Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Military AI challenges CMR. Turns case. Civil-military relations are a pre-requisite to AI.

Burton and Soare 19 [Dr Joe Burton, New Zealand Institute for Security and Crime Science, University of Waikato, Dr Simona R. Soare, Institut d’Etudes Européennes, Université Saint Louis; "Understanding the Strategic Implications of the Weaponization of Artificial Intelligence"; 2019 11th International Conference on Cyber Conflict: Silent Battle, NATO CCD COE Publications; Published: 2019; Accessed: 6-23-2022; https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2019/06/Art_14_Understanding-the-Strategic-Implications.pdf; KL]

Politics in this respect will be integral to outcomes in the deployment of military AI across domains. Strategy has always been the use of force to achieve political objectives, but we assert that politics will shape how AI is used as much as being the goal of the deployment of AI. What AI will not be able to do for combined arms operations, or any other type of operation for that matter, any time in the near future, is lift the fog of war: the veil of uncertainty around the interests driving opponents’ actions. It will not alleviate the security dilemma and may complicate arms control and disarmament efforts as barriers to entry are lowered due to the acceleration of technological progress in the civilian sector.

5. STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS

The purpose of this article is not to provide definitive conclusions as to how AI will affect strategy. As Clausewitz often stressed, the unseen complexities involved in military affairs do not allow for clear answers.41 The purpose of this paper is rather to enhance understanding of different aspects of what policymakers and military officials will face as AI technologies are integrated into war and conflict. In that spirit, we see several considerations as paramount to current and future strategy and policy.

The first is the requirement for and the simultaneous challenge of greater military-civilian fusion. We recognize this as a tautology that has always been true. However, it seems clear that militaries will need to develop much closer cooperation with the private sector in the development and use of AI technology through ‘spin in’ effects. China has already recognized this, as detailed by Elsa Kania in a recent report, and is working to fuse military and state-owned enterprise efforts to enhance China’s AI capabilities and technologies.42 In this respect, the extent to which China has an inherent advantage over the US because of state control of private enterprise is likely to influence the emerging power struggle over AI. China certainly has some advantages, including a productive and innovative economic and industrial base, and the clear articulation of national strategies around AI, but the notion that direct control over industry confers an advantage should be questioned. Much of historical innovation in technology has been derived from research conducted in private enterprises and research labs, sometimes with government funding. China’s technological progress has also been driven, at least in part, by illegal appropriation of technologies and copyright theft, largely through cyber espionage. This has been amply documented.43 The latest research suggests that China faces significant challenges in developing technologies due to the exponential increase in the complexity of military technology and the difficulties involved in replication and imitation.44 In the US and Europe, conversely, the challenge will be to develop effective cooperation between the military and private sector in the development of AI, while managing concerns around ethics and privacy. Recent reports suggest that the US military is now more trusted to develop AI systems than some of the big tech companies such as Google and Facebook, reflecting recent controversies around social media being used as a platform for AI-enabled information warfare and data privacy breaches.45 However, it is our contention that technology must be jointly and collaboratively developed, and that military control of AI innovation will ultimately be counterproductive, largely because of the need to apply the technology across a wide range of societal activity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.