higher-level system (Suedfeld et al. 2011).
A critical feature of IC is that it is intended to capture the underlying conceptual structure of positions rather than the actual content of statements. This means that the construct is valid neutral and ‘the coding system does not rest on assumptions concerning the logical, pragmatic or ethical superiority of any particular school of thought’ (Baker-Brown et al. 1992: 402-403). Another key feature of the IC is that it explicitly accounts for integration and not only differentiation, which is not the case with all measurements of complexity (Conway et al. 2014).
Another benefit of IC is that it encompasses a relatively broad understanding of complexity, recognising both its dialectic and elaborative forms (Conway et al. 2014). Dialectic complexity refers to a willingness to consider multiple views. Elaborative complexity recognises ‘several complex arguments in defense of a particular perspective’, involving elaboration of a specific viewpoint without additional information input (Conway et al. 2014: 605).1
Low integrative complexity is associated with salience of a single dimension or aspect of an issue in reasoning, and with a greater tendency towards stereotyping, prejudice, dogmatism, and closed-mindedness (Suedfeld 2010). High complexity, in contrast, connotes reasoning that adducts multiple perspectives, supported by the activation of higher-level principles that provide a normative structure to complex issues (Suedfeld 2010). It is associated with balanced and comprehensive evaluation of available information, reducing the risk of biases in promoting better judgment and decision outcomes (Gruenfeld and Hollingshead 1993).
In sum, IC measures individuals’ receptiveness to new information and alternative perspectives and the ability to incorporate these into their own reasoning. Given that the same type of cognitive processes are demanded of deliberative citizens, increases in citizens scores of complexity of thinking as a result of deliberation can serve as an indicator of deliberative norm compliance. It would be oversimplifying to try to connect the deliberative dimensions to either one of the two aspects of complexity (differentiation and integration) by saying, for instance, that reasoning corresponds to differentiation of perspectives or vice versa. What is assumed, however, is that high complexity involves both reasoning and listening dimensions. As such, IC can be used to draw inferences about citizens’ compliance with the listening and reasoning demands of deliberation (cf. Brundidge et al. 2014; Wyss et al. 2015) and thereby inferences can be made about the deliberative quality of political discussions.
Since IC denotes a particular mental stance, adopting IC as a measurement of deliberative quality also makes sense given recent suggestions that deliberation refers to a particular deliberative mindset or stance (Morrell 2010; Owen and Smith 2015). The idea of a deliberative stance gives increased attention to the listening dimension in the form of the ‘right’ kinds of attitudes, affects and cognitions as key to deliberation (Morrell 2010; Owen and Smith 2015), and there is a need to identify methods to assess the extent to which citizens cultivate a deliberative stance in political discussions.
What is more, the IC measure can potentially further the understanding of the formation of meta-consensus, i.e. the ability to attain inter-subjective understanding and agreement regarding the relevant issue dimensions irrespective of actual disagreement on preferred outcomes (Dryzek and Niemeyer 2006), which is claimed to be the outcome of successful deliberative conversations.
Next, I demonstrate how IC as a psychological construct contributes important insights regarding the question of how to cultivate deliberative norm compliance in political discussions.
Cultivating Deliberative Norms (and Complexity of Thinking)
Understanding what factors affect the cultivation of deliberative norm compliance in formal deliberative settings is vital as deliberative processes can be ‘seen as more or less deliberative depending on how deliberative norms are put into practice’ (Black et al. 2010: 325). Deliberation is commonly used as a vehicle for citizens to acquire basic political skills, to learn about political issues (Gastil 2004) and to develop reasoning abilities (Rosenberg 2014). This ‘transformative’ dimension is realised through citizens’ active engagement in conversations when they develop a distinctly deliberative way of reasoning about politics (Warren 1992), which I equate with improved complexity of reasoning. However, developing these capacities is far from automatic. It requires careful attendance to social, psychological and contextual factors thereby creating a supportive environment for the emergence of complex thinking.
