No spillover – Congressional exemptions circumvent AND Courts won’t oversee intel gathering procedures – OR, causes leaks – wrecks ISR capabilities to avoid compromising sources
Elizabeth Rindskopf-Parker & Pate 7, Bryan Pate, 2007, “Rethinking Judicial Oversight of Intelligence,” in Reforming Intelligence: Obstacles to Democratic Control and Effectiveness, https://www.academia.edu/13052951/Reforming_Intelligence, nihara
To function effectively, all democratic governments must subject their actions to open public debate, review, discussion, and response. These are the essential ingredients of oversight and accountability. Yet, to survive in an often hostile world, these same governments must also be able to collect, analyze, and use foreign and domestic intelligence—information of ongoing value only insofar as its methods of collection and secrecy can be maintained. This is the paradox of intelligence oversight: the need to achieve open review of secret materials and activities without destroying their value.
In the United States, there are many established mechanisms of oversight and accountability, both inside and outside the government. Under the U.S. Constitution, the three separate branches of the federal government—executive, legislative, and judiciary—share power through a system of checks and balances. Each has the obligation and authority to ensure that the other two branches perform their assigned functions appropriately. This tripartite division naturally encourages oversight and accountability between the branches. In addition, each arm of the government provides its own unique internal oversight. Within the executive branch, management reviews are conducted by numerous offices, each of which typically includes an inspector general and a general counsel to ensure that it is complying with the law.
Congressional oversight occurs through the appropriations process, congressional audits, and statutory reporting requirements. Judicial review of the legality of actions taken by the two political branches occurs frequently, with judgments rendered on a case-by-case basis. Outside the government, the actions of each branch are subjected to scrutiny by an independent and active press and are ultimately adjudged by the electorate through the democratic process.
Yet, for the national intelligence system, these traditional oversight mechanisms are an awkward fit. Perhaps this is part of the reason why, historically, oversight of intelligence has been uneven in its success. Often, the importance of maintaining secrecy to protect the sources and methods of the intelligence capabilities appears directly opposed to the effective functioning of the existing oversight structures. Moreover, the secrecy surrounding intelligence activities seems to limit the role of the press to reporting on periodic scandals—some real, some not. Some critics argue that the broader goals of oversight—the effectiveness of the overall intelligence system—are inadequately served by the current system.1
Secrecy concerns have also restricted the judiciary’s role in reviewing intelligence activities. For good reason, court procedures in a democracy do not easily accommodate secrecy. Uncomfortable with secret procedures, the judiciary has been reluctant to engage issues arising from intelligence activities, even when such matters are properly presented to them.2 There is an important corollary to the concerns of the judiciary: judicial openness is commonly seen by all branches of government as a threat to effective intelligence gathering. Thus, because revealing individual secret facts can threaten the underlying ‘‘sources and methods’’ by which substantial amounts of intelligence are produced, legislated exceptions to public legal review are common where intelligence information is involved. Most notable in this regard is the exception for foreign intelligence contained in the Freedom of Information Act—the primary statute providing accountability through citizen access to government information.3
In a few of the areas where intelligence issues inevitably come under the purview of the judiciary, Congress has stepped in to strike the balance between competing concerns. For example, to facilitate the adjudication of criminal trials that involve critical evidence that cannot be made publicly available, Congress has established the Classified Information Procedures Act (CIPA).4 CIPA is modeled on earlier protective orders fashioned by the judiciary to handle such problems and provides a procedure for the courts to follow in handling classified evidence during a public trial. It is the means Congress has chosen to achieve the dual objectives of protecting national security and ensuring defendants a fair trial.
Procedural provisions like CIPA, however, have not alleviated the fundamental impediment to greater judicial involvement in the review of intelligence activities: an overriding reluctance on the part of the judiciary to become involved with foreign affairs and national security concerns. Is this resistance inevitable and unavoidable? Or are there structures that exist now, or could be devised, that would allow greater oversight by the courts in the overall process of collecting, analyzing, and using intelligence?
These questions are particularly timely as terrorism places the national security structures under increasing pressure to respond in new ways both at home and abroad. With headlines exposing abused detainees, ‘‘torture memos,’’ race-based ‘‘no-fly lists,’’ and ‘‘illegal wiretapping,’’ it is evident that the traditional balance between national security and individual liberty is being challenged, making even more important the courts’ role in ensuring that responses to terrorism do not fundamentally degrade personal freedoms and liberties.What role should the courts have in intelligence oversight in a time of terrorism? Before considering this question, we will first review the origins of existing oversight structures; then we will examine the basis for the judiciary’s reluctance to participate in national security matters; and finally, we will consider one example of active judicial oversight that may presage future approaches, especially if terrorism continues to pose a credible threat beyond the foreseeable future.