Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Leaks wreck US democracy promotion efforts

Margaret B. Kwoka 14, Assistant Professor, University of Denver Sturm College of Law, “Leaking and Legitimacy,” SSRN Scholarly Paper, ID 2494375, Social Science Research Network, 09/10/2014, papers.ssrn.com, doi:10.2139/ssrn.2494375

The effect of most leaked information, however, is not nearly so clear as these extreme hypotheticals. Pozen recently argued that the government has deliberately chosen not to punish leakers because while individual leaks may be harmful to government interests, leaks as a whole are more beneficial than detrimental.92 A permissive attitude toward leaks allows the government to credibly “plant” information in the press, and promotes the public’s belief in the legitimacy of the government, compensating for an overbroad classification system.93 The focus of Pozen’s analysis, however, is the much more common, everyday leaks of higher-level government officials, and Pozen acknowledges that some leaks can be truly harmful.94 Citing Chelsea Manning’s disclosures to WikiLeaks as a “rare undeniable leak”95 of the unauthorized nature, Pozen concedes that even a permissive approach to leakiness “cannot tolerate the proliferation of internal dissenters who seek to impeach the entire secrecy and national security system.”96 Pozen’s account of the costs and benefits of leaking thus does not fully account for the deluge leak.

1. Past Harms

Are deluge leaks, then, the leaks that may cause so much harm that they cannot be tolerated? Certainly, government officials have been harsh in their condemnation of past deluge leaks. For example, highlevel officials declared that Assange, and his source of Afghanistan war documents (then unknown) “might already have on their hands the blood of some young soldier or that of an Afghan family,”97 ***FOOTNOTE BEGINS*** 97 Greg Jaffe & Joshua Partlow, Joint Chiefs Chairman Mullen: WikiLeaks Release Endangers Troops, Afghans, WASH. POST, July 30, 2010, at A4 (quoting the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff). President Obama also made early comments about WikiLeaks disclosures: “I’m concerned about disclosure of sensitive information from the battlefield that could potentially jeopardize individuals or operations.” Obama on WikiLeaks: ‘I’m Concerned,’ ABC NEWS (July 27, 2010), http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/ video/obama-wikileaks-im-concerned-11260389. ***FOOTNOTE ENDS*** that Manning’s leak of State Department cables “put at risk our diplomats, intelligence professionals and people around the world who come to the United States for assistance in promoting democracy and open government,”98 ***FOOTNOTE BEGINS*** 98 Key Reactions to Wikileaks Cables Revelations, BBC (Nov. 29, 2010, 5:28 PM), http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-11866220 (quoting a White House statement). U.S. Representative Peter Hoekstra, the senior Republican on the House Intelligence Committee, also stated that “[m]any other countries — allies and foes alike — are likely to ask ‘Can the United States be trusted? Can the United States keep a secret?’” Id. ***FOOTNOTE ENDS*** and that the records leaked by Snowden were “putting at risk our national security and some very vital ways that we are able to get intelligence that we need to secure the country.”99

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.