Contextual Factors
A standardised feature of deliberative design that addresses these dynamics involves the use of facilitators to stimulate and encourage citizens to adopt a deliberative style of reasoning (Burkhalter et al. 2002). Most commonly, facilitators are given the prominent role of introducing participants to the deliberative norms at the beginning of processes (often by reading out loud rules of the discussion) and guiding participants throughout the interactions (e.g. Grönlund et al. 2010). In this way, facilitators take deliberative norms into practice and function as rule-setters and rule-keepers, ‘a kind of personification of discourse rules, whatever these rules are in the given case’ (Landwehr 2014: 77).
Nevertheless, given the demanding norms of deliberation, it is to be expected that deliberative processes will vary in effectiveness in inducing deliberative norms, resulting in greater levels of discordant dogmatic views and closed-mindedness. Some of this variation is likely attributable to the style of facilitation, where some forms of facilitation might even discourage deliberative transformation (and hence decrease complexity of thinking).
Styles of facilitation range from active to passive, and they also vary in terms of the degree to which the focus is on the specific task performance (reasoning) or on managing relationships (listening) (Mansbridge et al. 2006). All have particular strengths and weaknesses with respect to inducing norm compliance. However, evidence suggests that more active facilitators are preferable (Rosenberg 2014). Unless an active and balanced facilitation strategy is adopted –recognising the importance of both reasoning and listening dimensions –deliberation might give rise to intuitively desirable ‘side effects’ such as knowledge gain (Grönlund et al. 2010) or the halo effect of a ‘group hug’ (Curato et al. 2013) without necessarily strengthening the deliberative quality or participants’ complexity of thinking.
An active facilitator attending to the reasoning and listening demands is potentially better placed to help individuals overcome the tendency to hold on to prior commitments and evoke a sense of security and trust among participants. The assumption applied to the design of the case study cited below is that facilitator intervention must be ‘clearly substantial’ in order to accomplish the expected transformation of participants’ political reasoning (Rosenberg 2007).
Similarly to deliberative scholars concern about situational variables, research on integrative complexity has traditionally been concerned with contextual factors that affect individuals’ tendency to engage in complex reasoning (Gruenfeld 1995). In particular, IC has been discussed as an effect of being informed about an issue, the type of issue being discussed and expectations on participants in discussions. For example, studies on complexity have demonstrated that when subjects have made a prior commitment (by expressing a view on the topic) they are less likely to engage in complex reasoning (Krupnikov et al. 2007).2
Of particular relevance here are findings demonstrating how integrative complexity increases when individuals try to solve important problems – as is ideally the case for deliberation. Alternatively, where this ‘deliberation’ is interrupted – if the problem appears unsolvable, if a decision has already been made, or if there is a lack of resources to implement a solution – the situation reaches the level of ‘disruptive stress’, and decreasing integrative complexity is observed (Suedfeld et al. 2011).
These findings suggest careful attention to the deliberative context. Settings that might otherwise be deliberative can reproduce the aforementioned negative dynamics. Complex political issues might appear unsolvable, increasing levels of stress as dialogue pushes against time pressures and fatigue. Certain conditions might induce anxiety among citizens, such as when they are asked to remain open to the unfamiliar, uncomfortable and radically different (Bickford 1996; Morrell 2010). To enter into political discussions with a listening, open and pragmatic stance means that what takes place in the discussion has the potential to profoundly change, or even undermine, one's existing views, opinions and even identity (Beausoleil 2014). Consequently, there is a constant risk of backlash of deliberation when participants resort to stereotypical and prejudicial thinking and established scripts of mind because it ‘reduces the burden of understanding complex social environments’ (Lillis and Hayes 2007: 390). Reverting to defensiveness, bias and motivated reasoning tends to induce simplified reasoning for otherwise complex processes and events to maintain a sense of stability and security. Improving IC (thereby cultivating deliberative norm compliance) involves addressing these challenges, for example by providing enough time for discussion among participants and the use of experienced facilitators that can make the process smoother.